Jump to content
 
  • entries
    3
  • comments
    16
  • views
    2,643

Taking project forward (Rob M, Aber Uni)


Robert MacKinnon

423 views

Many thanks for the considerable amount of comment this first blog and post got, if you are reading from the blog and from ‘modelling musings and miscellaneous’ I will be talking here to commentators on both my blog and modelling. Another post later will deal with some critical thoughts on some of the conceptual issues that posters have highlighted, i.e what is modelling, but this post discusses in particular what I am going to be doing from here although I want to start this post with some issues that more recent posters have raised;

 

Principally this project was developed by myself, although initial ideas for a research project revolved around the emergence of Road Safety in Britain from the 1900’s to the present day, how road space has, since the 20th century been a focus of technologies, experiments and general governmental concern. In particular the model railway bit of my project emerged from a general lack within the Arts and Humanities and Social Sciences of attention to the hobbyist modelling community, which can be thought of of course as not only railway modellers but military/battlefield modellers and wargamers, ship, aircraft and car modellers, and these come under the idea of the ‘craft consumer’ and we can include many more things too including making and engaging with dollshouses, cooking, making clothes, decorating. I will be engaging with military/battlefield modellers and wargamers, ship, aircraft and car modellers over the course of my research if only to be able to develop some broader arguments. The conceptual framework of ‘model’ and ‘modelling’ emerged generally though the potential for a novel but important line of attack from which to explore these concepts and I will come onto what we can think of modelling is a bit later.

  • The project should not be seen as simply a means to an end for a qualification. Whilst the project may earn a qualification I would hope to build on this research throughout a potential academic career. I am viewing this project as the stepping stone to developing some research themes that have the potential to stay with me for the rest of my life.

  • This project as I highlighted in the previous post is taxpayer funded (and most good academic research is whether at my early career level or through mid and late career), there a various hoops to have to go through (quite rightly) to get it, including relevance and impact (often either one or both). I note some debate around relevance and that this project should not be funded by the taxpayer. I don’t want to get into hot water by commenting on this debate and this goes right through into government and indeed even with academia.

  • My first post was too long, as some commentators have suggested, and I have to agree with them. Furthermore it was not as grounded in practical substance as it should have been which would have also made some of the conceptual ideas a bit more clearer and thus accessible, as one commentator helpfully suggested I ought to place some forum discussion links that nicely fit with each of the conceptual themes that I am interested in i.e ‘space of the home’ ‘illusion’ etc. Others have suggested I edit the piece; I will have a go at doing this when I get the chance.

  • On a final point to this section, I have been very impressed by the response that my project has got and will try and reply to as many posters as I can.

 

 

For the Second part now I note comments by Weston Sunset and Coombe barton;

 

Weston Sunset

Now that Rob MacKinnon has launched his ideas on us, it'd be nice to get some feedback from him as to how he's going to further pursue his research.

 

Coombe barton

 

"What do you require from us immediately?"

I think we'd all like some guidance to see if we can help.

 

Whilst I have perhaps regrettably spewed everything out all at once, it is my intention to use my blog on the forum to talk about things that I will be writing about in my research and ask questions relating for instance to your own practice of the hobby. I intend to talk in more detail and less academically about some of the conceptual themes I highlighted in the first post as well as some that seem to emerge. I am currently sorting out interviews with modellers, I have already undertaken a 3hr one with a garden railway modeller. The current state of the research project is that at the moment modellers are contacting me and I am either visiting them or, in some cases, I am undertaking correspondence via e-mail with them. Indeed in some cases, for instance with the garden railway modeller I interviewed I will also be corresponding with him via e-mail to ask further questions that I had not thought about at the time or wanting to clarify things. Some modellers I am just corresponding with, principally through a questionnaire (c100 questions or so) which I am in the process of drawing up. If you are interested in taking part in the questionnaire then please e-mail me, at
I will have to give you an ethics form for you to look over first and sign (electronically) which basically details what I will and will not do with the research (i.e kept anonymous in all discussions about the research and will not be given to 3
rd
parties). After looking through the response from the questionnaire I will ask further probing questions to the respondents whether through another formal questionnaire or just through e-mail. I will also, as I highlighted in the original piece be seeking to go to some model railway exhibitions within the Wales and West Midland’s areas. Several or so modellers have got back to me and have invited me to attend some of their club shows which will be a great experience. I will also be in contact with manufacturers either formally through interview/questionnaire or informally at trade fares.

 

So, as to Weston Sunset’s point that;

Now that Rob MacKinnon has launched his ideas on us, it'd be nice to get some feedback from him as to how he's going to further pursue his research.

 

I hope to have answered this, I also hope I have been able to answer

Coombe Barton’s point that

 

"What do you require from us immediately?"

I think we'd all like some guidance to see if we can help.

 

A number of modellers who have got into contact with me have been very helpful and have offered to critique my first post. I understand there are some problems with it as posters have here highlighted and people have e-mailed me too about this. Despite these problems over length and legibility I would welcome modellers to contact me at
and I will send over a word document of the first post where I very much welcome modellers to suggest different angles, ideas, links and so on and very welcome to include your own ideas and knowledges and practices about these matters, particularly in the research themes section although for those of you are interested in participating via questionnaires some of this will emerge there instead so you don’t have to do this. As modellers have done so far, they have written (via the computer) underneath or within my text either highlighting their writing from mine or using a red font. I have very little practical and emotional knowledge of the hobby and welcome critical eyes to look over it to help make the research stronger.

0 Comments


Recommended Comments

There are no comments to display.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...