Jump to content
 
  • entries
    41
  • comments
    98
  • views
    25,750

Richard Mawer

1,767 views

As a boy, watching Deltics storm south out of Newark Northgate, one of the spectacles was the cant as they roared round the bend aproaching Barnby Lane Crossing. I used to love standing there and watch these beasts leaning round the bend and then straighten up to accelerate even more, up towards Grantham.

 

Not many model layouts seem to employ this. There are a few exceptions, mainly in O gauge. I think it always looks impressive. With many OO layouts having unprotypical sharp curves, some superelevation (or cant), could improve the look of corners and the trains on them.

 

I intend Buckingham West to be my last and only home layout (who knows for sure), so I want to try my best. That includes superelevation on the main curves. I use 3mm foam as an underlay. I didn't fancy cork, not being convinced of any gain. My club tends to use it, but once the track is glued and ballasted (another topic completely) its solid like concrete. I want a bit of suspension in there, some way of smoothing out the small differences in baseboards (nothing is a substitute for poor carpentry), a bit of sound deadening and a way of making a shoulder for the ballast. The laminate underlay is closed cell, so smooth finished.

 

I reasoned that I just needed something under the outside edge of the track on a corner. After some research on RMWEB and elsewhere, it seemed I needed no more than 1mm. 5 - 10% of the track gauge would be max. I didn't want it to look silly, or be instantly noticeable with no trains running. This is not the Wall of Death! But if someone looks down the line as a train comes round a corner, I want them to see the cant and the straightening up. I figured subltety was needed. So I needed something narrow that could be bent and was about 1mm thick.

 

I thought of plastistrut, but would have to heat it to bend it. Would I get the right radius? Too complicated. It was going to have to be card. But then I fell upon a stash of thin sheet metal plates about 15mm wide and 30mm long. They are about 0.8 or 0.9mm thick. They were meant for fixing on stuff as a warning its alarmed. The company logo and "Warning - Alarmed" type thing is printed on one side. Where I got them from, I have no idea now. It's always useful to keep useless stuff! Ha Ha.

 

blogentry-15300-0-50987800-1433662606.jpg

 

Next I had to decide whether to put these plates under the foam, or between the track and the foam. I decided on the former option. I think the foam will form round the plates, sealing them below the foam. I should still be able to ballast. The other way, I would have gaps below the sleepers in places and that would make ballasting hard work.

 

I normally glue the foam down, then glue the track on that. For the curves though, I needed to be able to turn the whole unit over to fix the plates in the right place. I would never be able to prejudge the position. So I temporarily fixed the foam in place with screws and laid the outer track. I hold my track in place with screws on each side in various places so it makes the required curve, and glue it with PVA. When dry I

added the inner line the same way.

 

blogentry-15300-0-94454700-1433663086.jpg

 

blogentry-15300-0-98697900-1433663130.jpg

 

 

When that was dry, I removed the screws and cut the inside of the foam to fit.

 

blogentry-15300-0-08037400-1433663198.jpg

 

blogentry-15300-0-26357600-1433663222.jpg

 

 

 

On the back I glued two lines of the plates. There is no real need to have them touching but I didn't want large gaps. Also they mustn't start as soon as the curve does. There has to be a transistion. How far is yet to be seen. There are various views on that. In the end it will look right or it won't. Until I glue it down, I can always pull one or two off. Because the plates are quite thin and I am not going for 10%, I think the track will manage the transistion supported by the foam.

 

Once the plates were dry, I turned it upright. Nearly right, but not quite. By being conscious that the "6 foot" in between the tracks needed to be glued to the board quite well to achieve the cant on the outside track, I had put the plates for the inside track too far under it. Instead of just raising the outer edge of the sleepers and the outer rail, I was effectively raising about half the sleeper width. So the whole track lifted - both rails - leaving no cant. The plates peel off the foam quite easily, so I moved them out a bit and reglued.

