Jump to content
 
  • entries
    261
  • comments
    1,413
  • views
    143,393

Meltdown


Barry Ten

898 views

Viewers of a nervous disposition, look away now...

 

Long-time followers of the blog may remember my 28xx, which was a detailed and repainted Hornby model:

 

index.php?app=core&module=attach&section=attach&attach_rel_module=blogentry&attach_id=62243

 

index.php?app=core&module=attach&section=attach&attach_rel_module=blogentry&attach_id=62245

 

The model has always been a favorite of mine, not only because of the work invested in it, but also because it was a birthday present from my wife and therefore had a bit more significance than just any old model bought by me. It has also always run well, in fact it is probably the best of the traditional Hornby tender drive locos I've owned.

 

The model was given a good outing a couple of years ago but has been in a box since then, while I've mainly been concentrating on running DCC equipped models. Over the last year, however, I've gradually been getting more confident with doing my own decoder installations and after fitting decoders into some fairly awkward models, it looked as if the tender drive 28xx would be a doddle, with a simple soldering job and plenty of room for a standard Hornby chip. Given that the slow speed running on DC was good, I anticipated that it would be even better on DCC.

 

Can you tell where this is heading?

 

In the end the decoder installation turned out to be relatively pain-free and I completed the job in about half an hour, taking my time and using plenty of heat-shrink insulation. I hooked up the loco and tender and gave it a test. As always the decoder was wired backwards, but a quick reset of CV#29 took care of that. As anticipated, the slow running was very satisfactory and I spent an enjoyable few minutes running the loco up and down a stretch of track. It looked great. I have one of the newer 28xx models but this old one can still hold its own and on my small layout there are no question marks over haulage. I looked forward to changing the tender coupling to a 3-link hook so that I could load up a long-ish train of South Wales mineral wagons.

 

The next evening I came back and ran it again - still good. But I got on with other stuff and only gave it a short run. The next evening again, I couldn't resist calling up the loco and giving it another spin. As before, the slow running was great. BUT - something was a bit strange.

The loco looked different. I was only watching it from a distance, but there was something about it ... something near the front. I peered closer and had a bit of a shock. The smokebox had melted.

 

Yes, somehow I'd forgotten that there was a smoke unit in this model - a smoke unit which had been quietly receiving full DCC voltage and current the entire time I'd been testing my lovely engine. Of course I had never made much use of the smoke generator so it had dropped off my things to think about when chipping the loco.

 

But here, for your edification, are the sad results:

 

blogentry-6720-0-01861500-1351613375_thumb.jpg

 

blogentry-6720-0-85131800-1351613399_thumb.jpg

 

Close inspection revealed that the melting had begun to deform not only the smokebox/chimney, but also the boiler barrel. So any hope of simply grafting a new smokebox into place were dashed. It looked as if I had two options - bin the model, or source a new body and perform either a complete body transplant or the whole boiler/smokebox. Obviously at this point I was pretty heartbroken - in fact, in a week that had seen some other cockups, I came closer to thinking about chucking in the hobby than at any time in years.

 

As it happened, sourcing a body turned out to be not as straightforward as I'd imagined. I drew a blank on ebay - I guess people tended to keep the bodies and dispose of the chassis, not the other way round. I also couldn't locate one from a spares dealer. The guy at the Cardoiff show, who turns up with lots of Hornby loco bodies, also couldn't help - he seemed to have everything but a 28xx.

 

My wife suggested I put out an appeal on the forum but I wasn't hopeful that it would do much good. However, I did it anyway. And within a day I had an extremely pleasing response from forum member Richard (RCAR6015) who, it turned out, had acquired a 28xx body some years ago for a project that had not come to fruition. With the new model out, Richard now had no use for the body and was happy to let me have it. After a quick phone call it became clear that Richard would not even accept payment, even to cover postage costs. I was genuinely touched by Richard's kindness and think it says something very positive about the best aspects of a forum like this.

 

Richard was quick off the mark and within a couple of days of our phone call, I had another 28xx body. After deliberating, I've decided that the best thing is to leave the body intact, and simply transplant all the extra detail from the melted one onto the new carcass - that it will be a lot cleaner than attempting a cut and shut, and in any case I'd have to redo the handrails if I went down that route.

 

So the 28xx lives on, or will live on, after some surgery, and I get to keep on playing with my present, all thanks to the kindness of an Rmwebber. Thanks, Richard!

  • Like 19

11 Comments


Recommended Comments

A heart warming tale after a near disaster! Just the thing to cheer up a cold, dark evening. You can get the smoke units to work off DCC so leave it in disconnected if it is still alive then wire it up at your leisure.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Glad it turned out all right and what a great advert for the people who use this forum.Bravo Richard.

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Al, I did the same all those years ago in Beatties, Cardiff, demo'ing (well playing) the 'new Zero One' !

 

I did it to a customers loco to!

 

I think it was a LMS 4-4-0 which he brought in to show the chip fitted etc, I cant recall the exact details but we actually saw the chimney start to sag before we realised what was happening!

 

Luckily it was a bog standard loco, which I exchanged right away, but learnt a valuable lesson!

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Im glad that you havent decided to chuck in the hobby. I love reading this blog and looking at your work. Gives me something to aspire too.

 

Good luck with the body swap.

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Adding a word of thanks and praise to RCAR6015 for his generosity (in many ways typical of the spirit of RMweb), allowing the rest of us the opportunity to see more of Barry Ten's modelling.

 

That's a lesson to remember... check and check again before firing-up!

  • Like 1
Link to comment

I don't mind telling you that reading this has left me with a lump in my throat.

 

Thanks for sharing,

 

Jonte

  • Like 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Before you fire it up again, what have you done about the smoke unit!!!!

 

Don't forget and go for a repeat experience :)

 

Regards

 

Richard

  • Like 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

I'd have to intentionally wire up the smoke unit in the new body for it to happen twice, so hopefully that won't happen. I wouldn't mind connecting it to a suitable decoder, though, at some point.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...