The attention to detail is great! But if it´s supposed to be a pedigree Terrier, then there is still some way to go. I struggle with the proportions and lines of certain elements. As I was afraid of, the design appears to be based on Dapols O gauge model, meaning a lot of errors are carried over:
- the roof shape seems to be wrong
- the cab windows are too far apart
- the smokeboxes (especially on the A1s) feel too short
- The A1X smokebox protrudes too little in front of its base, therefore the frontmost side strip of rivets ends at the base, although the rivets go on some prototypes all the way round (32661 was one of them).
- the smokebox doors feel also too flat
- the balance weight on the middle wheels has the wrong shape
- The coupling rods are completely straight, despite the prototype having a subtle bow. Compare it with the Hornby model, Hornby on the other hand has overdone said bow.
- the bottom line of the wooden brake shoes is misaligned
- the tank vents are way too long
- the balance weights on Boxhills wheels are not picked out in green, as already described by Edwardian
- Yes, the tank top recess is there. But the recessed area should be black, already mentioned by Edwardian as well.
Then there are also a few shortcomings the O gauge model did not have:
- the black beams (?) on top of the dome protrude too far out vertically
- the inner part of the buffers is far too thin
- the scary coal rails for 32661 have already been mentioned by Edwardian
Sorry for the long list. Even though there are a lot of good things about the first samples to be said - I think Edwardian did a very good job in pointing them out - there is still a lot to be done. Obviously some of the mentioned errors are rather minor, but others are not. Let´s hope Dapol and Rails take their time for the necessary amendments.