Jump to content
 
  • entries
    9
  • comments
    47
  • views
    15,450

ARC/Hanson JHA Part 2: Bogie test prints in frosted ultra detail


lyneux

1,489 views

The test print arrived last week and I couldn't wait to try it out with Colin's Wheels. Here it is with a white background:

 

blogentry-7525-0-32859100-1312737041_thumb.jpg

 

 

And here it is against black (seems to show up more detail and yes, they are the same wheels!):

 

 

blogentry-7525-0-48747700-1312737895_thumb.jpg

 

 

I was initially worried about the material (frosted ultra detail) not being strong enough and/or warping but it was gratifying to see that the bogies are nice and strong and totally "true". I added a bit of sprue between the ends of the frames (evident in the pictures) to keep the frames the right distance apart. I'm not sure that this is totally necessary. The amazing thing is that none of the brake gear is damaged at all (I was expecting this to be the weakest bit).

 

The axle holes need opening out a bit with a cutting broach to make them free rolling. I've also lost a few of the dampers in the process of handling and washing them. I'm not totally convinced that metal axle on plastic will give a long life to the bogies so I've ordered some Markits bush bearings for 2mm axles. On the test prints I'll open out the bearings to 3mm with a drill to accept the bushes once they arrive.

 

I've washed a lot of the residual wax off the bogies using warm soapy water and a soft paintbrush (inserted into all the nooks and crannies). This seems to have done the trick and it is now a case of seeing how well they take paint.

 

Things to improve on in the next batch:

  • Print with a 3mm hole ready to accept the Markits bearings (assuming they fit on the test print).
  • Strengthen the join between the secondary dampers and their attachment points (make a bigger cross section so they don't snap off). I might also add a sprue that joins the 4 secondary dampers together to keep them from snapping off. Will also print some spare ones as I've lost a few on the carpet!
  • Add a bit of bracing between the main and the side frames (light and dark grey bits in the 3D render on my previous blog entry). The extra bracing on the bogie with the handwheel has a significant strengthening effect.

Off now to make up some of Colin's handwheels and to order some sequins and O-rings to act as the primary suspension units.

  • Like 4

7 Comments


Recommended Comments

I had a look at these at StormEx yesterday and they are a nice little piece of engineering! It was also good to have a chat!

 

Cheers,

 

Jack

Link to comment

These look amazing! glad to see its all progressing well, and these look how i wish mine looked! The 3d printing has done a great job, it looks like a very faithfull reproduction of the bogie, the brakegear in particular looks the part. What size handwheels will you be using, i wasn't sure what size they were, they're quite a small wheel. Look forward to seeing this progress, and also the wagons, eventually!

Link to comment

Thanks fellas!

Chris, I was going to use these:

 

http://colincraig4mm.co.uk/#/hand-wheels/4532593494

 

I have a few packs of CC01D. I was going to use the ones second from right. I've lots spare since I've used the other types on my PGAs. Alternately the ones from CC02D might be better?

 

I need to sort out the design issues mentioned above then I hope to make them available via the shapeways shop. I'll probably also adapt the 3D model for the JMA bogie too and make this available. Just a matter of time which is in short supply at the moment!

Link to comment

I've just had a look at all of Colin's handwheels that I have and re-measured my drawings of the JHA. Actually, it looks like 18 inch handbrake wheels (i.e. CC01D) are too large. The smaller 15 inch wheels supplied with CC06D seem about the right size. I'm guessing that the smaller wheels in CC02D are the same as the small ones supplied with CC06D. If so, then they would also be appropriate.

Link to comment

Wow, these look great. I was at Stormex and missed this. Now I understand what Shawplan Brian was talking about when we were chatting about 3D printing.

Link to comment

Looking good!

Can´t wait to see them painted. Hope you will share the painting experiences with us.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...