Jump to content
  • entries
    30
  • comments
    250
  • views
    19,542

3D-printed Broad Gauge carriage, Part II

MikeOxon

324 views

In my previous post, I described making a 3D print of a Broad Gauge 1st / 2nd composite carriage, based on a prototype dating from 1854. With a bit of ‘Photoshop’ colouring, the 3D model of the body looks like this:

 

BG_1854_Comp-Dwg.jpg.39e280a38ece56c460f771f56f8782b3.jpg
3D-printed Broad Gauge Carriage Body

 

After printing the body, I have now turned my attention to the under-frame and running gear.

 

I have mentioned before the many useful ‘out of copyright’ books that I have found on the web, mostly in the ‘Internet Archive’.  My latest ‘find’ is a book by Daniel Kinnear Clark called ‘Railway Machinery’, published in 1855, which has proved something of a ‘gold-mine’.

 

Amongst all the information about locomotives, track, etc., there are details of components such as wheels, axle-boxes, and springs, together with excellent drawings of many early carriages, including some early GWR Broad Gauge designs.

 

Finding the 1st volume (text) on-line was straightforward but Vol.2, which contains the plates, proved more difficult, since many scans fail to copy the large ‘fold-out’ drawings. Fortunately, I eventually found a free download from Google Books at https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=QQ0cqi6y9vYC

 

For some reason, I could not download this book from my usual Firefox browser but Internet Explorer worked: Just click on the wheel icon, at top RHS of the page, and select ‘Download PDF’ from the drop-down menu.

 

These plates show details of the Normanville axle boxes, used on many early GWR carriages, and also the various wheel patterns, used at different periods, as shown below:

 

BG_1854_Clark-wheels.jpg.f53dc9c677234e6d7c93561b901f4627.jpg

Wheels and Axle-Boxes – from Daniel Kinnear Clark ‘Railway Machinery’ 1855

 

I also found detailed drawings of a GWR Broad Gauge 1st class carriage, which includes details of the longitudinally-divided central compartments, the underframe, and the running gear.

 

BG_1854-Clark_1st.jpg.b2623e6b994621059a81bb77e3bede01.jpg
GWR 1st-class Carriage – from Daniel Kinnear Clark’s ‘Railway Machinery’ 1855

 

By combining information from these drawings with that contained in the BGS Data Sheets, available to members of the Broad Gauge Society, I was able to prepare scale drawings in sufficient detail to design a 4mm-scale model.

 

As usual, I found that the research took rather longer than actual model building but it is good to retrieve so many otherwise ‘lost’ pieces of information.

 

As regular readers will know, I do not go for a high degree of mechanical precision in my modelling but like to create a general impression of the prototype, with as many correct dimensions as I can achieve, with my limited equipment.

 

 

2D Sketch

 

In creating the chassis, my first step was to prepare 2-dimensional drawings, using my favoured ‘Autosketch’ software. My end result is shown below:

 

BG_1854_2D-ChassisDwg1.jpg.60f8939dcb580357bf7be7acd7c0bb1f.jpg
Sketch of Broad Gauge 6-Wheel Chassis

 

 

3D Design

 

Now, I had to decide how to turn this design into a 3D-printed model. Since it was over a month since I last used my ‘Fusion 360’ software, I had forgotten a great deal about how to begin but, fortunately, I have used my other blog to keep notes on my methods, as I went along. These proved invaluable in jogging my memory over many important ‘lessons learned’.

 

It’s hard to know where to begin when modelling the complex assembly of parts that make up the running gear of a railway carriage. Should I model the individual components separately and then glue them together, as when using traditional design method?  As an experiment, I decided to try exactly the same technique as I used for the body, starting from the ‘floor’, immediately below the main body of the carriage and then using the extrusion (‘push-pull’) tools in ‘Fusion 360’, to create the sole-bars and head-stocks as an inverted open-top box. I then took my 2D drawing of the sides, including springs and axle-boxes, and ‘pasted’ the (DXF) drawing over the sole-bars, exactly as I described, in the notes referred to above, for placing the window-openings on a carriage body.

 

It would have been extremely tedious to design all the details individually for each wheel but, fortunately, I am becoming more adept at using the various ‘move’ and ‘copy’ tools within the ‘Fusion 360’ software. I must admit that I’m not yet completely au fait with the precise meanings of terms like ‘bodies’ and ‘components’ but, with a little trial and error, I managed to select groups of items, such as spring leaves, and to link them together into a single entity, which I could then copy and move to locations aligned with other wheels.

 

The copying process is a little cryptic, since it depends on a small check box at the end of a list of options for the ‘move’ command.

 

Eventually, I was able to complete a reasonable representation of the sole-bar and its various fittings on one side of the chassis. Then, I thought that I should be able to mirror-image the work I had done, to create the opposite sole-bar with little extra effort. An initial ‘Google search’ for how to do this was somewhat dispiriting , until I realised that I was reading some old material, but a later ‘upgrade’ to ‘Fusion 360’ has made the task relatively simple.

