Jump to content
  • entries
    93
  • comments
    685
  • views
    124,516

Class 22 - Part 7

D869

933 views

The body gains its buffer beams, valences and roof panels.

 

... and I promise to write about something else one day

 

Buffer Beams

 

As far as I can tell the method of assembly intended by the Worsley Works kit involves two false cab floors to be soldered to the main body and a separate chassis built around a floor unit with two cutouts, presumably for motor bogies. The floor unit and the cab floors have etched holes, so I guess that the idea is that they should be bolted together. The side valences are provided with tabs to locate into slots in this floor unit. This sort of construction is clearly not going to be suitable when using a Farish or Atlas 'N' gauge chassis.

 

So where does that leave us? - the buffer beams and valence etchings seem to be a pretty reasonable representation of the prototype but without the etched floor from the kit there is not much to ensure correct alignment or to hold them in place with any real robustness.

 

I did a quick trial using one buffer beam and one side valence just to see if I was being pessimistic, but found that I was struggling with lots of unwieldy bits that didn't want to stay in the right place for soldering so it was time for a bit of a rethink.

 

The buffer beams are provided with four layers of overlay at each end where the buffers are mounted. I can't get a decent measurement from a drawing or photo to confirm this but 40 thou seems too thick to me and would leave the coupling hook and other things buried well underneath the nose. I therefore left two layers of overlay off.

 

The end of the nose is 20 thou thick and its bottom edge sits 1mm lower than the bottom edge of the body sides. I therefore filed 1mm off the top of the outermost buffer beam overlay which has the dual benefit of providing a good vertical location for the buffer beam, more joint area to solder and ensuring that the outer face of the overlay sits just 10 thou behind the outer face of the nose.

 

Assembling the buffer beams to the body still proved to be a pretty painful process. I wanted to use normal solder for this to give as much strength as possible, but this meant that the joints holding the various layers of the buffer beam together would come undone in the process. I only found a partial answer to this problem: I fitted the (N Brass LMS Oval) buffers to the buffer beams during assembly of the layers. This provides at least partial location for the various layers although everything is still free to rotate and separate when it gets hot again. The only answer to this was to keep trying and to remove and reassemble the buffer beam components after each failed attempt.

 

Holding things in place and ensuring correct alignment was also difficult. My solution (see picture) was not very elegant but it worked - I clamped the buffer beam in a pin vice and clamped this in the vice so that the beam was held horizontal. I kept a square alongside so that I could align the body by eye. Heath Robinson would be proud. I used plenty of flux and plenty of solder on the tip of the iron to try to get heat into the joint as quickly as possible. I think that both ends took three attempts before I was happy with them.

 

blogentry-9623-0-56823900-1300917278_thumb.jpg

 

Ideally I would have liked to leave the buffers off until later in the assembly. This would have given me better access for tidying up the valence corners and detailing the ends but it was not to be.

 

Side Valences

 

Class 22s seem to have had a habit of losing parts of their valences in later life. The remaining valences could also be pretty wonky. Checking the photos of the real D6309 showed that it had a complete set of valences on one side which appeared to fit reasonably well. On the other side it was missing the centre valence and the remaining valences were sticking out noticeably.

 

<edit>

Oops - Forgot to mention in the original post that before fitting the valences I filed a slight radius onto the bottom of the loco sides as per the prototype.

</edit>

 

For the side with the complete set of valences I just used the etch provided in the kit after creating a couple of slight bends where the cab side sheets start to taper inwards. I found that by adjusting these bends I could just about get it to stay in place although there is very little overlap with the buffer beams. I then held one corner in place with blu-tack while I soldered the corner at the other end. After soldering the remaining corner I tacked the valence on to the bottom of the sides at several points along its length before cleaning up the solder that had crept into visible areas.

 

On the other side I cut some strips of 5 thou nickel silver to represent the sticking out valences. These were made so that they had a decent overlap to solder inside the body but still stayed below the louvres. Fixing these involved some trial and error before the alignment was good enough, but there weren't any major problems.

 

Finally I held my breath and cut the remaining side valence etch so that just the bits under the cabs could be fitted to the loco. These were then lined up and soldered in place, starting at the buffer beam end. There is practically no overlap to hold these in place so once they were tacked in place I added a small strengthening strip of 5 thou nickel silver behind the valences and sides just inboard of the cab doors.

 

Fixing the Roof

 

This was another nerve-wracking process but it went quite smoothly in the end.

 

I held the overlay in place with a blob of blu-tack at each end and after carefully checking the alignment I drew around it with a CD marker pen. The body and overlay were then cleaned, fluxed and tinned all of the way around the edge of the overlay. After cleaning up any thick bits of solder, the overlay was then put back into place, held with blu-tack and checked again (twice) for alignment.

 

Once the alignment was OK, I sweated two corners on the same side into place. I found that getting enough heat into the joint was tricky. The technique that I used was to run flux into the joint, paint flux onto the outside of the overlay and then put some solder onto the bit of the iron and immediately wipe it off on the sponge. This leaves a tiny residue of fresh solder on the bit which (with the help of the flux) is enough to transfer the heat into the joint without leaving a big unsightly blob afterwards. I pressed the overlay down using a small piece of card to (partially) insulate my finger. I still found that my finger got pretty hot though.

 

Having done the first two corners and re-checked the alignment, I removed the blu-tack and made the joints in the centre of the cab roofs before doing the last two corners. Hopefully this sequence of doing things helped to avoid creating any wrinkles. Finally I sweated the two sides down, starting in the middle and then filling in the gaps.

