Jump to content
 
  • entries
    87
  • comments
    69
  • views
    39,504

Troublesome Bogies


Ravenser

299 views

This is by way of a short bump or plea for help , sparked by a few comments in the MBA thread.

 

One of the wagons I'm currently working on (or should be instead of typing) is the wretched Walrus. An ancient kit from deceased estate. As I mentioned somewhere down below , the bogies as supplied are unbuildable. I can't get them together for modern wheels ,. The only way forward I've found is to use some A1 Models H- frame etches.

 

The bogies are GWR Plate type, and even this approach is a bodge. The minimum wb permitted by the etch is about 1mm too wide. The second problem is that the brass of the A1 etch protrudes beyond the sideframe - which will now be cosmetic. I can trim the brass but not quite enough to eliminate the problem completely . It will look okay unless and until you compare it closely with the real thing - at which point it will be not much better than Dapols efforts on the MBA

 

The frames are soldered up, but before I'm finally committed to this compromise (like it won't get done tonight) does anyone have any really bright ideas for alternative solutions? Anyone built this dratted kit themselves - if so what did you do?

 

Comments , gentlemen, please....

7 Comments


Recommended Comments

What wheelbase is required? I got so fed up of the bogies for the Cambrian Sealion, that I did my own etch, but that's for the cast type, not platebacks.

Jon

Link to comment

Thanks for this . It looks like Cambrian bogies (from the reissued retooled kit) are the cheapst way to go. I hope I can get some at Warley. Its not been the best of evenings as I've managed to bend an axle pulling wheels off 12mm dia wheelsets while dabbling with the Pacer - replacement needed- , and a quick check has revealed there's only one possible NL Pacer in Provincial livery with Hornby's multirib style 1st batch roof (142 050). Trying to find photos of Pacers in original blue isn't exactly easy either. I can see several projects grinding to a temporary halt here...

Link to comment

Jon: all I was trying to do was to fit the sideframes supplied in the kit. These appear to be 5'6" and are quoted as such for the new version Cambrian spare parts . Southern Wagons vol 4 simply says "the standard BR plate bogies" - Alan Blackburn was somewhat beyond his official remit in covering these BR derivatives and there's no drawing .

 

Having said that , if the Cambrian Sealion was bad news in this area, then replacement Cambrian bogies may not help that much....

 

The Bill Bedford etch frame will cost me more than I paid for the kit, secondhand

Link to comment
Guest jim s-w

Posted

Hi Rav

 

Originally Cambrian kits came with bogies that needed assembling and they were weak as hell. Recently Cambrian have started selling one piece bogies (like RTR) and they are much, much better.

 

HTH

 

Jim

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...