Jump to content
 

Scratchbuilt GWR horsedrawn float


Mikkel

2,694 views

These past weeks I have had some pleasant early morning modelling sessions, building a GWR covered float for my early 1900s setting. 

 

001.jpg.e6fa4e04dfb396396932ba6a5f4e9e4e.jpg
 
The model was built using  two drawings in Great Western Horse Power by Janet Russel (figs 180 and 182) and a photo in Great Western Way p.163 (original edition). I was a bit slow to discover that there are variations between the drawings and the photo. The prototype is not in the GWR diagram book for horse-drawn carriages, but is arguably a variant of  the E5 diagram (see GWR Goods Cartage Vol 1 by Tony Atkins).


 

002.jpg.c2e0816b6e170e36a9288700464bd107.jpg

 

I say 'scratchbuilt', but the wheels are from an Arch Laser kit for another wagon (see discussion here). They conveniently represent the correct 4'6" diameter 14 spoke pattern used by the GWR in earlier days.

 

 

003.jpg.a06fd44b6ef1455d4b0eda5ce413e825.jpg

 

Although just a lowly float, the prototype had a certain Victorian elegance in the design. Like all floats, they had cranked axels to allow for a low floor and thereby easier loading of goods.

 

 

004.jpg.472975361b5d355dbeb9d3f6a84be52e.jpg

 

The hoop sticks for the tilt were formed over a jig, stuck on with duct tape and dunked in boiling water.

 

 

005a.jpg.265dd5aae634721f757ff4bcf7b7505d.jpg

 

The drawings show the tilt with vertical sides and a curved top. The wagon in the reference photo suggests a rounder shape. I initially concluded that this was an optical illusion. In retrospect I am not so sure.

 

 

006.jpg.000cb6b1e8031af9111f40afbbe1d71d.jpg

 

The shafts were also nicked from the Arch Laser kit. They are flat as they come, but on my prototype they have a curve so I rolled them with a round scalpel, and modifed them to allow proper fixing to the body.

 

 

008.jpg.b7ad2ff944f3981f671b4ee9dd1b7a5e.jpg

 

The shafts had extended mounting plates/irons along the side of the wagon. Mine are a bit over scale.

 

 

009.jpg.9033e3600f30eda461de7008ee313933.jpg

 

The springs were cut on my Silhouette. A rough outline was enough as the wheels obscure the details. 

 

 

12a.jpg.93837133decd24ac9387ad07da4230ef.jpg

 

The brake design seems to have varied on these vehicles. The reference photo shows a somewhat crude external design, operated by a lever from the front, so I imitated this.

 

 

14a.jpg.cb8b83b8be79c2f62e5c3127e6f4e314.jpg

 

For the painting, I followed Tony Atkins who in GWR Goods Cartage Vol 1 states: "According to the Railway Magazine, at the turn of the 19th/20th centuries GW horse lorries for delivering goods had red wheels, shafts and framing, while horse-drawn  vans used for collecting and delivering passenger train parcels were painted chocolate all over [...] In 1909 horse vans were also given the same red shafts and wheels as lorries."  Although floats sometimes doubled as parcels vans at rural stations, they were first and foremost intended for goods cartage, so I opted for red wheels, springs and shafts for my early 1900s period. As an aside, I'm never entirely confident about livery references in the Railway Magazine of the 1900s, but that is another story.

 

 

13a.jpg.4bfb2c806a9d8cbc6b5b717bd55e2dae.jpg

 

Then along came Charlie, new to the GWR stables. Young and hopeful, he dreamt of a career in tap dancing and an endless supply of Cheese & Cucumber sandwiches.

 

 

15a.jpg.b260dc76eda7934144cbf1e20308ab15.jpg

 

We quickly put an end to that! Here he is being modified with extra harness.

 

 

16a.jpg.9d121de8f7d936e641c89eceff1b1900.jpg

 

I modelled the harness so that it loosely indicates the method used to pull fixed-shaft wagons, while also allowing the wagon to rest on the back of the now disillusioned Charlie. This solved the problem of balancing a one-axle vehicle. 