 

I first ‘cut’ my chassis into two halves, along its length, and deleted the half on which I had not added the details. Whereas the ‘move’ and ‘copy’ commands appear in the ‘Modify’ menu, the ‘mirror’ command took some finding, since it lies in the ‘Create’ menu. Once this was sorted, it was simply a question of selecting a plane to act as a mirror and the other half of the chassis ‘magically’ appeared on the base plane, a little distance away from the original. I then used ‘move’ to bring them together, followed by ‘Assemble’ to join up the halves into a single entity again.

 

BG_1854_chassis-build.jpg.d0510272b051aafd03215507008a9d30.jpg

Stages in creating 3D Model

 

Since I usually work by ‘following my nose’ (i.e. ‘empirically’), I only realised at this stage that it would be a good idea to provide holes in the axle-boxes, to accept pin-point wheel bearing cups. All that was needed was to draw a circle, centred within a face of the axle box, and use the ‘push-pull’ tool to take the opening across the body to the outer face of the opposite axle-box. One of the advantages of my ‘all-in-one’ approach is that the two sides are aligned automatically. I also opened slots in the floor to allow the wheels to protrude into wheel-boxes within the compartments, as on the prototype.

 

Preparing the Printer

 

A cause for concern was that the axle-boxes and springs overhang the area defined by the main frame members. This is a problem when 3D printing, because the final model is built up in layers and the printer head cannot lay down filament over empty space! For my experimental prototype, I decided to let the Cura ‘slicing’ software deal with the problem in its own way, by selecting to allow it to add ‘support structures’, where it considered them to be necessary.

 

BG_1854_chassis-Cura2.jpg.3f4d2fb1e78ff90ab72282761b617be0.jpg
‘Cura’ Layer View (152 layers) after ‘Slicing’

 

The good news is that my first trial print went smoothly and quickly – well under an hour to complete. I am now gaining much more confidence in the printing process and was content to leave the machine to its own devices ‘for the duration’.

 

In fact, despite some of my ascerbic comments over teething troubles with my Geeetech E180 printer, it is now proving extremely simple to use. I simply copy the ‘gcode’ file produced by the ‘Cura’ software onto an SD-card and place this into the slot in the back of the printer. Switch ‘on’ and select the required model on the touch screen of the printer, press ‘Print’ on the touch screen, then sit back and watch or get on with something else. Since the printer works from an SD card, it does not tie-up my computer when printing so I can get on with other modelling tasks.

 

The fans start up and the printer pauses for a while, until the head reaches printing temperature (200°C) then immediately starts printing. I now set the ‘Cura’ to add a ‘brim’ around the model, which has two advantages: It (i) fixes the model securely to the (unheated) print bed, and (ii) ensures that any initial ‘blob’ of filament, as the printing starts, goes onto the brim rather than the model.

 

Looking back, it seems strange that I initially experienced poor adhesion of the model to the print bed as I now have the opposite problem and find it difficult to remove the model without a lot of easing with a knife blade.

 

Design Modifications

 

My first prototype took under 1 hour to print but was too fragile and two of the axle-boxes broke off, while trying to remove the chassis from the printer bed. The springs had also become muddled with the support structures and were, again, too lightly constructed for a 4mm scale model. The lesson was that I needed to ‘beef up’ the thickness of some of my structures, in order to use plastic for under-frame construction.

 

Now that I am more familiar with using the ‘Fusion 360’ software, I found it was quite easy to increase the thickness of various components, by selecting the faces I wished to move and then using the ‘push-pull’ command to make the necessary adjustments. The ‘thicker’ versions can be seen in the last frame of my illustrations of the process, above.

 

Because there are a lot of small details in the model and the overall print time was relatively short, I decided to select the ‘extra-fine’ mode when printing. This lengthened the print time to about 2h 20m but did result in a finer surface finish.

 

The Printed Model

 

I’m pleased to write that the finished model exceeded my expectations. I had bought my printer as something of a ‘toy’ which I could use to explore a new technique and, perhaps, make some small component for my railway. I had never envisaged building complete carriages and am pleasantly surprised by how it has turned out.

 

The underside view of the chassis, as removed from the printer bed is shown below. There were a few fine ‘fingers’ of filament sprouting from various corners and a finger-nail proved to be an excellent tool for removing these. Otherwise, the print had worked well, including the over-hanging springs, which I had thought might cause problems. The ‘extra-fine’ mode showed almost no layering effect at all on the vertical faces of the sole-bars.

