Jump to content
 
  • entries
    13
  • comments
    32
  • views
    5,881

Do not despair, for I have a cunning plan...


Skinnylinny

408 views

Having a layout involving sharp curves (140mm radius), bogie coaching stock looks a bit silly (with three mark 1s covering approximately 180 degrees of curvature), so I have decided to go down the route of 4-wheel coaching stock. A quick look on eBay was horrifying and caused the student loan alarms to start wailing - they generally go for about £25-30 a pop! Then I remembered having seen the Tomix Thomas the Tank Engine range in N scale. Fantastic - one set of Annie and Clarabel available for £20 from the shop I'm buying my track from, so no increase in postage. Plus, being made by Tomix, they'd go around my ludicrously sharp Tomix curves, right?

 

Well, the parcel arrived today. I say "arrived" - it got to the perfectly fine by the Japanese post office, at which point it was handed over to Parcel Farce. Long story short, they didn't even bother to put a "You were out" (I wasn't) card through my door, just threw it on the floor inside the main door for the building. One 'phone call to the nearest post office confirmed that the parcel was there, and so I went to collect it.

 

The track was just as I expected, and the points are beautiful - very small, but you can still unclip a small piece of plastic underneath and slot in the standard Tomix point motor in about 15 seconds.

 

blogentry-793-077651300 1288890669_thumb.jpg

 

Next out were the coaches. These actually look really nice, with a decent representation of the panelling on the coaches in the TV series. I don't know if there's any specific prototype these are meant to represent, but they make nice generic panelled stock:

 

blogentry-793-057510900 1288890653_thumb.jpg

 

However, on playing with them on the track I had to hand, I came up against a problem; the coaches struggled with simple curves, tipping over when going from straight to curved track due to buffer lock. This photo (with the Rapidos removed) gives an idea of the angle the coaches are at to one another on curved track:

 

blogentry-793-010629600 1288890893_thumb.jpg

 

Trying the on a reverse curve, however, pointed out a different problem with the long rigid chassis-mounted couplings; they wouldn't stand half a chance of staying coupled, even if the couplings could be extended to prevent buffer lock:

 

blogentry-793-057082500 1288891220_thumb.jpg

 

Between the coaches, this could possibly be remedied by having a rigid bar coupling free to pivot at each end, but how to (removably) couple to a loco? I was thinking of fiddling around with bits of bent wire at this point, until I placed a Peco van on the track too. This led to another discovery:

 

blogentry-793-011691200 1288891483_thumb.jpg

 

These coaches, despite being nominally 1:150, are somewhat larger than Peco rolling stock at nominal 1:148. So the question is posed: Do I cut my losses and sell them on whence they came on eBay, or do I persevere and attack them with a saw and file and try to make something presentable out of them? I'm loath to damage the finish on them, especially having paid just over £20. If all else fails, I may have to try to make something out of a Peco chassis and some plasticard, unless anyone else has any suggestions for how I can obtain four-wheeled coaching stock at a price suitable for a student budget? Also, does anyone fancy a Tomix Annie and Clarabel? :P

 

Answers on a 4" by 6" piece of pulped dead plant or recycled electrons, please.

4 Comments


Recommended Comments

re: the buffers on the corners - *modify* them to be hydraulic? They look like they are halfway there. I'll have to confirm when mine arrive... (currently stuck at Japans outgoing terminal)

 

I'm sure we can collaborate on this? ;)

 

Nate

Link to comment

Mhmmm, sprung buffers might help, but on these curves, the couplings on reverse curves are more likely to be an issue, I think. Collaboration would be good! :)

Link to comment

Actually, the buffers simply pull off, allowing the coaches to traverse my curves, as long as I don't expect them to run through reverse curves. Removing the body from the chassis is rather harder, though, requiring some slitting with a scalpel...

Link to comment

I can identify with what you are trying to do here! In the end I gave up on having a roundy-roundy (for now at least).

 

I do wonder if there might be more mileage in trying to fit a Tomix close coupling unit to the coaches rather than producing sprung buffers in N. As far as I'm aware there aren't any N sprung buffers commercially available at all, and I've never even seen anyone using them in 2mm Finescale.

 

The old Farish 4 wheel coaches were very much freelance, and i think had quite a long fixed wheelbase, as well as no close-coupling. Chances are you would have had the same problems.

 

However, if you're looking for an off the shelf solution, you might consider changing to German prototype? There are quite a lot of short wheelbase steam locos available in N, as well as quite a range of 4 wheel coaches. Some of which have close-coupling mechanisms as standard (look for "kurzkupplung" or the logo that looks like =)(= in the catalogues). Fleischmann 4 wheel composite coach

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...