 

 

18a.jpg.09ba872f07478ae5cf0d3c1423a7c231.jpg

 

The tilt was made from plain paper, with the lettering copied from the reference photo. Period photos show that tilts of this type were very taut, with the impression of the hoop sticks sometimes showing through. To indicate this I wetted the paper and formed it around the hoop sticks.

 

 

17a.jpg.ed448e71ea8fc1daecc0cc27407c8525.jpg

 

The tarp was then varnished several times, and holes punched in the sides to emulate how it was fixed in place. I wish I had used the number of a wagon that hadn't been photographed, as that would have solved the problem of inconsistencies between the drawings and the reference photo!

 

 

19a.jpg.63357cc84b349bee2d88a246dbc00bec.jpg

 

The reference photo shows two thin and rather unsightly boards along the sides of the tilt, presumably to pin it down further and stabilise it. I made them from masking tape.

 

 

20.jpg.3e466f4dfddc93100a15970bfc0ff8ca.jpg

 

The lettering in the reference photo shows a style used during the 1890s (sometimes with, sometimes without the "Co."). I pieced it together from a couple of photos using this style.

 

 

 

22.jpg

 

The tilt had separate protective tarps fitted on the inside of the hoops at the front and rear. Again, these were simply made from paper. Photos suggest that in daily practice the rear "flap" on horsedrawn vehicles was often secured in half-open or fully open position.

 

 

23.jpg

 

Lastly the wheels hubs were fitted, made from a styrene tube and filled with putty.

 

 

IMG_20191219_113448552.jpg

 

So that's it. I won’t be fitting reins at this point, as I have to set up my layouts every time I want to run trains, so reins are just not practical. In this view you can see that the wheels are Lasercut, but it's OK from normal viewing distance.

 

 

IMG_20191219_113528417_HDR.jpg

 

There are photos of fixed-shaft vehicles resting like this in GWR yards. Smaller carts without a tilt were sometimes, er, tilted the other way.

 

 

IMG_20191219_113212310_HDR.jpg

 

By and large, Charlie appears to have accepted his fate. Though sometimes, out of the corner of my eye, I can see him doing a secret little tap dance.

 

 

IMG_20191219_122939816.jpg

 

Lastly a view of the horsedrawn GWR fleet at Farthing as it currently appears. So much for corporate identity! 

 

 

  • Like 15
  • Craftsmanship/clever 27

41 Comments


Recommended Comments



  • RMweb Gold

Tony Atkins discusses an 1869 survey of the economy of the GWR's horse stock (admittedly a rather early date). He has a comment that captures the no-nonsense approach (vol 1 p66 of GW Goods Cartage): "the initial quality of bought-in animals, and the work they had to do, governed the average length of service of GWR horses which was, at that time, about 6 years. Taking into account the amounts received for worn-out and disabled horses, carcases and manure, a depreciation rate of 16% was employed by the GW". 

 

Later the average length of service for a horse seems to have improved.

 

@Simond, that's a nice quote by Lauire Lee. I read his Spanish book recently, must see if I can get hold of Cider with Rosie.

 

14 hours ago, DonB said:

But the driver appears to have to stand within the cart body as there is no seat or foot-rest, although he would have some protection from the weather under the tarp.

 

I have a driver in the making. Some GWR designs had a built-in box for the driver to sit on, while in other cases it seems to have been "loose"-fitted. I expect some drivers simply improvised. The following photos show driver's boxes. 

 

https://www.warwickshirerailways.com/gwr/gwrhd745.htm

https://www.warwickshirerailways.com/gwr/gwrhd748.htm

 

The last one is a favourite picture of mine, and also shows a 'chain horse' in use.

Edited by Mikkel
  • Like 1
Link to comment

One of the things I found a bit difficult, was finding details of the harness etc., arrangements, I eventually got there.
I know I model in 4mm scale and therefore small detail is lost, so is not worth adding ?  But as a retired Engineer, I like to know how things work, are arranged etc., then I go off ........... :jester:

  • Like 4
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

 

I think harness detail is definitely worth it in 4mm scale. But I have to set up the layout every time I want to run something - which doesn't take long but does mean that detailed harness is impractical so far, especially as the vehicles are stored like this: 

 

010.jpg.a94774ada47ccbb8267838f51bef2dd7.jpg.d46c3ee3a436a6c71e17ce7e1301eac3.jpg

 

Looking at photos suggested that the harness arrangement for fixed shaft one-axle vehicles were a bit different from moving ones. Here's a small float with what seems to have been a typical arrangement.

