Hi Phil, the short answer is no, the 'UK Model Shops' website is primarily concerned with model railway clubs, hence its name.
Yes, it does make reference to a some non-model railway societies, but that is not the focus of the website, and it is very far from comprehensive in that regard.
The RCD covers traditional railway societies only meaning:
1. National railway clubs (like RCTS, LCGB and SLS),
2. Specialised national railway societies (like the Industrial Railway Society and Narrow Gauge Railway Society),
3. Historical 'line' societies (like the Great Central Railway Society, the North Eastern Railway Association and the Midland Railway Society) and
4. Local railway clubs.
It does not include pure model railway clubs for two reasons:
1. The reason you have pointed out, i.e., model rail clubs are already well catered for through a variety of existing websites.
2. There is estimated to be something like 400 model rail clubs of some form or another in the UK (many are small without any internet presence, so the exact number is uncertain). Anyway, if you mix model rail clubs with the 100 traditional societies under my above definition, you completely crowd out those traditional societies.
The RCD has created for traditional societies (as defined) their own space, something they currently do not have. Perhaps that is way so many of the clubs are supporting it.
Also, the information provided by RCD on each club is comprehensive. It is not a list with a few basic points and a link. The entries are all approved by the clubs themselves and contain a considerable amount of detail.
Far from being just a list, the RCD has many elements as described, (i) a printed directory running into about 200 pages, (ii) a forthcoming dedicated website, and (iii) a dedicated social media presence.
Hopefully all railway clubs will thrive. Some at the moment are doing better than others. The smaller local railway clubs (non-modelling) are particularly suffering at the moment. Lets hope they all survive post covid. The chairmen of some have told me that for them it is touch and go.
Thanks for raising your points. Hopefully I've answered them.