Jump to content
  • entries
    11
  • comments
    103
  • views
    14,875

Cattle Train - GWR (2mm FS)

Gingerbread

1,419 views

Although it's not obvious from the product list, the 2mm Association kits provide a good start for building GWR cattle wagons - known as MEX (or should that be MEXes?) for identification purposes.

blogentry-10888-0-34139100-1324034909_thumb.jpg

 

The Association body kit 2-561 is intended for a BR cattle wagon (Diag 1/353) which is very similar to the late GWR cattle wagons of diagram W12. By substituting the Association 2-363 underframe (11'6" DC) for the recommended 2-352 underframe, you can easily build the GWR W8 diagram of 1913 (the underframe kit helpfully includes replacement doors, providing the earlier style of lower horizontal planks, rather than higher vertical ones).

 

However, I wanted something earlier, so a slightly more radical piece of kit-bashing was required. The following are candidates for my period (1900-1910):

W1, size=large, 1200+ built from 1888 to 1904

W2, size=medium, 300+ built from 1878 to 1982 (outside-framed)

W3, size=small, 99 built in 1888

W5, size=large (but convertible), 575 built 1902-1911

 

Briefly summarising the later versions, all of which are similar size to W5:

W8, 700 built 1913-1927

W10/W11 300+ built 1923-1928, as W8 but with Morton either-side brakes (ie as BR cattle wagon with GWR doors)

W12 200+ built 1929-1933, as BR cattle wagon

 

For the purpose of completeness, I should also mention W4, which was the "special" or "pedigree" cattle wagon, fitted to run in passenger trains. Of similar size to the W1 or W5 large cattle wagons, it had louvres at the top instead of open space, and no external bracing on the sides. Vacuum brake gear was similar to fruit and meat vans, and similarly it ran on passenger wheels (3'6" solid instead of 3' spoked ). About 50 were built, from 1888 to 1898. Later versions were larger (about 26 ft long), with a cattle compartment each end and a central attendants' compartment, and formed diagrams W6, W7, W13 and W14, about 50 in total being built.

 

And finally the missing W9 was for two cattle wagons for the Vale of Rheidol railway.

 

As cattle traffic moved form rail to road, various cattle wagons became surplus to requirements, and were converted to carry fruit or ale in 1939.

 

Based on numbers built, and assuming my train is of six wagons, it should probably be something like 4 x W1, 1 x W2, 1 x W5. I haven't yet obtained or built a W2, but will be building a W3 instead.

 

Simplest to produce in 2mm scale is actually the W5, which is largely similar to the W8. So I started with the 2-561 body and 2-363 underframe, cut out the upper part of the doors and substituted the etched ones from the underframe kit. So far this follows the W8 conversion.

 

blogentry-10888-0-15088900-1324034950_thumb.jpg

 

Next came the more challenging parts - the ends require X-shaped flat cross-bracing, instead of L or T-shaped diagonal supports. Perhaps the ends from the early mink body (2-525) could be used instead - but the body is solid, so that would require a lot of cutting and filing.

 

So I carefully filed off the diagonals from the 2-561 body, (re-)scored planks then added some thin strips of styrene to simulate the cross-bracing. These thin strips are actually square in cross-section, rather than flat bars, so need a little gentle flattening when soft while they are being added. Meanwhile care must be taken to try to avoid leaving various distortions (such as fingerprints) in the softened surface of the ends.

 

The other significant difference is that the roof is much flatter, so I filed the ends lower/flatter, and decided to discard the plastic roof and replace it with an etched one from 2-336 (actually designed for LMS, but I think they are acceptable for GWR).

 

Brake gear had various options, DC1 or DC2, with or without vacuum, 8-shoe clasp or 2/4 shoe wagon block style. The one I have built is DC1 with two shoe wagon brakes - which means I should probably snip off the tiebars (which were fitted only to those with vacuum brakes, i.e. DC2).

