Jump to content
 

A lineage


JamFjord

1,409 views

In the last blog I said I wasn't going to write anything for a couple of weeks whilst I was deep in the planning stage and starting to acquire materials, but I couldn't resist posting this...

 

An exciting delivery arrived yesterday. Well, exciting to me anyway. The final piece in a puzzle; completing a picture that should help me to understand 'The Art of Compromise' as a layout, as a trackplan and as an idea.

 

A couple of weeks ago I’d already found myself a copy of Railway Modeller from October 2018, with Chris Ford's article detailing his interpretation of 'The Art of Compromise' - the layout that has become my project for the next year. Yesterday's delivery brought a copy of RM from October 1978, with the feature by Roy C Link that inspired Chris to create the layout. 

 

981953405_RM_19782018-Covers-20230217.jpg.532966bdae0932ba964971b22d2ef626.jpg

 

I felt a charge of excitement course through me as I held the copy for the first time, and flicked through its pages, enjoying a bit of nostalgia for the publication that I consumed voraciously as a kid (albeit a few years after 1978). Having read Chris’ article first, seeing the piece by Roy before me in its double-page glory felt a little like discovering some long-lost historical document.

 

RM_1978-RCL_Article-20230217.jpg.74cc64efa5d3f706addfaf8885f221e5.jpg

 

RM_1978-RCL_Article_Illustration-20230217.jpg.31f2924700bd196bed6bfee9d23b2ed8.jpg

 

RM_1978-RCL_Article_Trackplan-20230217.jpg.2aaa2fe11dd9c85605f0185c2aa6b8f6.jpg

 

RM_1978-RCL_Article_Construction-20230217.jpg.78de6755be8dd2c5647b11b2bb676b01.jpg

 

I’ve included some photos of Chris Ford’s 2018 article as well for context, as this has already been a huge help in understanding how I can best preserve the essence of ‘The Art of Compromise’, whilst also putting my own stamp on it. Well, that’s what I hope to achieve, anyway.

 

RM_2018-CF_Article-20230217.jpg.33b8f351e04a10a3a023e46d075c5d40.jpg

 

RM_2018-CF_Article2-20230217.jpg.833feee0ba0a51349bae2ef3abad71c4.jpg

 

RM_2018-CF_Article_Trackplan-20230217.jpg.83517babbf68577697a569071ff6d2a7.jpg

 

In addition to the two magazines, I also got a copy of Chris’ book ‘Modelling the Great Western Branch Lines’, as well as ‘Great Western Branch Line Termini Volume 1’ by Paul Karau and ‘Industrial Locomotives & Railways of Wales’ by Gordon Edgar. A copy of ‘Great Western Branch Lines: Rural Wales Volume 2’ by Michael Welch is on the way too.

 

ResearchBooks-20230217.jpg.64a93e3c6b226b11346ef2ed26738b9e.jpg

 

That lot should keep me going for a while…

 

Edited by JamFjord

  • Like 10
  • Interesting/Thought-provoking 2

11 Comments


Recommended Comments

  • RMweb Gold

I remember both articles well, like you I looked up the 1978 one after reading Chris Ford's. I look forward to following this project.

 

I wasn't aware of Chris' book, thanks for that, must look it up. Is that @Ian Smith's Modbury on the cover? 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Thanks @Mikkel. I haven't found confirmation in the book yet (maybe I missed it), but the upper photo does indeed appear to be Ian's Modbury layout, very deservedly on the cover. The lower photo is, I'm pretty sure, the lovely Condicote by Bob Vaughan.

 

I'm very much enjoying Chris' book; some fascinating historic context, examples and step-by-step guidance on specific projects/builds. The other books are excellent as well - lots of inspiration and ideas. 

Edited by JamFjord
  • Like 1
  • Informative/Useful 1
Link to comment
10 hours ago, Mikkel said:

I remember both articles well, like you I looked up the 1978 one after reading Chris Ford's. I look forward to following this project.

 

I wasn't aware of Chris' book, thanks for that, must look it up. Is that @Ian Smith's Modbury on the cover? 

Mikkel,

It is indeed an early view of Modbury!  A couple of years ago a friend who had bought the book alerted me to the fact that Modbury was shown on the cover (at the time I wasn’t aware of the book even existed!)