 

BG_1854_chassis-frame.jpg.3f684d01660e76853a9f12e742ebff60.jpg

3-D Printed Under-Frame

 

Wheels from the Broad Gauge Society fitted neatly between the axle-boxes and I soon had a ‘rolling’ chassis, as shown below:

 

BG_1854_rolling-chassis.jpg.57b87283f7bacb5d912f44b44919fec3.jpg

3D-printed ‘Rolling’ Chassis

 

Finally, I brought together the chassis with the 3D-printed carriage body, to complete the overall model of an 1854 Composite carriage, with its internal partitions dividing the 1st class compartments into side-by-side pairs.

 

BG_1854_printed-carriage.jpg.96800422b1a8e78a880ed395dee8aaab.jpg

3D-printed Model of Broad Gauge 1854 Composite Carriage

 

With a coat of brown paint, it should fit well into my planned Mail Train. I should be able to use a very similar chassis for my planned 2nd class carriage, although this will also require brake gear.

  • Like 6
  • Informative/Useful 2
  • Craftsmanship/clever 3


13 Comments


Recommended Comments

Many thanks, Dave.  As you know, I enjoy experimenting and am especially pleased when things turn out better than expected.  A long was to go to reach 'Sherton Abbas' quality :)

  • Like 1

Share this comment


Link to comment

Looks very god Mike.  I love the way you just experiment with the software, which is what I do although 1) there may be easier ways if I had read the manual, (Read the manual? -they are usually completely unreadable.  What I mean is investigated all the function buttons.) & 2) I may well have to on my cutter to set the cutting up, although reading a blog or thread might be better.

Share this comment


Link to comment
MikeOxon

Posted (edited)

Than you, Chris.  i tend to do things my own way and then use Google when I get stuck.  I often get a better answer from there than from reading a manual.  Most modern electronic 'toys' have so many functions that it's impossible to learn them all, so I find out about things as I meet the need for them.

Edited by MikeOxon
  • Like 1

Share this comment


Link to comment

Mike,

 

An outstanding piece of work!  Looking forward to the next project.

 

BTW how long was this coach in service? Did any make to to the end of Broad Gauge?

 

DrDuncan

Edited by drduncan
  • Like 1

Share this comment


Link to comment
16 hours ago, drduncan said:

Mike,

 

............BTW how long was this coach in service? Did any make to to the end of Broad Gauge? 

 

 

I recall we discussed this about a year ago.  Since then, I've looked closely at the carriage in the photo at Swindon (behind a Loriot) and it seems to be a different type - the waist line is curved to follow the quarter lights, whereas it was straight in the 1854 design.  I don't think that photo was at the dump, so it could date back much earlier.

 

The answer is also complicated by the fact that most of these carriages received later modifications - most had their roofs raised by 6 inches around 1870 and new fittings such as continuous footboards and vacuum brakes were fitted.  Oil lamps were added for each compartment.  As far as I know they had all gone by 1890, by which time they were down-graded to thirds.  Some were sold to the South Devon and may have remained on branches there until the end but I don't have that information.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1

Share this comment


Link to comment

Can you post a link to the earlier discussion?

DrDuncan 

Share this comment


Link to comment

Hi Mike, looks like good progress. I wonder if your earlier experiments with paper printed sides could be combined with this?  If so, a whole train could be made within a reasonable timeframe.

  • Like 1

Share this comment


Link to comment

Hi Mikkel.  I hope you had a good holiday. 

 

I've just knocked off the 2nd class version of this carriage, to the same overall dimensions, and was pleased to see how easy it was to make the necessary adaptations.  I'll hold off from another blog post until I've taken things a bit further.

 

These early coaches were painted brown all-over and, looking at the models, I can see why the Directors decided to brighten things up a bit, back in 1864, by introducing white (cream after varnishing) upper panels. 

 

For a more complex livery, I'm sure the printing technique could be applied to these 3D printed models.  In fact, I've already tried some experiments with ink-jet printable self-adhesive vinyl.   At present, though, all I need is a rattle-can of brown paint.

 

My printer came with a 'free' spool of blue filament, which I have been using throughout my learning process.  Now that I'm starting to produce reasonable models, I must buy some filament of a more suitable colour.

  • Like 2

Share this comment


Link to comment

The vinyl might be a very effective way of doing pannelling. A South Hants member has lent me a 2016 S4 society newsletter which has on article on producing Isle of Wight ex LBSC and SECR bogie stock in just that way.

DrDuncan

  • Informative/Useful 2

Share this comment


Link to comment

 

10 hours ago, MikeOxon said:

At present, though, all I need is a rattle-can of brown paint.

 

Funnily enough I actually find all brown GWR coaches quite exotic, since we are so used to the brown and cream.

 

39 minutes ago, drduncan said:

The vinyl might be a very effective way of doing pannelling. A South Hants member has lent me a 2016 S4 society newsletter which has on article on producing Isle of Wight ex LBSC and SECR bogie stock in just that way.

DrDuncan

 

There is also Peter Smith's thread, I think he even published a book on it. 

 

 

  • Like 1

Share this comment


Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.