Jump to content
 

G.W.R. 2 Plank Wagon part 2


wenlock

1,518 views

Back in mid August I posted an entry in the blog about the construction of the GWR 2 plank wagon.

 

Well since those balmy days Autumn has hit with a vengeance in South Wales, we're back in full lockdown and it hasn't stopped raining!  Still the upside of this is that there's not much else to do other than a bit of modelling:)

 

The model was more or less completed and ready for painting , but I struggled to find a prototype photograph of a 2 planker in my admittedly fairly small book collection.   Fortunately Mikkel came to the rescue and pointed me in the right direction and so my model is based on number 19451 as running in 1902. 

 

Model waiting for paint

IMG_3395a.jpg.c04689eb7ba8c461413b3d50b66b2758.jpg

 

The first thing that struck me upon looking at the prototype photograph were that the buffers were off a completely different pattern to the ones that I had used from Slater's :rolleyes:  The one's in the photograph had a round base and "fins" leading down towards the buffer heads.  I couldn't find anything suitable after a search online and as I rather like the brass shanks on Slater's buffers decided to modify some from this manufacturer.  Slaters do some round based buffers ostensibly for Midland wagons, but with a bit of modification I thought they would pass muster:)

 

Small sections of plastic card were glued to the buffer base and shank at 90 degree angles using cyanoacrylate glue, once this had set they were then shaped using a fine cut bur in a rotary handpiece.

 

Buffer housing modification

IMG_3464a.jpg.e140074bc674b57b0c449ebd38cda286.jpg

 

Assembled buffers

IMG_3466a.jpg.a3bcc6eb28859aac385794a2c5d37b25.jpg

 

There do appear to be subtle differences between the photograph of number 19451 that I'm modelling as shown in Atkins and the lovely 4mm wagon that Stephen is building.  The vertical strapping on the solebars is not present on the photograph that I'm working from and the corner plates exhibit far fewer rivets.  https://www.rmweb.co.uk/community/index.php?/topic/113035-more-pre-grouping-wagons-in-4mm-the-d299-appreciation-thread/page/118/

 

Gratuitous picture of the wagon on the layout checking that all is well before applying paint!

IMG_3509a.jpg.2e7788986cf22d77e9dbc33e5e553b6b.jpg

 

The wagon was primed with acid etch primer https://www.advancedpaints.co.uk/product/aerosol-1k-etch-primer-400ml/ and then painted using Humbrol Enamel paints.  I've tried to achieve a well weathered appearance, the wagon would have been built in the 1870s and so would be approaching 30 years old in the period that I am modelling.

 

Finished Wagon

IMG_3948a.jpg.a643a9c765ad7bacbb0ea6d71e53f785.jpg

 

IMG_3949a.jpg.29c7643d6221141561d071ff624fe438.jpg

 

 

Upon looking at the photos I think the wheels need a bit of toning down with some rust coloured paint!

 

Some maybe wondering what happened to the "Pickfords" container that I planed on the wagon carrying.  Well either the container is a millimeter too wide, or my wagon is a millimeter too narrow, but either way it wouldn't fit!:rolleyes:  In some respects I'm relieved because the writing at the bottom of the container  was obscured by the height of the sides and I think it will look better on a one plank wagon!

 

Until next time....

 

Best wishes

 

Dave

Edited by wenlock
Restore pictures

  • Like 18
  • Craftsmanship/clever 6

10 Comments


Recommended Comments

...the unused Pickfords container deserves a similarly convincing wagon to ride on:  I look forward to the one plank wagon which, no doubt, you're already studying in Atkins!

 

Nice load in 19451: it makes such a difference to be moving goods rather than just moving wagons (which is where I'm stilll at on Swan Hill).

 

Kit PW

  • Agree 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Thanks Kit, yes a single planker is on the cards :)  I think I can probably kit bash something using the Cooper craft match truck top with scratch built solebars.

 

I quite like making loads for wagons, I’ve built a few crates and boxes from plasticard as masters.  I’ve then made silicone moulds so I can produce as many as I need.


Swan Hill is going to be magnificent, I’m really enjoying watching it develop.

 

BW

 

Dave

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Hello Dave,

 

The Slater's kit for Glos. 7 plank wagons has a cast brass buffer stock which is very similar to your piece of work.

 

regards, Graham

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold
1 hour ago, Western Star said:

Hello Dave,

 

The Slater's kit for Glos. 7 plank wagons has a cast brass buffer stock which is very similar to your piece of work.

 

regards, Graham

Thanks Graham, I shall file that information away and it will save me faffing about next time!  I hope they are available to purchase as a separate item!

  • Like 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

What a gem, Dave!  I like your solution with the ribbed buffers, nothing will hold back a persistent modeller. 