 

Two things probably worth mentioning here -

1)From the prototype perspective, this (W5) saw the introduction of the Wright-Marillier locking device which allowed the partitions in the van to be moved - so that the space available could be approximately 18' (large), 15' (medium) or 13' (small) in length. Thus small and medium wagons were no longer needed, and no more were built.

2) From the model perspective, fitting DC brake levers is painfully difficult - the holes in the etched levers are too small for wire to pass through, and too small for any broach I had at the time to pass through. And furthermore there isn't really enough spare metal around the hole to allow it to be safely opened out. The best two suggestions to date are:

i) Use the smallest available broach - nominally 0.4mm, from the 0.4mm to 1.4mm set, instead of the 0.6mm I had at the time (Noel Leaver)

ii) Chop off the end with a hole, and solder the remaining lever direct to the frame (Richard Brummitt)

Fortunately there are plenty of spare levers provided (4 on each GWR DC etch, of which two are needed).

 

blogentry-10888-0-48115700-1324034992_thumb.jpg

 

The W1 conversion is similar, but the design predates the introduction of DC brake gear, so there are two plausible options:

1) Use the same underframe style as W5, on the basis that many of the W1 cattle wagons were later updated to DC brake gear (and often fitted with vacuum brakes)

2) Use the intended 2-352 underframe (plus doors from 2-363) to build conventional brakes, with single sided lever.

I intend to have some of each, but primarily in the "old" version with non-DC brakes, as these should probably be the more common in this period.

 

blogentry-10888-0-26855600-1324035019_thumb.jpg

 

W2 should be available as an etch from Stuart Bailey - I've not acquired any yet, so they aren't covered here.

 

Most interesting is the W3 version - although rare, I think I can justify one as an attractive alternative to the W1/W5 large cattle wagons (and not much more work).

 

For the 8'6" wheelbase underframe I chose the RCH chassis number 2-326, which needs a little filing off the ends to shorten it to 14 ft length. Unfortunately there isn't really enough space available to shorten it, without weakening the fold-down support for DG couplings, so I decided on an additional change - I soldered a single layer of brass etch to the underframe for the headstock, and filed the headstock off the plastic ends - thus reducing length by about a mm each end. For the ends of the body I used the BR cattle wagon kit, with similar filing and rebuilding to obtain cross-bracing.

 

blogentry-10888-0-44408800-1324035058_thumb.jpg

 

The sides came from the 1907 RCH 7-plank wagon (2-552), but these needed shortening from 16 ft to 14 ft, by taking about 2mm from each end - which unfortunately meant that the diagonals on the sides no longer run quite to the corners. I cut out the top part of the doors, and glued in replacement doors from another DC underframe etch. Floor was scratchbuilt from styrene - probably as quick to scratchbuild as to shorten either of the existing kit floors.

 

blogentry-10888-0-12452900-1324035101_thumb.jpg

 

As is usual with my models at this point, they are "mostly complete" - meaning that roof/body/underframe haven't yet been attached (and need some fettling to fit properly), and though most are painted, the lettering and weathering are still to be done. In particular, the W3 needs some styrene strips added to the sides to represent the various vertical and horizontal framing missing from the upper half. At this point, the horizontal bars are missing from all of them - I have my doubts whether these would be visible at normal viewing range, so I may leave it off. I suspect that to the correct scale they would be about half the diameter of the smallest readily available wire (i.e. about 0.15mm).

 

In defence of my cavalier cannibalisation of 2-363 underframe etches for the replacement doors, I have identified alternative uses for the rest of these kits. Unfortunately there appear to be no other suitable GWR designs using the 11'6" wheelbase (a failure of Churchward's standardisation policies?). Possibly the Serpents might fit (almost), but the only one that's correct wheelbase is the G8, which dates from about 1870 and had wooden underframes, and only about 20 built, whilst G21 which had DC brakes, albeit on 11 ft wheelbase, was a bit late (1907 to 1913), with only about 30 built. G9 remains a possibility, 11 ft wheelbase and conventional brakes, with about 70 built. But all these have a couple of significant problems - the floor needs lowering, except at the ends, and in most cases the sides (which are about 6 inches high) need some holes drilled in them.

