Jump to content
 
  • entries
    17
  • comments
    96
  • views
    71,467

Polishing up Hornby Staniers


Ben Alder

1,018 views

The original releases of the Hornby Stanier, while good models, were blessed with a very dull finish that did not sit well with my other Stanier stock- Comet sides on Airfix cores, and finished with a mix of cellulouse and acrylic spray paints, so they have sat for some time waiting for attention. I will begin by saying that nothing I have done has been original but a straightforward crib from an article in MRJ some considerable time ago, but AFAIK there has not been much said here about this, so I have recorded my efforts.

 

The basis of the process is T-cut, which is applied and buffed off, and which leaves a lovely glossy surface that matches other stock far better than the original finish. Apart from a tiny bit of lining on one coach it did not affect the surface at all, although a Bachmann coach did lose most of its particulars in the process, but that is easily sorted.

 

Some pics of WIP.

Firstly some before and after views of the glossing up.

blogentry-2642-126860572802_thumb.jpg

 

blogentry-2642-126860574912_thumb.jpg

 

blogentry-2642-126860577271_thumb.jpg

 

Once this is done the next stage is to tackle the prismatic effect of the thick glazing strips. The original article suggested black but I found a crimson worked better- all the clear glazing has to be painted to improve the visual effect - as shown here.

blogentry-2642-126860618551_thumb.jpg

blogentry-2642-126860620608_thumb.jpg

 

The improvements can be seen in these shots.

 

blogentry-2642-126860580203_thumb.jpg

blogentry-2642-12686058193_thumb.jpg

 

Finally,two shots of in service vehicles- one of the modified carriage alongside an original, albeit not too clear, and of the two I did running together.

blogentry-2642-126860650702_thumb.jpg

blogentry-2642-126860652854_thumb.jpg

 

This was a straightforward piece of work that made a big difference to the models- I also put some Peco interiors in place- and they are now on the layout instead of lying in a cupboard, which is what should be. One less task to do. I don't know if later batches of these coaches had the same problems as I didn't buy any others, being happy enough with my existing hybrids, but it has transformed these two anyway.

Richard

 

This is the polished side with the glazing painted over.

 

blogentry-2642-12686071092_thumb.jpg

10 Comments


Recommended Comments

Interesting, that looks much 'redder' than my BG went on T-cutting, I thought I might have to respray the passenger ones (not wishing to bury them under so much filth as the full brake) - hence I didn't buy any.

Link to comment

Looks well worthwhile.

 

How fiddly is the inside glazing painting?

 

Cheers,

 

26power

 

 

Link to comment

Hi Richard.

 

Some nice bits of work to improve what is, in my eyes, an already superb model. You're right, the new Hornby staniers do look a little matt and your t-cutting has glossed them over just nicely.

 

Still waiting for the shiney bits to arrive for my upgrade, but I've been doing some work on the bogies in the mean time. All good fun.

 

Cheers.

 

Sean.

Link to comment
Guest Max Stafford

Posted

It's certainly a big improvement Richard. Worth the effort and I shall probably do the same to my own coaches. Thanks for sharing this.

 

Dave.

Link to comment

Cheers all,

A job worth doing, but it should have been unneccessary- Hornby's coaches are a real hit or miss mixture. The painting of the glazing just needs a small, good, brush, a steady hand and some tissue to wipe off mistakes :unsure:. Acrylics makes this easier, but it makes a big difference.

Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Richard,

 

They look very good indeed. I've been dithering on whether to do a similar job or to buy 3 Comet kits for a set for Kilbrannan Ferry. I quite enjoy etched kits TBH, and the price of the Hornby ones isn't much less so I will probably plump for the latter option. In case I decide otherwise though, would a dark brown colour (to simulate wood surrounds) work for painting the glazing inserts do you think?

 

Gus

Link to comment

This is so coincidental.

I've recently bought a couple of Airfix non-corridors from Les Kent (Haslington Models).

 

They'd been grimed so I tried some T cut on one side of one of them. This was particularly to remove the LMS lettering and lining - with a view to some BR crimson.

 

Certainly does the trick, but ohhhhh those prismatic windows !!!

 

Need to try and find a way into them !!!

Link to comment

Richard,

 

They look very good indeed. I've been dithering on whether to do a similar job or to buy 3 Comet kits for a set for Kilbrannan Ferry. I quite enjoy etched kits TBH, and the price of the Hornby ones isn't much less so I will probably plump for the latter option. In case I decide otherwise though, would a dark brown colour (to simulate wood surrounds) work for painting the glazing inserts do you think?

 

Gus

 

An interesting idea this, and I will have to look at some LMS coaches to see if it would be an alternative. However, I've no intention of doing any more of these as I have plenty of stock already- it was just a case of seeing if they could be improved. I prefer the hybrid approach of Comet/Airfix anyway to give a wider choice of types.

Richard

Link to comment

This is so coincidental.

I've recently bought a couple of Airfix non-corridors from Les Kent (Haslington Models).

 

They'd been grimed so I tried some T cut on one side of one of them. This was particularly to remove the LMS lettering and lining - with a view to some BR crimson.

 

Certainly does the trick, but ohhhhh those prismatic windows !!!

 

Need to try and find a way into them !!!

 

I actually gave a non-corridor brake third a tweak when I was doing the rest of this work-it was lying abandoned in my spares box, and when I was collecting donors for the Caley coach ends Ithis one came along for the ride. There is a pic of it on the layout thread. As the finish was tolerable- I had repainted it years ago- it got a spray of Games Workshop varnish to bring it up. The windows are horrible, so, although not a big fan of them, I fitted SE Finecast glazing, which is a good bit better than the original. The roof can be prised off and then the interior and glazing are removable, although its a tight fit in the body.

Richard

Link to comment

This is so coincidental.

I've recently bought a couple of Airfix non-corridors from Les Kent (Haslington Models).

 

They'd been grimed so I tried some T cut on one side of one of them. This was particularly to remove the LMS lettering and lining - with a view to some BR crimson.

 

Certainly does the trick, but ohhhhh those prismatic windows !!!

 

Need to try and find a way into them !!!

Here is the non corridor with the SE windows. The lining is a bit heavy, but it must be about twenty five years old by now and wasn't worth the time stripping and re-doing, so stayed as is.

 

gallery_2642_313_29592.jpg

 

And a cruel close up.

gallery_2642_313_55471.jpg

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...