Jump to content
 

GWR 0-6-0 Tender Engines - continued... problems...


Brassey

570 views

There is a strategy to my building 2 outside frames together.  Firstly they both shared the Armstrong Standard Goods S4 boiler.  The also had springs above the footplate which is a challenge I want to tackle in one go.  And I intend to build 2 outside frame tenders that also share the spring issue.

 

So the Armstrong Goods now has a cab and rear splashers:

 

IMG_0455.jpg.a22e8a46575fab7dee3e2ea5ad7bbb67.jpg

 

Smokebox, boiler and roundtop firebox:

 

IMG_0456.jpg.f03220ed056b7689511989dc3f5e2a1c.jpg

IMG_0457.jpg.ac63e035faef703ac81ce9841df21044.jpg

 

The Beyer Goods, being bits of old K's kits, is further on but I have now hit a problem common to trying to get old whitemetal kits to work in P4:

 

The width across the outside frames is 29.5 mm

 

IMG_0458.jpg.5128d5bbfbf42a2d9938faa85429f95b.jpg

 

Alan Gibson OSF axles are measuring up at 31.75mm.  (Ultrascale OSF axles that I have for a Duke and a City measure 32mm)

 

IMG_0459.jpg.925193168b6c4a3982caf1a0acc8c7e2.jpg

 

With 2.25mm to spare, this does not leave sufficient clearance to fit the AGW outside cranks which are about 1.5mm thick and then a bit more needs to allowed for sideplay.

 

IMG_0460.jpg.a4a572bedad6b72fcaadaeafb8978200.jpg

 

The solution could be to fit thinner, brass cranks (and I do have some in my stash).  But I am not sure about the appearance and also the idea of soldering them to the axles fills me with horror.

 

Eagle-eyed would have noticed that the above shot is the Armstrong chassis not the Beyer one.  I have used the AGW axles on the Armstrong as, being brass, the frames are more slender.  These wheels are actually Mike Sharman.  Mike in his wisdom did not cut down his axles so I have a number of over length axles that I can cut down and use on the Beyer.  My worry now is if I make them too wide, they could foul on the platform edges.  At 34mm (which might be what's needed here) that's 8'6" which is near to the loading gauge.  Watch this space.  For some reason I seem to be choosing to build the most challenging of things at the mo.  Maybe it's lockdown!  I seem to have similar problems with my Metro builds (common feature the springs above footplate)  .

 

In the meantime, here's the current status of the two goods engines,  the Beyer just needs handrails and then onto those springs.  As this was just a few parts on eBay, it did not come with any springs or castings.  The Armstrong on the other hand has springs on the etch that need o be laminated up.  Next stage, the remaining 4 splashers:

 

IMG_0461.jpg.a72fa41ec791a28292ad8e09a28357fd.jpg

  • Like 6
  • Craftsmanship/clever 1
  • Friendly/supportive 1

4 Comments


Recommended Comments

Adhesives are available that would fix the thinner brass cranks to the axles without the soldering issues, if you can get past the appearance in your mind. Seem to quite commonly available from helicopter and drone hobby suppliers for fixing props/gears to motor shafts (so similar applications).

 

If not that or the suggestion in the previous comment then you are talking yourself into replacing the (over width?) outside frames. 

Link to comment

I took the option of making longer axles at 34mm but, low and behold despite looking hopeful, once the rods and crankpins were on, they fouled the platforms and neither is there clearance for the dock in the goods yard.

 

IMG_0463.jpg.4843cff250e94c9bb50abc8aa1d7d3af.jpg

 

So that must have been a reason why the AGW were shorter.  I have one other completed outside frame loco (Barnum) and I based the axle length for that on the Ultrascale axles (32mm).  This clears the platforms so is the standard to aim for.  The next option that remains is to move the outside frames and revert to shorter axles.

 

All this has thrown up another issue though.   The Barnum is 4 coupled whereas the the longer rod length of a 6 coupled may prove more of a problem with the clearance.  I have some other GWR outside frame locos to build,  so I will try to see if the problem persists and is a bigger clearance issue.  These will be built pretty much out of the box with components almost exclusively from the Alan Gibson stable.  Hopefully his wheels should work on his locos!  But with P4 who knows.

 

Until then, these 0-6-0's are on hold.

 

 

Link to comment

The Standard Goods is stalled whilst awaiting the restart of High Level to supply a gearbox.  The standard 1.5mm bore RoadRunner should be an OK fit with a 1220 motor but I don't have one at the mo.

 

In the meantime the Beyer Goods has progressed.  I finally bit the bullett and the wheels were removed and the axles trimmed down by about 1/2 mm. I also repositioned the compensation beams to raise the running plate height and give more movement to the hornblox.   It now clears the platforms and loading dock, just!  Smokebox door fitted.  The tenders are well on their way too:

 

Test run:

 

 

  • Like 3
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...