 

Once this was done I cleaned up any excess solder and then soldered the boiler vent and engine room panels into place in a similar way. I had made a new boiler vent panel because D6309 doesn't have this plated over.

 

Next Steps

 

The pictures below show the current state of play, albeit spoiled by the flash bouncing off the bare metal - it looks a lot better in real life. Note the China Clay wagon pressed into service to hold all of the fiddly bits that aren't yet on the loco. The loco has also gained some finescale wheelsets temporarily stolen from my Atlas GP7 while its own wheels get sent off to the 2mm Association wheel turning service.

 

There is still a lot more to do - I'm currently working through a list of jobs that I need to complete before D6309 goes into the paint shop. Most of these are pretty mundane but necessary things like making a proper fixing between the body and the chassis.

 

blogentry-9623-0-53886800-1300917393_thumb.jpg

blogentry-9623-0-99757800-1300917414_thumb.jpg



9 Comments


Recommended Comments

Just been catching up on your blog and must say, looking really nice there Andy.

 

You start to forget how small your modelling in, then the shot with pin vice and tweezers, brings it back to reality. Love the 3/4 shot of it parked in the sidings, giving me some inspiration to get my layout finished this Summer.

 

Cheers

Trevor

Share this comment


Link to comment

Looks good Andy - really looks the part now after all the hard work.

 

I do enjoy following a good series...do you think we will get to see a title Class 22 - Part 22 :D

 

Good to see that china clay open too - Is this on the small layout that you moonlight on outside of St Ruth?

Share this comment


Link to comment

Trevor: Thanks. I've been modelling in 2mm for a long time so it doesn't really seem small to me. It does have its advantages in terms of being able to portray a bigger scene as we are doing with our group layout - St Ruth. For a bit of balance I also have some 16mm trains that appear occasionally in the garden.

 

Pete: Yes, this is South Yard... which also doubles as my test track and parking location for incomplete models - it's more difficult to forget about them if they are on show all the time. Because it's so small I can't fit too many half finished things in so it encourages me to get on and finish stuff. I haven't forgotten that I've promised to post more about the layout... although you can see pretty much half of it in the photos.

 

Regards, Andy

Share this comment


Link to comment

Andy,

 

that really is looking right on the money - and as Trevor H notes above, the quality of your work makes you forget this is 2mm. I similarly have a number of the Parkwood OOVs (pre hood for me too).

 

This blog is an inspiration - I remember the tail end of the Warship's - just, and being a Bucks lad, also saw the last of the Hymeks circa 74/75 as well as the Westerns. Have developed a massive soft spot for the 6300's - can't honestly say I remember seeing them, just an incredibly characterful 1st gen diesel - and like you said at the outset, a must for a Devon or Cornwall layout set pre 72.

 

I am about to have to dismantle my own layout for redecoration of the children's playroom, which once decorated, will give them an area to play in, (and, ahem, me, a 3 metre by 0.7m or so area for a layout again). There were some cracking photos of Drump Lane goods depot near Redruth that inspired me on a previous version of RM Web, but I don't seem to be able to find them now. I like the idea of having some stock on show, and an excuse for a bit of shunting, without the compromise of trying to condense Par or St Erth down into unworkable size.

 

Anyway - your work looks fantastic, the MP15 chassis does look spot on in terms of wheelbase, and honestly, if I achieved results half as good as you have I would be thrilled. I will continue to watch with admiration and interest.

 

Regards

 

Matt Wood

Share this comment


Link to comment

Thanks Matt - glad to hear from another WR fan.

 

I hope you manage to track those photos down because I can't recall ever having seen many pics of Drump Lane - the only one I can think of is in GWR days.

 

I look forward to reading about your new layout in RMWeb soon!

 

Regards, Andy

Share this comment


Link to comment

Thanks Matt - love the pics.

 

Looks like the Roskear branch terminus would make another excellent micro layout. I've never seen a pic of the place other than an aerial photo before.

 

Regards, Andy

Share this comment


Link to comment

Looks like the Roskear branch terminus would make another excellent micro layout.

 

was just thinking the same myself earlier... ;)

Share this comment


Link to comment

I've been looking at these photos some more and checking the very sketchy info elsewhere.

 

The sidings depicted seem to be north and south of the Foundry Lane level crossing and the works are Holmans No 3 Foundry. This was not the original terminus... and possibly not the terminus at all even at the time of the photo. Mr RA Cooke's plans say that Holman's bought the line North of MP 313.34 in 1970. I'm guessing that 313.34 was just North of the crossing where Maurice Dart's West Cornwall Mineral Railways book has a photo of some steel gates which you can also just about see in the second photo.

 

According to Mr Cooke, the line by the dock was a short loop installed in 1966 which rejoined the branch before the level crossing. North of the crossing there was one siding to the right of the line and two to the left.

 

The first photo tells quite a story really - steel ingots and either coal or coke sat on the loading dock with more ingots in the wagon. On the left are a couple of (con?)flats with compressors on them. My first assumption was that this was some sort of PW train but then I realised that the CompAir compressors are brand new and are probably the products manufactured by Holmans being dispatched by rail.

 

As an aside, page 40 of 'Heyday of the Hydraulics shows D1039 at Paddington in 1970 with a big advert for Holmans compressors behind it.

 

Ah... for the days when Britain had a manufacturing industry.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.