We shouldn't be giving up now and heading off to get specialist small batches made or kits. True it may not be quite what we wanted to hear from Hornby or Bachmann; Bare in mind though that this poll has only really got started not that long ago. What we should be doing is gathering together all our time and energy into proving to them that there is a significant market for Pre-Grouping Scottish locos in rtr form.
Once we have the gained enough evidence to back up that there is a market. We should have a much better chance at pressing home our requests and in doing so; much like the Southern region models will open up the oppertunity of a whole range of Scottish region locos and rolling stock to complement the ones we wish for at the moment.
I wouldn't take too much from them saying that they maybe too specialist. If you consider that they've produced locos such as the Clans, which in my opinion is a specialist loco considering it is rarely mentioned when discussing the standard classes and was only a class of 10 locos. When you consider that, our hopes for Scottish region locos may not sound too far fetched. In my opinion I've always considered Bachmann as being the more specialist of the two when you look at their range of locos over the years like the V3 tank, J39, WD 2-8-0, Collet Goods, Super D, 3MT, O4 etc. I feel they are generally been more open to the lesser known and "workhorse" locos; although Hornby has shown some signs of that too like when they introduced the Thompson L1 this year.
As said earlier we represent only a small percentage of all the British Railway modellers. To get more support we should try writing to magazines such as Railway Modeller, Hornby, British Railway Modeller and putting forward our case, which should hopefully help gain more support among our fellow modellers. We still got a long to go guys but we shouldnt give up now, all this effort will pay off and we will finally be able to have Scottish region represented in rtr form.