Jump to content
 
  • entries
    261
  • comments
    1,413
  • views
    143,478

Cambrian 2-4-0T and Dean Goods


Barry Ten

1,202 views

Updates on a couple of loco projects here.

 

The Cambrian 2-4-0T was one of the locos absorbed by the GWR and given the Swindon treatment. Although I've no particular intention of modelling
the handful of rural lines on which these three engines operated, I still thought it would be a nice little loco to own, especially given that 2-4-0s in general
aren't very common on layouts.

 

A couple of years ago I bought a package kit containing white metal body parts, a chassis, motor, gearbox and wheels. The body originates from the Gem
castings, while - at least according to the instructions - the chassis appears to have some basis in Gibson.

 

First the good news: the chassis goes together superbly well, with a very good design of slots enabling accurate assembly of the spacers and chassis
halves. Allthough I used a pair of jig axles, and aligned everything on a gridded cutting board, I'm pretty confident that it would have gone together
nicely without these basic aids, so positive was the location.

 

blogentry-6720-0-31440500-1475613803_thumb.jpg

 

I did run into some issues getting the Rod Neep gearbox to mesh nicely, but these were eventually resolved and they're no reflection on the quality of
the components. The motor is an open frame Mashima for which there's plenty of room in the body. In fact, I doubt that I'll bother trimming the motor
spindles as there's no real need, especially one a crew is installed to block the view into the cab a little.

 

The bad news is that the body parts were pretty poor in general, with some awful pitting and voids. Perhaps if I'd paid more attention on receiving the kit I could
have chased after some replacements, but I'm afraid I was far too taken with the shiny etches to pay any heed to the castings. Anyway, nothing ventured,
nothing gained, and I still decided to make a go of the body:

 

blogentry-6720-0-62484800-1475614117_thumb.jpg

 

blogentry-6720-0-38586000-1475614167_thumb.jpg

 

This is the basic structure in all its ghastly glory, and fair amount of bodging was needed to get the cab and bunker parts to mesh well with the boiler, various
bits being well oversize and needing some delicate filing back.

 

Thereafter it was a case of filling in the major voids with solder, where possible, and model filler where not. I went over the body several times before applying
a test coat of matt black, to highlight what was still needed. Then it was a case of more filling, more sanding and filing, until the parts started looking a little
more acceptable. The main issue was the two lumpy halves of the boiler.

 

Finally I was happy to start adding additional boiler detail, and on went the chimney, dome, safety valve etc:

 

blogentry-6720-0-59129500-1475614431_thumb.jpg

 

At that point I realised that the kit's instructions really weren't adequate to help with the additional boiler plumbing, which seemed to vary quite a bit from loco
to loco, so after an internet trawl I managed to find two photos of the same engine from each side, and I now need to rework the pipes from the top-feed, which
should bend back to the horizontal rather than running down the boiler sides as seen here. In the meantime, I'm waiting on handrail knobs to complete that
aspect of the detailing. As can be seen, the chassis now has full brake detail which certainly goes a long way to making it look "interesting" in my view. I've
a particular liking for locos with outside brake linkage...

 

Which brings us neatly to:

 

blogentry-6720-0-76116100-1475614682_thumb.jpg

 

Those who've been reading this blog for a year or two may remember the protracted saga of the Dean Goods, but finally it all came good and after several weeks
of very satisfying test running, I'm happy to call this one conquered! The chassis is Comet, with their own gearbox and a Mashima motor, and it runs brilliantly,
and with more than enough grunt for my typical goods trains. All that remains to be done now, other than final painting and decal-work, is to get rid of that huge
coal load. This one has been particularly satisfying for me as it's been far from an easy road to get here, but it's been well worth the hassle.

 

Cheers, and thanks for reading.

  • Like 14

6 Comments


Recommended Comments

  • RMweb Premium

A good result & good example of why we've moved on from white metal kits, in this case with unacceptable quality control from the latter days of GEM, I suspect.

Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

I've yet to build a fully-etched loco but I have to admit I'm happy enough with white metal provided the castings are of good quality and accurate.

Link to comment

I remember reading reviews of that kit when it came out in 1977 and the castings certainly looked a lot better back then - you've made a grand job of some pretty ropey main components ! 

Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Well done for for turning that collection of duff whitemetal castings into a locomotive!   Quality control obviously wasn't a priority for some manufacturers of kits :-(

 

Definitely time you moved on to an all etched kit Al, you've got all the skills required and you wouldn't need bucket loads of filler to get a good result :-)

Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

One of these days, Dave - but I'll have to clear the current stock of white metal kits first! Besides, who else is going to keep model filler manufacturers in business?

Link to comment

I've got three of these and the castings are superb. They are less than five years old and are the Lychett Manor version that Mainly Trains were selling as complete kits until recently. The LNWR 2-4-2T and NBR J83 are also very good castings wise.

 

I've only half built one as I didn't realise that all three were totally different from each other. I got up to the footplate level and the bunker looked different on the photographs that I have. I need to do some research before completing it.

 

I bought two as I wanted them as a pair. And then found one on Ebay going cheap, I thought it was just the standard kit but it was complete with motor/wheels/etc.

 

The chassis is an Iain Rice one I think. The gearboxes that were supplied with mine are SE Finecast ones.

 

 

However I seem to remember that someone else on the forum had a poor quality kit. Quarryscapes I think it was. So there must be some rogue ones about.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...