 

blogentry-15300-0-50268200-1433663927.jpg

 

blogentry-15300-0-57637500-1433663978.jpg

 

 

 

When turned over, the track looks fine.

 

blogentry-15300-0-36578900-1433664025.jpg

 

 

 

Although not yet glued in place and hence the foam is not held hard down onto the baseboard, the cant can just be detected on these coaches. Compare their lines with the vertical side of the glue bottle in the background. When I pressed the track down in place, a little more cant can be seen.

 

blogentry-15300-0-41127100-1433664229.jpg

 

 

I am really pleased with the look of this. Just enough I think.

 

Once I have more track laid I will be able to test it and glue it? I will update.

 

Rich

10 Comments


Recommended Comments

About 30 years ago, there was a guy at The Croydon Model Railway Club in Vic Australia who was doing a layout with superelevation. All the formwork was done in card. He only had a module there where he was demonstrating what he was doing. Looked brilliant! Don't know what ever happened, whether he finished it or not.

 

Be good to see this progree and will be watching with interest.

Link to comment

Thank you.

 

I have 2 joints on the lifting flap on curves. That will be fun.

 

There's also an S or reverse curves at the top of the incline!!!!

Link to comment

Superelivation seems to be the last thing ever modelled but it makes the look of trains running around curves much more realistic.

 

How will you make the transition from flat straightr track to elevated curved track?  Could cardboard spacers of different thicknesses be just as good?

Link to comment

Hi. Because I am only using 0.8 or 0.9mm packing and there is 3mm foam, i am hoping the foam will "take the strain" as they used to say, and that I won't need to pack anything in the transition areas. I'm hoping the foam at the start of the packing will compress enough and will expand in the gap between straight flat and raised curved.

 

I think cardboard could be just as good. And i may have to resort to some 0.4or 0.5mm card in the transistion areas. I need to stick it down and see though.

 

I might try Copydex for that because people seem to think thats easier to lift if necessary. But if I don't stick it down, the "6 foot" will just be suspended between the two lines of plates.

 

I think i am going to try ballasting with copydex too, to allow some flex.

Link to comment

I do like the simplicity of your design for this.

I've used the same underlay before and stuck down with Copydex and also the track too. Track pinned down lightly onto the Copydex one length at a time and used a track ballaster to run the ballast over it then lightly tamped down. Any 'bald' areas have then been rectified after all has been completed. When i decided to remove the underlay and track about 90% was successfully removed without damage.

 

Good luck with the project :)

 

And as always......enjoy! Happy modelling

Link to comment

Thanks BG. I'm glad the copydex is a good idea.

 

I might try tracklaying and ballasting at the same time like you, but not sure. I was planning to brush it dry into place and then use 50:50 copydex and water with a drop of washing up liquid shloshed over it.

 

Do you know if that would produce a film over the track and sleepers? I know I could immediately clean the track surface, but I want to spray the track later to weather it.

 

Can you spray over copydex?

Link to comment
By spray over copydex, i mean spray paint over copydex.

Haha !

I haven't tried it but maybe try a test piece on a spare length of track first, that's what I tend to do then if you're satisfied do the rest.

I'm not too keen on using the Copydex in a watered down form ( in the traditional method) as I've had problems with it tending to give a "craggy' feel to the ballast if you understand me.

Give both a test bed trial eh ?

 

Regards

Link to comment

Thats exactly what I intend to do. I am also going to try strong wallpaper paste. I was thinking whether to mix it in the ballast, dry, and then spray water on when the dry mix is in place?

 

Anyway, I've bitten the bullet and glued the superelevated curved section in place. It's drying now, so we'll see.

Link to comment

My idea from the start was that it was natural for the curves on my layout to have superelevation to avoid the risk of derailment at speed. I started the layout using foam underlay, although there has been some replacement with cork. The problem was that since I do not glue the underlay or the track down but hold it with screws, it wasn't easy to get the inner rail to stay at a lower level than the outer rail. However, whatever the way of achieving it, I believe that the curves should have a camber.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...