Jump to content
  • entries
    161
  • comments
    1,232
  • views
    369,295

Llanvair Grange – new from Hornby 2018

In the 1960s we lived in the north east of England and took our holidays in west Wales. This Spring after a winter season of north east model railway memories I have taken a ‘Western’ break and invested in Hornby’s latest BR (WR) Grange.

 

27200391598_53f798416e_b.jpg
Hornby R3452 Llanvair Grange – front end

 

I think the Grange is one of Hornby’s more finely detailed models. As a result it is rather delicate and in my opinion lightweight, benefiting from the addition of some lead ballast. Hornby’s previous Grange, Bucklebury Grange, was one of the first models to be sourced in China from ‘Refined’. I had to return my first model to Locomotion for replacement because of quality control issues. I wrote a Blog Post at the time about adding lead ballast together with comments on some of the quality issues:

 

http://www.rmweb.co.uk/community/index.php?/blog/880/entry-14897-a-more-refined-grange-%E2%80%93-Hornby-bucklebury-grange/

 

What do I think of the new model, Llanvair Grange? Judging by the reference number on the box Llanvair Grange is another ‘Refined’ model and from my limited personal experience, still affected by quality control issues. This time my model came from Rails of Sheffield. Thank you Simon for spending time to sort out a half decent model.

 

40363509704_b470886233_b.jpg
Hornby R3452 Llanvair Grange – tender behind

 

As with the earlier model of Bucklebury Grange ‘Refined’ seem to me to have used over long handrail knobs at the rear of the tender.

 

40178828865_d63bded1ed_b.jpg
Hornby R3452 Llanvair Grange- tender hand rail knobs

 

Bits of plastic detail on my Bucklebury Grange were warped or damaged and needed tweaking. Llanvair Grange exhibited similar minor problems, for example a damaged buffer head.

 

40178833725_28b39f2e02_b.jpg
Hornby R3452 Llanvair Grange – damaged buffer head

 

However one of the models I received had what I thought was quite a noticeable bend in the body shell.

 

26201178697_7c9ea8b408_b.jpg
Hornby R3452 Llanvair Grange – banana shaped?

 

It was so severely warped that the reversing lever would not fit and was loose in the box.

 

40178840945_001dd7d5fe_b.jpg
Hornby Bucklebury Grange – with bowed footplate

 

Interestingly I have revisited Bucklebury Grange and can see that it exhibits similar bending. All that time and I had never noticed! Infact it would appear that all of the ‘Refined’ Granges exhibit a degree of bending – some obviously more severe than others. I would investigate further.

 

27200373888_c5354a4dd0_b.jpg
Hornby R3452 Llanvair Grange - footplate - Note lack of Vacuum Pump Body and Spindle

 

On separating the body and chassis I half expected to find some wiring that had been trapped, but no that was not the case. I did observe that the joint between the smoke box saddle and the footplate was no longer glued together. If I tried to remake this joint I noted that this only made the footplate more warped. The boiler is a super strong cylinder and it seemed to me to be pressing down on a cross member half way along the footplate.

 

27200378798_f8a1788c9a_b.jpg
Llanvair Grange - underside of body shell

 

40178842705_278488337e_b.jpg
Llanvair Grange - underside of body shell

 

I would shave some plastic from beneath the boiler and from the cross member. It was not very scientific and more a case of where will a blade fit. However it seems to have worked and the footplate was soon dead level. I should add that to compete the straightening exercise I had to temporarily disconnect the small pipe running along the side of the footplate where it clips behind the buffer beam. After a little bit of gentle massage it can be pushed back with a better alignment.

 

40178847565_8c93b1a2f4_b.jpg
Hornby R3452 Llanvair Grange – footplate fettled - Note Vacuum Pump Body and added Spindle to Bucklebury Grange (top)

 

In all the excitement I had dislodged a piece of bent wire at the side of the smoke box. Could I figure out how to put it back – no! I would look at Bucklebury Grange.

 

27200389338_f7a429e994_b.jpg
Llanvair Grange left, Bucklebury Grange right

 

It appeared to me that the piece of wire on my model of Llanvair Grange was formed as a mirror image of the one glued in place on Bucklebury Grange. It is steel wire and is not easily reshaped. However deed done and with a new coat of black paint I don’t think it looks too bad.

 

41029945822_3624786ae6_b.jpg
Llanvair Grange- smoke box fettled

 

I didn’t take a before picture of the smokebox so have no way of knowing how the ‘wrongly shaped’ wire had been attached. Perhaps I have got it wong? Equally I cannot imagine that my model was the only one so fitted!

 

40178868125_332049583d_b.jpg
Hornby R3452 Llanvair Grange complete

 

Llanvair Grange has been ballasted with some extra lead and is back together with not too many bits broken. It is a lovely smooth and quiet runner – so a good outcome.

  • Like 1
  • Informative/Useful 1


5 Comments


Recommended Comments

Hi Ray,

 

Thanks for another of your invaluable tutorials - you're one of very few people who take the reader 'step-step' through the process of improving rtr models. Given the quality of assembly coming off the production lines in China these days that's invaluable.

 

The wire you're referring to is at the exhaust end of the brake ejector pipe. I have a feeling that its purpose is to drain condensation away, presumably between the frames.

 

The pipe that runs along the running plate towards the buffer beam is the conduit for the GWR's Automatic Train Control system. If you're at all interested you might want to read the article below:-

 

http://mysite.du.edu/~etuttle/rail/atcgwr.htm

 

Andy.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Thanks Andy

 

Didn't know about the smoke box pipe but had half an inclination that the footplate conduit was for the AWS.

 

.The pipe that runs along the running plate towards the buffer beam is the conduit for the GWR's Automatic Train Control system.

 

Regards

 

Ray

Share this comment


Link to comment

Hi Ray. Nice to see a Western interlude!

 

That's an impressive fix of what seemed to be a pretty hopeless case. Apart from the body, how do you find the running quality of these Refined models (other than being too light)?

Share this comment


Link to comment

Thanks Mikkel

 

Early days for Llanvair Grange but it is smooth and quiet.  I was not happy with Bucklebury Grange which bounced all over the place.  I fitted a Sanda Kan wheel set which sorted the problem. So far the Refined models seem  to be immune from another of Hornby's recent problems - duff five pole motors.

 

Keep warm

 

Ray

Share this comment


Link to comment

Thanks Ray. I try to keep up to date with available GWR RTR models, so this is good to know.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.