Jump to content
 
  • entries
    261
  • comments
    1,413
  • views
    143,478

Gettin' Jiggy Wit It


Barry Ten

507 views

I must be a proper modeller, I've made a jig:

 

blogentry-6720-0-59476600-1372620554.jpg

 

Actually there's not much to it but after some frustration with the performance of my Spratt & Winkle equipped stock on Paynestown, I decided to make a simple coupler height bar setting jig, and this is the not very technical result. The main problem I was having was rolling stock uncoupling when it wasn't supposed to. The idea with the jig is that there's a slot cut in the end piece into which the coupling bar should slip, if it's at the right height. The end piece has a central recess for the coupling arm to enter.

 

blogentry-6720-0-64978200-1372620685.jpg

 

After checking all my stock, and adjusting where necessary, I've got to be honest and say that the results haven't been as dazzling as I'd hoped for. Yes, there's a general improvement in reliability, maybe from 70 to 85%, but it's not like night and day. I think the problem is that, even when you've got the height of the bar set correctly, there's still quite a lot of room for error in the other parameters, such as the distance that the bar is set out from the buffer beam, and the angle of the arm. I was hoping that by being virtuous and building a jig, I would have made the necessary observances to the model railway gods and my coupling issues would be behind me. That said, it is still a useful tool for setting up the couplers when installing them, and I'm trying to be a bit more consistent in setting up the other distances and angles, as well as revisiting some of the older stock where my installation was significantly "off".

 

My plan for couplings, incidentally, is more or less divided between BR and pre-nationalisation. For BR stock, it'll be mainly S&W equipped but with 3-links between short rakes or blocks of similar vehicles such as fish vans which will not be shunted. For pre-nationalisation, where the bulk of my stock is already 3-link equipped, I'll only do S&Ws on passenger vehicles.

  • Like 4

3 Comments


Recommended Comments

Given that you've made one jig, it would be rude not to make some more, surely? :)

If I recall - having spent time with various S&W advocates over the years - the distance between the inside of the hook and the buffer heads has to be consistent across all stock (it's the same for Alex Jackson's - which I'm attempting for my stuff). If they don't work - or my failing eyesight/patience halts further endeavours, I may come back to S&W's.

Keep on keeping on.

Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

I'm not sure the buffer heads come into it as such, at least in my approach, but there's definitely a critical distance between the inside of the hook and the coupling bar, and that's where some of my wagons are a bit off, I think - as well as, the coupling hook doesn't always sit exactly horizonal even when the bar is at the nominal right height. It's all solvable, though, or at least I'm optimistic that that's the case. I could probably add a couple of register lines to the jig to indicate the desired distance between the hook and bar. There's a tiny bit of leeway in that parameter, but not much.

Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Thinking back to Jan's comment about the buffer heads, I realised that a lot depends on whether you mount the bar to the buffers or not. I prefer to drill two holes in the buffer beam itself and then fashion a "goalpost" which then sits between the buffers, with the bar set at slightly below the bottom of the buffer beam. Personally I find it a bit less obtrusive, and it allows me to use the "lower" mounting method for the S&Ws. But there's a lot of guesswork in setting up the relationship between the goalpost and the coupling hook, even more so as you first have to fix the goalpost in place, allow the glue to harden, and only then bend it down to the right height. But again, I think it's all solvable with a bit of patience.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...