msw2009
-
Posts
81 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Blogs
Gallery
Events
Exhibition Layout Details
Store
Posts posted by msw2009
-
-
On 07/01/2023 at 21:22, jackrob said:
A class 465 networker please!!
In N gauge, of course, after the Electrostars ...
Mark
-
2
-
-
1 hour ago, John M Upton said:
All I can find is issues 2 and 3 listed together?
I already have issue 2.
I found exactly the same a little earlier but if you go back to Ebay now Issue 3 is on sale on its own for £4.95 + p&p.
Grahame - Delighted to see another issue - I've thoroughly enjoyed issues 1 & 2. Hope this isn't the last one.
Mark
-
Has there been any statement on the development of other, previously announced new / modified tooling such as the 450 and sound fitted 5MT?
Thanks,
Mark
-
I picked up NSE 319 004 from the always helpful Great Eastern Models yesterday. It's a lovely model but the pantograph, which is very fragile, hadn't been assembled properly and fell to pieces as soon as it was very gently removed from its packaging. I tried to reassemble it but it seemed to be missing a tiny pin so reluctantly had to return it. It's the only one they had in stock so will have to wait a couple of days for a replacement to arrive. I wondered whether to just glue it in place - I model 3rd rail Southern so wouldn't ever run it with the pantograph up, but didn't really want to drop just shy of £300 on an imperfect model.
Mark
-
1
-
1
-
-
Just noticed the RRP has risen to £349.95 - £297.46 with the 15% discount at Rails, TMC, Kernow etc. Not wholly inconsistent with current inflation rates (BoE prediction of 7.25% next month) but still painful. Will have to have that 'do I or don't I?' debate again, although will probably reach the same conclusion I reached after the last increase.
Mark
-
Those Revolution figures on sound are interesting. My local model shop, the wonderful Great Eastern Models, recently told me that over 50% of their loco / mu sales are sound fitted (either factory fitted or subsequently added) these days. This is mostly 00 gauge of course, but sound equipped n gauge models (on the rare occasions they get any new models to sell of course) fly off their mostly bare n gauge shelves.
I haven't dipped a toe in the sound fitted world yet, but I am tempted by the forthcoming 5MT and, @grahame, would queue for months in the snow for a sound fitted 2EPB.
Mark
-
37 minutes ago, Davexoc said:
Not by NGS standards. The Hunslet shunter was the 50th Anniversary model, the anniversary year was 2017.....
This is true, but (and I'm referring specifically to n gauge here, although the same may well be the case for other gauges) pretty much every manufacturer has experienced fairly considerable delays with at least some of their releases in the last few years for a variety of well discussed reasons - developments in Chinese manufacturing practice, Brexit, Covid, supply chain crises, shortages of and rising costs of raw materials, wages etc. to name just a few. Admittedly in some cases (and Dapol's WC / BoB is looming large in my mind as I write this) the delays are to some degree self inflicted, it's often the case that global events completely beyond a producer's control have conspired against them. It's been a pretty challenging few years for Farish / Bachmann, Dapol and the NGS and even the brilliant newer entrants to the market - Revolution, Sonic etc have seen some delivery times stretch to a level way beyond what they'd anticipated and planned for.
I think the Farish 319, which is due early 2022, was announced in 2016 - quite a wait and although it's a little outside my timeframe, I'll definitely be picking one up. We can reasonably question some of the decisions that manufacturers make on which models to prioritise (do we really need a RTC TSO before any one of countless blue/grey, green, maroon, choc & cream mk1s?), but I take the view that rather than bash them (and any other n gauge producers) for taking so long to get a model on the shelves, I'm just grateful that, in the climate of the last few years, they've made the effort to (hopefully shortly) get it there at all.
Getting back to the NGS Hunslet - I think the Society have stuck their necks on the line a little with this and should be highly commended for it. I can't wait for mine to arrive. I wonder if the DCC ready 03s and 04s would have appeared quite so soon if the NGS hadn't broken some considerable ground.
Mark
-
1
-
-
13 minutes ago, AY Mod said:
Disappointing comment.
In light of the positive noises Bachmann made to Osborns about the Farish range 3 months ago (copied below from the Summer Announcements thread) it's hardly unreasonable to express mild disappointment.
Posted May 5
just had this from the horse's mouth and more encouraging for Farish hopes
"I can also assure you that if you get asked and I am sure you will, Graham Farish has not been forgotten just wait until the Autumn launch, rest assured we have some very exciting models en route.
I can't see a whole lot here that's very exciting, or even slightly exciting, for n gauge modellers in fairness. I guess they've maybe had some unexpected delays.
Mark
-
4
-
6
-
-
Mine arrived this morning and I'm very impressed. I've only skimmed through so far but, there's a good and varied selection of 'How to' articles along with some good layout and product features. I'll be particularly interested to read more on London Bridge - I'd been keenly following developments in the NGS Journal when Grahame was Editor and will be very happy to read more. I'd always been fairly ambivalent about the A4 v A5 debate, but this (A4) magazine is as persuasive an argument as I can imagine for the Society to upsize - visually it's a big improvement.
