Jump to content
 

To stimulate discussion, post photos and exchange ideas, and (being an open public forum) help encourage others to try S scale modelling.

Drakelow: S scale


ianb3174
 Share

Recommended Posts

My biggest youngster has a few 3D printers but I'd have to make the files for him to print, and know very little about making a suitable drawing. I have tried. 

Presume you are using S Scale Society chairs?

Yes they are society chairs. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Lacathedrale said:

I wonder if 3D printed chairs would work for those specialist versions?

 

The SSMRS stores has 28thou nickel silver strip for such requirements.    It sits under the rail and can be glued to the timbers and the crossing nose soldered to it.  Then you can hack about the uppers of the Society chairs to represent the crossing chairs.

 

Jim. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Who needs all those fancy chairs anyway. The check rail chairs are cut down standards, alternating between the stock rail and the check rail. 
the check rail is held in place by 3 chairs over its 5 sleeper length whilst the stock has 2. Then half chairs complete the job. They seem to bond together well with the solvent. A similar process was used on the crossing though it was a bit fiddly to make in situ without jigs. 
Does this class as ‘experienced’?

  • Like 3
Link to post
Share on other sites

On 02/08/2020 at 20:05, ianb3174 said:

-- There is no appreciable ingress of the glue into the foam layer as far as I can tell. PVA glue dries on the surface over time and forms a very secure bond. I've built temporary structures for sizing etc and they are very robust --

 

Thanks!

 

Looking forward to seeing the layout finished -- something I've always failed to accomplish :(

 

pekka

Link to post
Share on other sites

The permanent way department. led by Arthur Bodgett and his assistant Josiah Scarper have been making the most of the good weather and beer bonus to crack on with the crossover.  The inspector was pleased with their efforts. 

It's quite therapeutic this S Scale. I was musing about the need to make the majority of this from scratch and wasn't phased by it at all*.

Loco's may cause me a bit of grief, not having done anything more technical than put a kit body on a RTR chassis. I've got the basic understanding of how to make a coach and buildings are the same in any scale.  With 3D printing and laser cutting the tasks should be that much easier, or is that cheating?

One question, would my crossover have lengthened wing rails to form the check rails? Or considering this isn't meant to be anything but a rural backwater siding would my version be the common practice?

 

*ok, maybe a bit

 

IMG_7651.jpg

Edited by ianb3174
Replacing lost image
  • Like 5
  • Craftsmanship/clever 3
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Gold
1 hour ago, ianb3174 said:

With 3D printing and laser cutting the tasks should be that much easier, or is that cheating?

Only if you think so.

How you go about your modelling is entirely up to you!

Quote

One question, would my crossover have lengthened wing rails to form the check rails? Or considering this isn't meant to be anything but a rural backwater siding would my version be the common practice?

I think you gave it right for most prototypes: check and wing rails would be standard components, supplied directly from some stores.

But as always, your prototype may vary, and either ask a person knowledgeable about that company, or look at photos from the right era, if you wish to be precisely right.

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Been busy with a myriad of other tasks recently so not much got done. Then the Gazette dropped through the door and I found a bit of momentum. I was watching a fancy setup with a milling tool to cut/shape turnout blades and realised it would take me years to acquire such a machine and get to use it proficiently so I broke out the trusty file and started shaping my own. Then I realised I hadn't put a set bend in the stock rail. I didn't want to remove the whole stock rail after just glueing it down so I've tried to craftily reprofile the blade. No one will notice (I hope) and fewer will be appalled by its omission (I'm sure).

The next task is to design/make a robust link between said blade and the TOU pin. I have some ideas, one being a flat section of brass with a hole that sits over the pin then bends upwards 90 degrees and then 90 degrees flat so it sits under the rail. It would extend under the stock rail to prevent it from lifting. There is enough play in the plastic tie bar to alleviate any stresses in use (he hopes) and could be easily maintained without removing the turnout (he's confident). 

Enough gin soaked ramblings, compare and contrast with your own efforts and offer some critique. 

Tomorrow I shall be looking at my tax refund and asking why they send a cheque on a Saturday knowing full well that I can't get it in the bank until Monday now. I think another stores order is in 'order'. 

 

 

IMG_7875.jpg

Edited by ianb3174
Replacing lost image
  • Like 6
Link to post
Share on other sites

It looks as though you've saved the day. :-)   But you might have to check for a wee bit of gauge narrowing when the other stock rail is in place.   I think I would just have lifted the errant stock rail and put the set in.   Plastic chairs on plywood are quite easy to pop off the sleepers with a sharp blade like a razor blade,  and re-stick down when the rail had been bent with the offset.

