Jump to content
 
  • entries
    24
  • comment
    1
  • views
    5,830

Great Tunsley Dale Page 7


trains12

120 views

Great Tunsley Dale

 

by trains12

 

original page on Old RMweb

__________________________________________

Comment posted by pilotfriend on Wed Sep 03, 2008 5:52 pm

 

This is exceptional industrial modelling. Well done...so impressive

best wishes and keep up the good work

John

__________________________________________

 

??? posted on Sat Sep 06, 2008 10:43 am

 

hi all

Just a couple of shots of the small diesel engine that I started last week. Much of the inspiration for this must go to Neil. He gave me the push.The cab is an old airfix 03 shunnter the body a old matchbox toy with a new under frame from plastic card and bits of fittings from the junk box. It is powered by a Tenshodo spud but on test running needs a good deal of lead fitting to give it the power to pull any wagons. It still needs handrails couplings and small details before painting. It is to be used on both GTD and on my new extention to my china clay layout Porth Eithin. icon_thumbsup2.gif

Peter

 

file.php?id=30642

 

file.php?id=30641

 

__________________________________________

Comment posted by MartinWales on Sat Sep 06, 2008 12:57 pm

 

Nice work from a cheap toy and different! Ideal for Porth Eithin icon_thumbsup2.gif

__________________________________________

Comment posted by Baby Deltic on Sat Sep 06, 2008 1:05 pm

 

Looks like part of the good old Matchbox shunter. I'll bet they're getting rare now. icon_razz.gif

__________________________________________

Comment posted by MartinWales on Sat Sep 06, 2008 1:55 pm

 

A bit rarer still now! Mind you it's upped the value of the remaning ones by a fraction!

__________________________________________

Comment posted by Ruston on Sat Sep 06, 2008 7:31 pm

 

file.php?id=30641

 

I don't get it. I don't mean to be rude but why? The rest of the layout is superb, especially the buildings. It looks so much like a real location that I recognise (Great Rocks Junction?) You've obviously got a great deal of modelling skill so why spoil it for a ha'pennorth of tar? i.e making up a fictitious shunter out of bits and pieces. Especially when there are suitable kits of prototypical shunters available. The Judith Edge Steelman Royale or the Sentinel/Rollls Royce would be ideally suited to the location modelled.

 

It's one of my pet hates when people pay great attention to the rest of the layout and the mainline stock, moaning that so-and-so wagon has got the wrong brake gear or such-and-such tender had the wrong axleboxes but when it comes to industrial shunters anything goes.

 

I'll get me coat now. Sorry. icon_redface.gif

__________________________________________

Comment posted by pharrc20 on Sat Sep 06, 2008 10:25 pm

 

I don't get it. I don't mean to be rude but why? The rest of the layout is superb, especially the buildings. It looks so much like a real location that I recognise (Great Rocks Junction?) You've obviously got a great deal of modelling skill so why spoil it for a ha'pennorth of tar? i.e making up a fictitious shunter out of bits and pieces. Especially when there are suitable kits of prototypical shunters available. The Judith Edge Steelman Royale or the Sentinel/Rollls Royce would be ideally suited to the location modelled.

 

It's one of my pet hates when people pay great attention to the rest of the layout and the mainline stock, moaning that so-and-so wagon has got the wrong brake gear or such-and-such tender had the wrong axleboxes but when it comes to industrial shunters anything goes.

 

I'll get me coat now. Sorry.
icon_redface.gif

In fact the two we are going to model for GTD will be based on two rebuilds of 0-4-0 steam shunters into 0-4-0 diesel shunters as converted by ICI back in the late 60s, RS/8 and RS/142 'Trevithick', which at first glance would appear to be total works of fiction but are based on real examples. Besides it's Peters layout, so he says goes IMO. As Peter said, he got the inspiration for his fictional shunter from Neil Rushby, who I believe made another fictional shunter for Martin 'Wales' Jones. I suppose we could model the Ruston shunter that was trialled at Tunstead in the 60s as well along with the class 08 lookalike 0-6-0 EE Diesel-Electric shunters, both of which we have photos of working at Tunstead.

 

Paul

__________________________________________

Comment posted by PaulCheffus on Sun Sep 07, 2008 9:32 am

 

Ruston wrote:

 

file.php?id=30641

 

I don't get it. I don't mean to be rude but why? The rest of the layout is superb, especially the buildings. It looks so much like a real location that I recognise (Great Rocks Junction?) You've obviously got a great deal of modelling skill so why spoil it for a ha'pennorth of tar? i.e making up a fictitious shunter out of bits and pieces. Especially when there are suitable kits of prototypical shunters available. The Judith Edge Steelman Royale or the Sentinel/Rollls Royce would be ideally suited to the location modelled.

 

It's one of my pet hates when people pay great attention to the rest of the layout and the mainline stock, moaning that so-and-so wagon has got the wrong brake gear or such-and-such tender had the wrong axleboxes but when it comes to industrial shunters anything goes.