 

CslZPuHXEAAK6-m.jpg.7895db346429b2425e58f06845001b08.jpg

 

One photo of a single-axle GWR vehicle shows extra padding added to relieve the strain on the back of the horse. 

 

 

Edited by Mikkel
  • Like 2
Link to comment

Has to be different!  

 

If you have a one - axle cart, the shafts have to attach to the horse in such a way that the cart cannot tip forwards (weight on the horse’s withers) or backwards (lifting the horse by means of its girth strap).

 

if you were to do this on a two axle cart, you’d either crush the poor horse as you lifted the front axle off the ground, or the horse would be dangling from its girth straps!

 

Of course with a badly loaded single axle cart...

 

image.jpeg.9837afdc80db807e84d25d250a8ca0b4.jpeg

 

not great for the poor horse :(

 

  • Like 2
  • Friendly/supportive 1
Link to comment
20 hours ago, Simond said:

 

There were about 3.5 million horses in the uk at the turn of the 1900’s. Assuming a twenty year life, that would suggest nigh on 500 dying each day.  That’s around 200 tons of dead horse to dispose of, daily!

 

atb

Simon

 

A huge number of horses were "borrowed " for military service in 1914-on. which would rather upset the above calculation.

  • Agree 1
Link to comment
4 hours ago, DonB said:

 

A huge number of horses were "borrowed " for military service in 1914-on. which would rather upset the above calculation.

 

Don,

 

You're right, and, additionally, my guesstimation of an average horse life was way out too, they didn’t live anything like that long in hard service.  

 

My 20 years was far too modern, hobby-horse, not working horse a century ago.

 

atb

Simon

  • Like 2
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold
On 22/12/2019 at 22:17, Compound2632 said:

There were, I believe, plenty of uses for dead horse.

Stuck with you flogging that one, are we?

;)

 

  • Like 1
  • Funny 2
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

A fascinating read and fab modelling Mikkel - great to see your techniques explained for forming the difficult curved parts :yes:

 

Am intrigued by the Cheese and Cucumber sandwich too...:O

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Thanks again Pete. As for curving polystyrene strips in hot water, I have found that results are improved by doing it twice. I.e. when the water has cooled, I repeat with a fresh bowl of boiled water.  This is a bit more wasteful of course, but over a year of modelling we are after all talking about very small quantities of water. Maybe I should skip one shower a year to compensate :locomotive:

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

This is a photo, or rather a rather poor marriage of a couple of photos, of a membership certificate from the London Carmen's Trades Union. It was presented to one of my wife's relatives in 1895 and is now with another relative who is a retired union general secretary. It is interesting in that it shows several of the carman's tasks, not just driving the car/cart but mucking out, harnessing etc. It is a large document - almost A2 to my recollection.

Edward_Webb_carman_certificate1895.jpg

  • Like 5
  • Informative/Useful 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

Clearly envisioning the day when the means of production - or at least cartage - would be in the hands of the workers, or at least their union. The Railways are still in private hands though, judging by the cart piled high with boxes marked GNR, GER, GW and SER.

  • Agree 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold
5 hours ago, phil_sutters said:

This is a photo, or rather a rather poor marriage of a couple of photos, of a membership certificate from the London Carmen's Trades Union. It was presented to one of my wife's relatives in 1895 and is now with another relative who is a retired union general secretary. It is interesting in that it shows several of the carman's tasks, not just driving the car/cart but mucking out, harnessing etc. It is a large document - almost A2 to my recollection.

 

 

Interesting document Phil! Makes me wonder how the railway carters and van lads were organised. I suppose they preferred a railway-specific union.

 

Ironically at this time the GWR (and perhaps also other companies) were on a drive to do more cartage of their own, cancelling agreements with local cartage agents.

  • Informative/Useful 1
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...