Ian

  • Like 2
  • Friendly/supportive 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold
29 minutes ago, Ian Smith said:

Mikkel,

It is indeed an early view of Modbury!  A couple of years ago a friend who had bought the book alerted me to the fact that Modbury was shown on the cover (at the time I wasn’t aware of the book even existed!)

Ian

 

I think I'd be more than a little bamboozled to find a picture of a layout of mine on the cover of the book I didn't even know about.🙄

  • Agree 2
Link to comment
2 hours ago, Barry Ten said:

 

I think I'd be more than a little bamboozled to find a picture of a layout of mine on the cover of the book I didn't even know about.🙄

I did find it a bit of a surprise, I assume the author took the photo at one of the exhibitions Modbury attended.  If I remember correctly when my friend showed me the book that there is another photo within the book too (I believe that the caption correctly references the layout and me as the builder).

I guess all publicity is good publicity 😂

Ian

  • Friendly/supportive 2
Link to comment

First of all glad to see TAoC has gone to a good home. 

If you look at the prototype plan of South Leigh in the same issue TAoC appeared in I suspect it provides a clue as to what partly inpsired the track plan.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Thank you, Jimbo, much appreciated. I'll have another look at the issue. I was aware that Roy C Link was inspired by the Fairford branch, I'd assumed the terminus.

Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold
On 09/03/2023 at 18:27, Yan said:

I remember the original article in the RM very well as I followed Roy Links design and build a layout.

http://grogleyjunction.blogspot.com/2008/12/lost-layout.html

 

Since then Iain Rice developed the idea further with his Broadwell Green design and I've often thought about this as a project but it never came to fruition.

2121691018_BroadwellGreen.jpg.817ea15b15156e9724856d3a333844ce.jpg

Will follow you progress with interest.

 

Yan, thanks - link and additional context both very helpful! Incidentally it's the second mention of Prototype Models' kits I've read this week; I'm starting to feel like I've missed out as the company seems to be long gone.

Edited by JamFjord
Link to comment

You can still pick up the Prototype Models Kits, for instance from Antics https://anticsonline.uk/Category/Bilt-Eezi--Prototype-Card-Kits_N1940

I have a small stash from my own ideas for building an Em version of TAoC. However the printing, by modern standards, leaves a lot to be desired. I've even tried improving them in Photoshop with no success.

So my suggestions. First of all you could buy the kits and use them as a template, perhaps using some Scalescenes textures to replace the originals.
But on TAoC the buildings are very close to the viewer, so it might be worth using laser cut kits. York Model Rail do a suitable groundframe, though I would be tempted to put a signal cabin on the platform. Arch  Laser do a Fairford Goods shed.

Years ago, I got Lcut to produce a lasercut version of the platform building. Somewhere, in amongst packing cases, I still have the preproduction version.
And Intentio do a GWR weighbridge.



Hope this helps

Edited by jimbofin
  • Like 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold
On 24/03/2023 at 08:53, jimbofin said:

You can still pick up the Prototype Models Kits, for instance from Antics https://anticsonline.uk/Category/Bilt-Eezi--Prototype-Card-Kits_N1940

I have a small stash from my own ideas for building an Em version of TAoC. However the printing, by modern standards, leaves a lot to be desired. I've even tried improving them in Photoshop with no success.

So my suggestions. First of all you could buy the kits and use them as a template, perhaps using some Scalescenes textures to replace the originals.
But on TAoC the buildings are very close to the viewer, so it might be worth using laser cut kits. York Model Rail do a suitable groundframe, though I would be tempted to put a signal cabin on the platform. Arch  Laser do a Fairford Goods shed.

Years ago, I got Lcut to produce a lasercut version of the platform building. Somewhere, in amongst packing cases, I still have the preproduction version.
And Intentio do a GWR weighbridge.



Hope this helps

Thanks jimbofin, sorry I didn't spot your comment earlier - it does indeed help! In the end I decided to take a different approach with the layout (which I've summarised in another blog post if you're interested) but it's useful to know about all those sources and suppliers as I'm hoping this layout will be the first of a bunch. The link was also useful - I can appreciate your point about the printing, judging by the listing photos, but there are some interesting building shapes in the range which could make a good 'skeleton' to overlay with texture sheets and detail packs. But not for this layout, probably, as I'm already struggling to find space for the structures I've already bought 😅😬

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...