Jump to content
 

SECR Birdcage Coaches


Bill
 Share

Recommended Posts

Not to mention two varieties of cattle wagons from Hornby, an L.S.W.R. brake van from D.J.Models and a B4 tank from Dapol .............. though the latter two have gone rather quiet of late !

The Dapol B4 has entered the Mystic Oriental Sanctuary of the believers in Eastern relative time structure in Chinese Factories, compounded by the Chinese Year being different to the West.....We know not what mysterious ceremonies and services are held over the CAD drawings, or it's rite of passage through to a 3d printed example, fabled for being prized by Model Magazine editors as evidence of the passage through the initiation rites, then to be taken to the Peoples Palace of Production (approved by the Chinese Communist Party Officials) to be completed, crated up and sold to the gullible west........

It's gona' to be a long time yet.........

Stephen

  • Like 3
Link to post
Share on other sites

The Dapol B4 has entered the Mystic Oriental Sanctuary of the believers in Eastern relative time structure in Chinese Factories, compounded by the Chinese Year being different to the West.....We know not what mysterious ceremonies and services are held over the CAD drawings, or it's rite of passage through to a 3d printed example, fabled for being prized by Model Magazine editors as evidence of the passage through the initiation rites, then to be taken to the Peoples Palace of Production (approved by the Chinese Communist Party Officials) to be completed, crated up and sold to the gullible west........

It's gona' to be a long time yet.........

Stephen

Maybe it's being held to ransom until Hinkley Point gets the go-ahead ? ....... it's not only Chinese politicians can procrastinate !

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

Oh well, the Great Dorset Steam Fair, that's all right then, we all go there......where else? Harrods food hall?.... so nice to have seen them then, but of course all the customers who have ordered them were warned they were there!........ Sorry to sound so cynical, but these teasers are plain ridiculous, they appear at one show, but not another, but rarely with a date to actually buy them. Still looks a long time off at present. Thank goodness Hornby got the LSWR coaches out in the meantime.

Stephen

Link to post
Share on other sites

They look wonderful!

The question from me is ...are they (with a bit lot of surgery) adaptable to represent the IOW SECR coaches? It's a bit frustrating to have such a lovely model of an Island 02 tank without anything suitable for it to pull....

JF

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Gold

Oh well, the Great Dorset Steam Fair, that's all right then, we all go there......where else? Harrods food hall?.... so nice to have seen them then, but of course all the customers who have ordered them were warned they were there!........ Sorry to sound so cynical, but these teasers are plain ridiculous, they appear at one show, but not another, but rarely with a date to actually buy them. Still looks a long time off at present. Thank goodness Hornby got the LSWR coaches out in the meantime.

Stephen

Stephen

 

That is quite harsh.

 

Firstly Bachmann have had a stand at the Great Dorset Steam Fair for many years now.

Secondly this is the first show that they have been at since the Engineering Prototypes arrived so hardly a case of them displaying them at one show then not another!

  • Like 3
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Gold

.

 

bertirdog  -  if you can go The Great Dorset Steam Show is an excellent day out.

So I hear. My Ferrari/Morgan-owning friend goes every year, and takes his neighbour, who is otherwise not known for stepping outside his delivery area. He runs a glazing business in Wunbridge Tells.
  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

They look wonderful!

The question from me is ...are they (with a bit lot of surgery) adaptable to represent the IOW SECR coaches? It's a bit frustrating to have such a lovely model of an Island 02 tank without anything suitable for it to pull....

JF

 

They will need quite a lot of surgery, as described elsewhere on this forum by chaps knowledgeable on Island history. Personally, I had thought that a different choice of prototype (only slightly shorter, I believe) would have had a wider appeal.

 

PB

Link to post
Share on other sites

.

 

bertirdog  -  if you can go The Great Dorset Steam Show is an excellent day out.

I used to go regularly with my Austin car on display, but these days impossible due to illness leaving me pretty much house bound. It is just that maybe pressure on the makers will finally cure them of leaving customers out to dry whilst waiting for long promised goods, or limited supply that runs out before you have a chance to buy them. it has crept in since the late 70's the US inspired limited production runs and limited stocks, using no factories you run to make the goods. I am generalising and it certainly does not apply to the Model railway suppliers but with many companies shows a lack of respect to the customer. Fortunately the model world is not so important to people as vital goods are, and the specialist nature will lead to longer production times.

Link to post
Share on other sites

They look wonderful!

The question from me is ...are they (with a bit lot of surgery) adaptable to represent the IOW SECR coaches? It's a bit frustrating to have such a lovely model of an Island 02 tank without anything suitable for it to pull....

JF

 

Very difficult, if not impossible. The layout of the 60ft coaches is wrong for IOW conversion. Plus the coaches that went to the island were 54ft ' Ashford Gothic '

style vehicles, where the quarter lights and vertical mouldings were square at the bottom edge. They were rounded on the 60ft coaches.

There may be room for ' artistic license ' if you wish.

I had hoped that Bachmann would choose the 54ft ' Ashford Gothic ' type as all three coach types for one of these sets still exist. The two brakes on the KESR

and the composite at Haven Street. But mainland BR era would not have possible for a livery option, as all survivors after war losses, army, and departmental

were sent to the Island in a converted state.

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Gold

So I hear. My Ferrari/Morgan-owning friend goes every year, and takes his neighbour, who is otherwise not known for stepping outside his delivery area. He runs a glazing business in Wunbridge Tells.

What is this Ferrari/Morgan that your friend owns? I was unaware these two companies had combined to make a car.

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Premium

I wonder if Bachmann is considering another Wainwright of some description. Imagine the excitement if one came out at more-or-less the same time as these coaches.

 

It would be nice - but given the current focus on clearing the backlog then I would be surprised if it happened.

 

In the longer term though I would imagine a H tank is an obvious goal for Bachmann - particularly as Hornby's Southern railway based models have all been primarily western section stuff and thus there is less risk of duplication (the M7 and Adams radial fitting the small tank engine slots for example)

Link to post
Share on other sites

I wonder if Bachmann is considering another Wainwright of some description. Imagine the excitement if one came out at more-or-less the same time as these coaches.

 

I am a man without hope.  Therefore, occasionally pleasantly surprised.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Premium

seeing a N gauge are getting a 3 coach train pack, why aren't we getting a deal in OO?

 

Cost?

 

While I have no idea what the RRP for each scale is off the top of my head - the traditional marketing tactic is to break down a large lump sum into smaller more 'manageable' payments - even if the person still ends up paying the same (or more) in the end.

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Gold

Cost?

 

While I have no idea what the RRP for each scale is off the top of my head - the traditional marketing tactic is to break down a large lump sum into smaller more 'manageable' payments - even if the person still ends up paying the same (or more) in the end.

Possibly, but Hornby did release their 'Somerset & Dorset' 3-set as a coach pack. Those low-window Maunsells, like these coaches, spent their careers as fixed formations.

 

I don't think Bachmann have ever done anything similar but a coach pack would be the more logical way to sell the Birdcages.

 

John

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Gold

Possibly, but Hornby did release their 'Somerset & Dorset' 3-set as a coach pack. Those low-window Maunsells, like these coaches, spent their careers as fixed formations.

 

I don't think Bachmann have ever done anything similar but a coach pack would be the more logical way to sell the Birdcages.

 

John

 

Bachmann did a while ago produce a Bulleid 3-set in OO gauge (34-500Z) complete with set numbers on each end of the brake coaches.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...