It seems like it's selling very well so I hope there will be further issues in due course. If there is - Grahame, would you publish a track plan for London Bridge?
Mark
-
1
-
-
18 hours ago, Dorsetmike said:
More negative I'm afraid, when - if ever - will somebody produce some pre WW2 SR 4-6-0s, there are 2 white metal kits somewhat long inthe tooth (Langley S15, BHE N15 both of which had some variants) No Lord Nelson.
Sum total of SR steam RTR pre WW2- N class, Schools class, T9, 700, 0395 M7, Terrier, C class, WW2 and after Spam cans, Q1; compare that with N gauge from any of the other 3 grouping companies, all of which have plenty of 4-6-0s available among other types.
Reminds me of a Catch 22 situation - nobody models the SR as the manufacturers don't make the stock / manufacturers don't make the SR stock as nobody models the SR.
I've been modelling N gauge for over 45 years, I started with BR(s) but gradually moved my timescale back to the 1930s and have hacked and bashed kits and RTR to try and get a reasonably representative stock but now at 86, hand/eye coordination is deteriorating so "new" stock increases much less than before. Below, a few of my efforts
I feel your pain & frustration, Dorestmike. I model BR(S) mid-late 60s, South London and would be very happy to see any Southern 4-6-0 even if it is at the outer limits of my timeframe.
I too feel the Southern is a little under-represented in N Gauge, although there have been a few more releases in recent years - C Class, N Class, V Class, Brighton Belle, Merchant Navy and Class 33 (the latter 2 obviously too late for your era) along with Bulleid, Maunsell and Birdcage coaches, so there has been some progress. I'm not sure how well the Merchant Navies sold - they seemed to hang around on the shelves for ages, although I note neither Rails nor TMC have any in stock now. Contrastingly, the N class must have sold well for Farish to invest relatively quickly in new liveries and a sound fitted model.
Lovely selection of locos you have there - thanks for sharing.
Mark
-
On 24/06/2020 at 12:38, Paddy said:
Hi Keith,
My advice would be to start with something small like the Shark and get it to market. Deliver a quality product and on time to build credibility (like RevolutioN). Sadly N gauge modellers have been let down too many times and are no doubt reticent to commit to an expensive loco unseen.
If RevolutioN announces a model then I have no worries about it being delivered or the quality of the finished model.
This is in no way meant as a slight on KR Models but rather you are suffering from those who have gone before.
I wish you every success with all your projects and I have certainly expressed an interest in the Shark.
Just my 5c worth,
Kind regards
Paddy
Couldn't agree more with Paddy's comments. Good luck to KR Models - I've just expressed an interest and will certainly be in for 1 or 2.
Production of a good quality n gauge Shark would, I'm sure, be an enormous boost to the King project.
Mark
-
I'm also amazed Farish haven't produced a 2-EPB. It does seem such a obvious choice. Would be very happy to see a rebuilt MN too.
I don't suppose there'll be too much announced though - didn't they say a year or two ago that they would only anounce new items when they were less than 18 months away from delivery? Not much sign of last year's announcements hitting the shelves any time soon and there's still quite a backlog from previous years.
Mark
-
Crikey, Mr Jones, these are seriously good! All 4 have been happily trundling around my filthy corner of 1960s South London for a few days now and are putting most of my other stock to shame. Will obviously need to get them weathered, although they clearly warrant some kind of Mercig-esque expert attention rather than being subjected to my ham-fisted efforts.
It looks like early sales are pretty brisk - Hattons appear to be sold out already (good effort) - really hope these continue to sell well and put you in a position to green light the next livery quickly, and the one after that etc.
In light of Dapol 's regrettable withdrawal from n gauge, it is really heartening to see new entrants to the market (djm & revolution - and NGS, although I admit, in it's Golden Julbilee, the Society's not exactly new) sticking their necks out and producing interesting models of such outstanding quality.
If you're wondering whether to pick up one or two or indeed several of these excellent wagons ... I'd jump in quickly before they go. You won't regret it.
Thanks from one happy modeller,
MW
.
Thanks
-
2
-
-
Lol - but its line 230 in my version.
Roy
It's actually line 225.
-
Noted in the new Farish 2017 catalogue that the Standard 5 4-6-0 is completely dropped and that green SYP versions of Classes 31 and 55 no longer feature.
Interesting observation about the STD 5. I don't think the first batch was a particularly fast seller, with some still being available and heavily discounted until recently.
Dropping poor selling models to free up production slots for others perhaps?
Tom.
