Roger Sunderland

Thanks Nigel, I’ll bear that in mind. I would probably prefer to use the DS64 as I already have them but I’ll look at all options.

Thanks both of you for the further suggestions. My friend is currently looking at possible MERG alternatives as he’s a member. The Yamorc option does sound interesting though. If I may I’ll come back to you on this if necessary.

Thank you so much Nigel. That’s clarified my thoughts and is definitely the way to go. I will try option 2 first to rule it out, if nothing else, although I did try this some years back unsuccessfully, however not with a diode fitted.

Yes you are correct in this Nigel, having spoken to GF.

The problem with the DS64, in slow motion mode, is that using it for signals, with the GF boards, doesn’t work, I think because you can’t switch off the current. You can raise a signal arm but then you have to remove the power for the arm to return to “on” and the DS64 simply reverses the power, as it would to reverse the point motor if it was connected to one. I’m wondering if I connect the board to say terminal 1R and the common, leaving out the opposite throw it might work? But surely there must be a stationary decoder on the market that can mimic an on/off switch, or be configured to do so. Nigel, your second guess was right for DCC Concepts- I don’t think they understood the question.

Yes I am using Panel Pro on a PC and I’d like to incorporate the signals into that, rather than have a separate panel with switches for just the signals.

Thanks for this Nigel. I will investigate the 2 options you’ve mentioned. As you say , the GF boards have a very simple requirement but I tried DCC Concepts and they said they were unable to help.

Hi there I’m looking for some help here please. I operate my signals with GF control boards. These are excellent but rather than use the suggested SPST switch to send an electronic signal to the board to energise the servo to move the arm to off or on, I’m looking for a DCC solution. I currently use JMRI panel pro to operate points etc through Digitrax DS64s. The way the boards operate is that when the switch is on the arm is lifted, returning the switch to off and the arm drops back to position. Only requires 2 wires to the board from the switch ie. Current on/signal arm “off”. No current/ signal arm “on”. I’ve tried using the DS64 but can’t seem to get it to mimic the simple on/off nature of the SPST switch. please does anyone have any idea how I can achieve this ?

I believe there is a rebate behind the window to fit a suitably sized piece of clear material. Can’t use the usual plastiglaze as it can’t be lasered. I’ll ask the specialist!

Sorry about the lack of info on here about further developments. In November there was a small fire in the workshop overnight. Fortunately the area where the layout is stored didn’t suffer but there was some smoke damage to other areas close by and access has been somewhat restricted since then. Things are still progressing though and Simon has been working on the massive task which is the station building. All the parts have been laser cut and the main items all 3D printed. Top photo , one of the 20 odd buttresses they line both sides of the main building. Middle photo is the 536 windows that now all need painting. Bottom photo is the goods shed in its raw state. Finally the remaining two scenic boards are nearing completion now and we hope to restart track laying once they’re done.

Most people use Kadees at rake ends only on Bachmann Mk1’s. Is this article advocating something different?

Yes , I have the same, diagnosed as Benign Essential Tremor(BET) it affects mostly my right hand. I was right handed but I’ve taught myself to do most things left handed like soldering for instance. So far it hasn’t stopped me from building layouts and indeed kits but can be very frustrating .

Well said Andy. Hattons have been a part of my life since I was 6 years old and living on Merseyside. I will miss them. Good luck to all the people who worked there, I hope things work out well for everyone and thank you.

From a personal point of view I think this is a great idea. I’m a very poor sleeper at best and hated having to share rooms, leaving me exhausted by the end of a 2 day show. But I didn’t have an issue with making a contribution to our exhibition outings. This idea at least allows flexibility to suit people’s preferences .

Very sad news about Hattons, an institution in the model railway world. I remember going to the old shop in Smithdown Road with my uncle, I’d be about 12. In the end he literally had to drag me out - I could have stayed in there for days.