 

I'll get me coat now. Sorry.
icon_redface.gif

Hi

 

Personally I think it makes a nice model and is something different.

 

Cheers

 

Paul

__________________________________________

Comment posted by david_ford_85 on Sun Sep 07, 2008 9:59 am

 

PaulCheffus wrote:

Ruston wrote:

 

file.php?id=30641

 

I don't get it. I don't mean to be rude but why? The rest of the layout is superb, especially the buildings. It looks so much like a real location that I recognise (Great Rocks Junction?) You've obviously got a great deal of modelling skill so why spoil it for a ha'pennorth of tar? i.e making up a fictitious shunter out of bits and pieces. Especially when there are suitable kits of prototypical shunters available. The Judith Edge Steelman Royale or the Sentinel/Rollls Royce would be ideally suited to the location modelled.

 

It's one of my pet hates when people pay great attention to the rest of the layout and the mainline stock, moaning that so-and-so wagon has got the wrong brake gear or such-and-such tender had the wrong axleboxes but when it comes to industrial shunters anything goes.

 

I'll get me coat now. Sorry.
icon_redface.gif

Hi

 

Personally I think it makes a nice model and is something different.

 

Cheers

 

Paul

Me too, I think its brilliant, an excellent use of what was itself a quite nice toy.

 

David

__________________________________________

 

??? posted on Sun Sep 07, 2008 9:24 pm

 

Ruston wrote:

 

file.php?id=30641

 

I don't get it. I don't mean to be rude but why? The rest of the layout is superb, especially the buildings. It looks so much like a real location that I recognise (Great Rocks Junction?) You've obviously got a great deal of modelling skill so why spoil it for a ha'pennorth of tar? i.e making up a fictitious shunter out of bits and pieces. Especially when there are suitable kits of prototypical shunters available. The Judith Edge Steelman Royale or the Sentinel/Rollls Royce would be ideally suited to the location modelled.

 

It's one of my pet hates when people pay great attention to the rest of the layout and the mainline stock, moaning that so-and-so wagon has got the wrong brake gear or such-and-such tender had the wrong axleboxes but when it comes to industrial shunters anything goes.

 

I'll get me coat now. Sorry.
icon_redface.gif

Hi Dave

i take your point but it was just a spur of the moment to make it before I got into the more serious modelling again on the buidings. One thing is that it is not totally freelance has it is based, I admitt loosely, on a North British Co. design from the early 1950,s of which I have some shots in a book. The main differances are the font cab windows and the length of the bonnet. The exhust when built was differrent but in later years before it was I belived scrapped it was fitted with the exhust as modelled. The main shutters that are being made for it are copies of ones made in the South Works Shops as paul has stated.

Regrds Peter icon_thumbsup2.gif

__________________________________________

Comment posted by Bomp on Sun Sep 07, 2008 9:30 pm

 

I'd like to be able to knock something like that up as a bit of playtime! Nice loco. I have a few of the Matchbox shunters, but couldn't bring myself to cut them up like that!

__________________________________________

Comment posted by mines a pint on Sun Sep 07, 2008 9:43 pm

 

Bomp wrote:

I'd like to be able to knock something like that up as a bit of playtime! Nice loco. I have a few of the Matchbox shunters, but couldn't bring myself to cut them up like that!

Likewise, I cant see what harm there is in 'freelance' loco's even on a 'serious' layout, besides once its painted and somebody sees it at an exhibition someone will swear theres one just like it somewhere anywhere! icon_wink.gif , 'till I can find the necessary 'wedge' for a DJH Barclay Saddletank, I'm going to have a go at hacking up a Hornby 'caley' pug to represent an NCB loco, if it turns out half as well as this I'd be well pleased!

 

That is another factor with these no doubt well researched 'kit' industrials, they aint cheap, so if you can knock something together as well as this then all the best! the diecast section has nice rivet detail and no doubt adds useful weight to the loco icon_question.gif

__________________________________________

 

??? posted on Mon Sep 29, 2008 4:37 pm

 

Well I am back at doing some modelling of the building kind icon_thumbsup2.gif now after a hectic last few weeks. Not much has been done on the main layout but hopefully that will change in the next few weeks. Have now started to paint some of the smaller items on the buildings realising that I can not now get to all the fine details due to the increasing pipe work and other fittings that are being attached. The detailing of the vertical lime kilns themselves is now under way (pictures to follow) and some of the old derelict shutes and other small objects, one of these being the funny little round concrete huts. Paul and I saw these at Tunstead but until we visited the site did not know what they were. In fact they are portable blast shelters for the workmen when blasting was taking place in the old days

These have been made from the small plastic retainers from inside Kinder Suprise Eggs. They are glued onto a base and the door is built up with micro strip and daz modelling clay then sanded down. icon_biggrin.gif

 

file.php?id=34509

 

file.php?id=34508

 

file.php?id=34507

 

__________________________________________

Comment posted by Grimleygrid on Tue Sep 30, 2008 8:32 am

 

Peter, all I can say is wow! Stunning, that really is.