Well spotted Crepello. Quite surprised that the Std 5s have been dropped - they're lovely models, ran everywhere and I would have thought they'd be in the catalogue for decades. The older 3MTs and 4MT 2-6-0s have both had re-runs with different numbers so they obviously sold well enough. If poor sales is the reason the 5MTs are missing from the catalogue I wonder why they didn't do better? The two I bought certainly flew off the shelves!
And ... if the Std 5 didn't sell well, what hope is there for the less mainstream offerings such as the birdcage coaches, newly announced C class etc?
Mark
-
Yes they are the same tooling. Third class changed to second class in 1956.
Thanks for linking to my blog but just for correctness the set number as stated on my blog is Set 84 not 80 as your post.
I will check my records for their repainting dates when I get the chance.
Hi Graham,
Thanks for replying - I always find your blog an interesting and highly informative resource. I'd be very grateful to know the repainting date if you can find it - although if it turns out not to be news that I don't want to hear (ie too long before the 60s) there'll just have to be a very minor enforcement of rule No 1.
On the Set Nos - you're quite right, the details of all 4 individual coaches does indeed state 84 - the short text after the listings though states 80 - and I guess that number stuck being the last one that I read.
Thanks again for the valuable info.
Mark
-
I was interested to read on the news section of Graham Muz's website that the 4 malachite Bulleid Coaches, although being sold separately, are numbered to make up set No 80 which ran on the SE section from 1949. The 2 semi open brake thirds will have 80 on the outer ends.
I haven't had a chance to do any digging yet, but does anyone know when that set might have been repainted into the darker shade of green? I'm sure I'll get them anyway, but it would be good to know if it stretched into the 1960s.
Mark
-
Happy that the C class is being shrunk down after the success of the larger version, but disappointed, although not particularly surprised, that none of their OO 3rd rail emus have made the cut again, especially with a newly announced 4BEP to go with last year’s 2HAP and a 2 or 4EPB seeming (to me at any rate) such an obvious choice. I’m sure the 8F will sell by the bucket-load, although it’s not for me.
The slow progress of some previously announced models is notable as others have pointed out. It does suggest some ongoing challenges that haven’t been fully met, nonetheless, after a few relatively sparse years, it is good to see a number of new toolings and does demonstrate Bachmann’s / Farish’s commitment to the gauge.
Mark
-
Despite the frother offer from Aldi, the foam seems to have sunk and disappeared on this thread.
So what we really need from Farish in the new year is a 2EPB emu - just a matter of shrinking down the OO version which they still seem to be churning out regularly in new liveries so it must have been a great success. Let's now have it in N gauge scale.
G.
Couldn't agree more. It seems such an obvious choice. The way things are going though, we'll probably get another 92.
Mark
-
Really good news.
Seriously, could an n scale model be crowdfunded? I hope this could be considered.
Regards
Gerry
Go on Dave ... you know you want to.
-
Clearly both DJ Models and Revolution have invested a lot of time, money and effort on this prospective model and it’s not difficult to appreciate the deep frustration for all concerned.
I must say I don’t really understand one or two of the more tribal and hysterical responses - I have a lot of time for both these new companies who, to me, have a great deal to offer our hobby (especially in n gauge). They’ve already inspired a fair amount of well-deserved excitement and anticipation about their about their current and (mostly) future products thanks in part to a refreshing engagement with contributors to this and other forums as well as a healthy visibility at many shows.
I hope they can find some kind of mutually agreeable accord and that neither will be too much out of pocket so they can get on with the job of producing what promises to be a couple of outstanding ranges.
Mark
-
Rick,
I have enormously enjoyed your adventures with Penhayle Bay and am sad to read of this lovely line's pending closure. It has been an inspiring thread to follow - your modelling skills, imagination and knowledge are absolutely first rate. I very much look forward to following your future project(s).
All the best to you and your wife with your move.
Mark
-
As ever, we have complaints about oversized gaps.
A lot of the N-gauge market these days is people who just haven't the space for larger scales.
...
If the hobby is to survive then Farish and Dapol need to continue to make Castles, Duchesses, A4s and the like that will go round Radius 2 curves - or, even better, Radius 1. The day of the train set isn't dead. If engineering a large loco to go round "silly small curves" means there is a larger clearance than prototypical around bogies, or a loco to tender gap that is too big then so be it. The alternative is to go so far to scale that the people who make up the bulk of sales can't run the model as it can't go round trainset curves..
If the current model is unsaleable to a proportion of the market how do manufacturers generate the cash to develop the next model?
I've looked at the Castle. It is a lovely model, and Farish have done a fantastic job within the limits of the market it has to sell into. We RMWebbers are a SMALL proportion of that market. Please don't complain about compromises that have to be made for the model to exist at all.
Les
Superb post.
Mark
-
Graham Farish - Spring 2024 Announcements
in Graham Farish
Posted
John, If you haven’t already done so, you could ask Farish themselves - use the Contact Us link on their website. They’re usually more than happy to help with queries like this.
Good luck,
Mark