Jump to content
 
  • entries
    109
  • comments
    358
  • views
    144,971

"An A Class Dillemma"


S.A.C Martin

1,390 views

blogentry-1656-0-35605400-1331934469_thumb.jpg

 

Sorting out my stocklist, I looked over my two valance conversions and spotted that something was amiss compared to my Walter K. Whigham A4 Pacific. The problem lies directly with the use of either Kingfisher or Mallard models as the donor locomotives for these conversions.

 

The short access hatches at the front end under the nameplates, are wrong - they should be the double length ones as seen on the Walter K. Whigham model, and any of the BR green liveried A4s that Hornby produce.

 

 

blogentry-1656-0-77126500-1331934434_thumb.jpg

 

So the dillemma is simple - the choice is, cut the valances from the same donor models - but modify the hatches, or repaint BR liveried A4s garter blue with coronation red wheels.

 

Hornby have not offered an A4 Pacific in the garter blue/single chimney/long access hatches form yet, so it is up to me to decide whether I can live with the knowledge of this fairly minor physical discrepancy, or want to repaint a vast number of A4 Pacifics in the forms I want.

 

I do know that at this point in time, I am not comfortable repainting a vast number of A4s - so am leaning towards ignoring the discrepancy, OR...

 

...designing an etched replacement access hatch to fit onto the A4 bodies which need it. Good idea, bad idea...?

 

It really can be thoroughly infuriating finding a new problem once you think you've cracked the method!

 

In terms of the stocklist, I am debating adding Dwight D. Eisenhower and removing Sir Nigel Gresley, as Dwight D. Eisenhower was the only A4 to remain in LNER livery through to 1949. Albeit, I believe as E8 and not 4496 as it was post-war. This would add something a little different to the other planned garter blue A4s.

 

Until next time.

2 Comments


Recommended Comments

  • RMweb Gold

Oh yes, this kind of discovery can be so annoying. Once you know the problem is there, it is very difficult to accept it even if you had no clue before. The repainting option does sound rather laborious and would steal a lot of time from making new stuff.

 

I like the idea of the etched access hatch. It would limit the problem and with care you might be able to remove the old one and fit the new one withput too much extra work? Others on here might even be interested in them?

 

I don't suppose it would be feasible to simply extent the existing hatches with a bit of thin perspex or similar, smooth out the dividing line and add detailing?

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Its an idea Mikkel, but if I go down this route of garter blue A4s and removing the valances, I would need to create two identical hatches for every single locomotive, and I know I'm not a good enough modeller to do that from perspex. Etched seems to be the way to go. What I need for my purposes are new reversers (the valanced models come without them) and these hatches really as etched items. Have them done together, and suddenly "de-frocking" becomes that more attractive and viable.

 

It's worth just thinking through before I do anymore. If anyone else is interested in etched A4 access hatches, let me know and I'll see what I can do.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...