 

Can??????????¬???????t wait to see the painted buildings on the layout. Can I come and bring some of my 60s for a play?!!!

__________________________________________

Comment posted by MartinWales on Tue Sep 30, 2008 5:15 pm

 

The buildings look even better close up icon_thumbsup2.gif

__________________________________________

 

??? posted on Wed Oct 01, 2008 8:27 am

 

Grimleygrid wrote:

Peter, all I can say is wow! Stunning, that really is.

 

Can??????????¬???????t wait to see the painted buildings on the layout. Can I come and bring some of my 60s for a play?!!!

Hi Grimleygrid

Thanks or the comments. It is hoped that the club is holding a small show / open day at Talsarn village hall in December when we hope to have GTD up and running so you are most welcome to bring the 60's. Between Paul and myself we have about four i think. The buildings will not all be finnished but it is hoped that some of the scenary will be done. Will post on here in the next week or so the dates when confirmed. May be looking for operators for that weekend as well as my other two layouts will be there together with the clubs 1mm layout and two other members layouts so we are a bit short of helpers. icon_clap.gif

Peter

__________________________________________

Comment posted by matty-a7x on Wed Oct 01, 2008 10:12 am

 

I think this is going to be a great layout. I also realy like the shunter you are making icon_biggrin.gif

__________________________________________

Comment posted by Grimleygrid on Wed Oct 01, 2008 1:12 pm

 

Hi Peter, thanks for the invite. I would love to come along with my 60 fleet and see GTD in the flesh but it is quite a long way for me to travel, but you never know??????????¬?‚?¦??????????¬?‚?¦

 

Look forward to seeing more updates.

__________________________________________

Comment posted by matto21 on Thu Oct 02, 2008 6:02 pm

 

I really like the little shunter, looks really cool! Wouldnt mind building something like this myself! Is it painted yet?

__________________________________________

Comment posted by MartinWales on Thu Oct 02, 2008 6:04 pm

 

Refresh my memory Pete-was that the first or second weekend in December?

__________________________________________

Comment posted by pilotfriend on Thu Oct 02, 2008 6:14 pm

 

The plant you have built appears to me to be to professional standards....marvellous....and as far as I am concerned, if you want that shunter, its your layout for God's sake.

regards

JOhn

__________________________________________

 

??? posted on Fri Oct 03, 2008 7:34 pm

 

matto21 wrote:

I really like the little shunter, looks really cool! Wouldnt mind building something like this myself! Is it painted yet?

Hi Matt

No it is still to be finnished yet ben working on the buildings also have not yet thought of a colour scheme.

 

Peter

__________________________________________

 

??? posted on Fri Oct 03, 2008 7:42 pm

 

Hi all

Well the next few weeks are going to be very busy. To day the club has booked the 6th & 7th of December for are open day show at Talsarn Village Hall in Talsarn. this on the stie of the old railway station. Have to get GTD complete on the wiring. It is going to be its first outing and the show is to be used as a try out that all works OK and it all fits icon_clap.gif It will appear as a workin hand layout to gether with 4 or 5 other club members layouts. So if any RM members fancy giving a hand all will be most wellcome. Just drop me a message. icon_thumbsup2.gif

Cheers Peter

__________________________________________

 

??? posted on Sun Oct 19, 2008 6:47 pm

 

Hi all

Just a quick update. Have spent the last 10 days still on the wiring, finished all fiddle yard and am on main part now putting point motors on. Am posting photo of rock faces on GTD because we have had some Americans in and a guy from down south who all know the area very well and say that the rock faces are not very good and don't do anything for the layout. Just wondering whether should hack all faces off and start again as I know they are not dead correct but had depressed me a bit considering the amount of time I spent creating them. Comments please.

Regards

Peter

 

file.php?id=38265

 

__________________________________________

Comment posted by Ben A on Sun Oct 19, 2008 8:36 pm

 

Hi Peter,

 

Although I'm an N-gauger, I've been following this thread with particular interest. I'm especially fascinated by Peak Forest traffic, and I am in awe of the quality and detailing of the large scale structures you are building.

 

As for the scenic modelling, and specifically the rock faces, in all honesty it is very difficult to judge the quality merely from photographs.

 

However, one observation I would make is this: your posting suggests to me that the comments from your visitors struck a little bit of a nerve. Is this because, having put in all that work, deep down you yourself are not totally convinced by the rockfaces?

 

I hasten to add that I speak from experience - there have been occasions when I've been honestly unsure whether I've "nailed" a thing or not and therefore asked someone who I trust - possibly seeking validation. I'm simultaneously angry and yet slightly relieved when they confirm my fears - that actually, something I've spent a lot of time on needs a little bit more work!!

 

Hope that helps!

 

cheers

 

Ben A.

__________________________________________

0 Comments


Recommended Comments

There are no comments to display.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...