 

But your trackwork is looking very good.

 

Jim.

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

Another thing that might help you in your tracklaying is the 28thou nickel silver strip in the SSMRS Parts List.    This strip can be used under crossings with bits of the plastic chairs to disguise them.  But I also liked to use one or two bits as slide chairs,  sticking them down to the ply sleepers with Araldite and soldering the stock rails to them.    I was always a bit worried with the stock rails over the plastic slide chairs being free to wave around in the breeze. :-)   Maybe not so bad in short switches like "A" size,  but when you venture into longer switches like "C" and "D",  there's a fair length of unsupported stock rail.   One metal slide at the toe of the switch and one or two spaced along the length of the switch helped to tie things down. 

 

Ot there's the brass slide chair in the lost wax casting of the chair sprue,  but that could get expensive with only one slide chair on each sprue. :-)

 

Jim.

Edited by flubrush
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Gold
42 minutes ago, flubrush said:

I was always a bit worried with the stock rails over the plastic slide chairs being free to wave around in the breeze. :-)   Maybe not so bad in short switches like "A" size,  but when you venture into longer switches like "C" and "D",  there's a fair length of unsupported stock rail.

 

 

Hi Jim, Ian,

 

Stock rails can be fixed firmly to moulded slide chairs using Loctite 435 adhesive. See this post from Paul Boyd:

 

 https://85a.co.uk/forum/view_topic.php?id=3257#p24474

 

cheers,

 

Martin.

Link to post
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, flubrush said:

Another thing that might help you in your tracklaying is the 28thou nickel silver strip in the SSMRS Parts List.    This strip can be used under crossings with bits of the plastic chairs to disguise them.  

I've used some of this on the crossings. I've also added my set bend to the stock rail now. Looks a lot better and I'm a lot happier. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

I only used the Templot plan, a file and some pliers. A jig would be lovely but not necessary. To solder the V I use blutack to hold it while I align it and apply solder. A slightly (very) maverick approach but still 100% better than ready made track. On my other thread Drakelow (currently EM-SF) I used jigs for the turnouts and was happy with the consistency. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...

I've been quiet for a few weeks due to a rejig of my cellar office/workshop/nerve centre which left my workbench under a pile of things to sort, and didn't get sorted in a timely manner*. Now it's clear enough for a resumption of services. 

Anyhow, there were some juicy society kits in a box just waiting to be bodged. But what to begin with? An underframe kit? The society plastic wagon kit? Maybe "get on with that track"? I have got the switches to add to the turnouts and a bit of plain track still to lay. 

I was briefly seduced by some 1/32 modelling which seems a related scale for some odd reason. I then mused about what 1/128 scale may look like before a cul de sac of what ifs, like realising metre gauge in 7mm is very close to 22.42mm. 

Before all that, a wagon, properly...

 

*work nonsense mainly, a terrible affliction that should be avoided.

 

 

 

Wagon.jpg

Edited by ianb3174
Replacing lost image
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Gold
7 minutes ago, ianb3174 said:

like realising metre gauge in 7mm is very close to 22.42mm. 

Indeed.

0m is a commercial scale, with track at 22.5mm gauge, which is compatible with S: “Toby” from East Lynn made a progression around a Swiss outline layout at the Northampton exhibition circa 1997/8...

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

24 minutes ago, Regularity said:

Indeed.

0m is a commercial scale, with track at 22.5mm gauge, which is compatible with S: “Toby” from East Lynn made a progression around a Swiss outline layout at the Northampton exhibition circa 1997/8...

The Bemo 0m range actually users a slightly narrower gauge with finer wheels standards than earlier models.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Enough excitement for one evening as I manage to fold up some brass without over bending it, ream out some holes without destroying the entire etch, superglue bearings in place without dropping one on the floor (progress) and not sticking my fingers together. I also found some very thin wire for the rocking W iron (wasn't expecting to) and marvelled at how it all might fit together. Tomorrow I begin my search for brake gear instructions. Runs a dream through the crossover though, which is the main thing

 

IMG_8769.jpg

Edited by ianb3174
Replacing lost image
  • Like 9
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

A sudden rush of blood to the head last night and I finished laying the timbers at the far end of the cameo. Mainly due to my work lamp having a failure and not being able to source a replacement bulb (the only excuse, weak, but I'm sticking by it).

I might have a go at putting in some scenic features as well, as long as this work nonsense doesn't impede on my time too much.

 

Edited by ianb3174
  • Like 5
Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...