 

There were numerous North Staffordshire Railway wagons using an 11' to 12' wheelbase and 18' to 19' overall length - not only the obvious cattle wagons, but 2 and 3-plank open wagons. I intend to build some of these later, converting the underframes back to conventional brakes.

 

Livery and Lettering - I intend the W5 to be grey with 25" lettering, whilst the W1/W3 (and W2 if/when I add it) to be (mostly) GWR red with 5" lettering - possibly cast plates for one or two of the W1s. Not forgetting the liberal application of lime wash, which would probably be seen dribbling down the outside (this stopped around the mid-1920s, when it was banned for potential damage to cattle's hooves).

 

David

 

PS Apologies for quality of photos - I will use lack of sunshine as today's excuse.

  • Like 3


6 Comments


Recommended Comments

Aargh! You fill my head with too many ideas of things to make and do. A couple of observations but most noticeably I would not consider a diagram with around 100 vehicles in to be particularly rare, even though the most common had several thousand. On almost the same theme I am currently building some W7s.

Share this comment


Link to comment

David,

 

I intend to build at least 2 x W1 cattle wagons (your preferred moelling era is the same as mine), I have a 2mm Scale Association rigid 11'0" underframe (which carries the part no. S5-067, bought in the mid '90s) which I purchased specifically for one. I was originally going to scratchbuild mine but using the 2mm Assoc BR version seems a much more attractive proposition now (although I would probably make my own top doors to save buying a chassis kit that I probably won't use)

 

Ian

Share this comment


Link to comment

Thanks for the comments

 

Richard -

Yes, "rare" is probably putting it a bit too strongly. I intended to make the point that W1 should dominate the cattle wagon fleet on any GWR layout, and W3 should be present at about 1/12 of the numbers of the W1 (which would typically be "none").

I heard that you were showing a "special" cattle wagon on the 2mm stand somewhere recently - at Peterborough I think ? Unfortunately a W7 would be too modern for me, but I'm tempted by the idea of converting the BR cattle wagon body to a W4 - haven't decided whether to lengthen your NPC underframe or use the DC 11'6" frame with 6mm solid wheels and conventional brake levers (and 8 clasp brakes).

 

Ian -

Agreed - I think it would definitely be worthwhile to use the BR cattle wagon for the sides. Scratch-building the ends might still be the better option - I am not really happy with mine, as there is still a "shadow" of the diagonal strapping that I have filed off, and the new X-strapping is a bit rough. However, I am not too worried about the quality of the ends, the sides are much more visible.

 

David

Share this comment


Link to comment
Unfortunately a W7 would be too modern for me

 

Are you sure? According to Atkins et al. the first ones were built in Edwardian times. ;) I had to have 4 made to meet the MOQ so at least two are going spare. The W4 would have been a rare beast.

Share this comment


Link to comment

Richard -

 

My reading of Atkins et al is as follows:

W4 - 53 built, 1888-1898

W7 - 30 built, 1909-1926

 

So I see all of the 53 W4s as being available in my period (wherever it finally settles between 1900 and 1910), whereas some of the W7s would be too late, even if I settled right at the latest date in the range.

 

[Looking again, I suspect 20 of the W7s could scrape into my period, 10 couldn't, which is more hopeful.]

 

Having said that, if you do have one looking for a good home, then I think I could stretch that far - looking again at my original plans for adding grilles to the BR cattle wagon to convert it to a W4, together with rebuilding the ends, removing the strapping from the sides, it's not a trivial conversion.

 

Thanks for the offer - add it to the pile for when we next meet (St Albans?), unless you find a taker that it suits better in terms of date.

 

So next I need to research the appropriate livery for a W7 built in 1909-1910 - grey or brown (I think crimson lake was a bit later - 1916?).

 

Then to work out some plausible numbers from the two different sequences (though I think they would be difficult to read at normal viewing range). Assuming it was amongst the first lot (of 20), it looks like 68464-83 in the goods sequence, then renumbered as 981-1000 in passenger.

 

David

Share this comment


Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.