 

I look forward to the one-planker. Will it be a GWR one? They are a bit of a minefield, as always :)

 

  • Agree 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

Interesting. I'm hoping to get my hands on my local copy of Atkins before the lockdown bites. Your 19451 is from os Lot 76. The photos I've been using all show wagons with the "more bolts" corner-plates:

1530432967_GWSaltneyLot402plankwagon.jpg.ee0e521092d6c4b43c3af152338f9e0f.jpg

 

One from os Lot 75: 19159 [Wood, plate 28]; three from os Lot 97: 20159 [Wood, plate 23], 20176 [Jackson & Tattershall], and 20181 [Wood, plate 32]; one unknown: 6683 [Jackson & Tattershall]; and one from os Lot 112, 20435 [Wood, plate 29]. Old series lots 75 and 112 were built at Saltney; I don't know where Lot 97 was built but it was presumably contemporary with Saltney's Lot 98, completed April 1874, just as Lot 76 is presumably contemporary with Saltney's Lot 75, completed December 1872. So I can only suppose that whichever works built Lot 97 was building wagons to the same pattern as Saltney, whereas the works building Lot 76 followed its own pattern - but which works? Paddington, Worcester, or Swindon? This is just the period when wagon construction was being concentrated at the new works at Swindon, Saltney's last new wagons being built in late 1874.

 

I presume inspection of the wagon register would resolve that question but of course not explain the difference in design.

 

References:

Tony Wood, Saltney Carriage and Wagon Works (The Wider View / Great Western Study Group, 2007)

B.L. Jackson and M.J. Tattershall, The Bridport Branch (OPC, 1976) photo of West Bay station, June 1900.

Edited by Compound2632
  • Thanks 1
  • Informative/Useful 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold
12 hours ago, Mikkel said:

What a gem, Dave!  I like your solution with the ribbed buffers, nothing will hold back a persistent modeller. 

 

I look forward to the one-planker. Will it be a GWR one? They are a bit of a minefield, as always :)

 

Thanks Mikkel:)  

 

I’d like to do a GWR wagon, I’ve been re-reading your inspirational posts about your 4mm version.  WEP do a 7mm kit, so I might treat myself to one of those:)  My only concern is that it will be a millimetre too narrow like the 2 plank version for the Pickfords container :rolleyes: Maybe some judicious surgery will overcome the issue!
 

I take it that there’s a picture of a suitable 1 planker in Atkins.  I really need to get myself a copy of that particular tome!
 

BW

 

Dave
 

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold
3 hours ago, Compound2632 said:

Interesting. I'm hoping to get my hands on my local copy of Atkins before the lockdown bites. Your 19451 is from os Lot 76. The photos I've been using all show wagons with the "more bolts" corner-plates:

1530432967_GWSaltneyLot402plankwagon.jpg.ee0e521092d6c4b43c3af152338f9e0f.jpg

 

One from os Lot 75: 19159 [Wood, plate 28]; three from os Lot 97: 20159 [Wood, plate 23], 20176 [Jackson & Tattershall], and 20181 [Wood, plate 32]; one unknown: 6683 [Jackson & Tattershall]; and one from os Lot 112, 20435 [Wood, plate 29]. Old series lots 75 and 112 were built at Saltney; I don't know where Lot 97 was built but it was presumably contemporary with Saltney's Lot 98, completed April 1874, just as Lot 76 is presumably contemporary with Saltney's Lot 75, completed December 1872. So I can only suppose that whichever works built Lot 97 was building wagons to the same pattern as Saltney, whereas the works building Lot 76 followed its own pattern - but which works? Paddington, Worcester, or Swindon? This is just the period when wagon construction was being concentrated at the new works at Swindon, Saltney's last new wagons being built in late 1874.

 

I presume inspection of the wagon register would resolve that question but of course not explain the difference in design.

 

References:

Tony Wood, Saltney Carriage and Wagon Works (The Wider View / Great Western Study Group, 2007)

B.L. Jackson and M.J. Tattershall, The Bridport Branch (OPC, 1976) photo of West Bay station, June 1900.

As you say interesting information and thank you for sharing it!  These early wagons are a bit of a minefield, but I suppose it all adds to the fun!
 

Ive sent you a PM

 

BW

 

Dave

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Just catching up, nicely done Dave and as stated before, and excellent home spun workaround for the buffer stocks.

 

G

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold
1 hour ago, bgman said:

Just catching up, nicely done Dave and as stated before, and excellent home spun workaround for the buffer stocks.

 

G

Thanks Grahame, a bit of paint hides a multitude of sins:)

 

BW

 

Dave

  • Friendly/supportive 1
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...