Jump to content
 

The Black Hat

Members
  • Posts

    3,272
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by The Black Hat

  1. 2 hours ago, davidw said:

    Well I didn't see that coming!

     

    Not sure if I'm delighted or not as Hornby do them - admittedly without the ccm....

     

    I've also done BSOs and FOs residing  Bachmann coaches. But with respect to the RBs, my research suggests that they were deployed to the ECML in 1960 can anyone confirm?

     

    Addendum: Bother. I've just read Robert's table. It was in1960


    Hornby did some, but it will still be cheaper to get the Hornby model and a spare Bachmann bogie and dremel the two together... as I have done to get modern coach rakes completed. repaint too if needed. 

  2. 18 hours ago, classy52 said:

    For Accurascale, are there any plans to include today's running (excluding the already included WCRC variants) Mark2b's, Mark2c's etc. in heritage liveries with cantrails and whatever other modifications for up to date charter workings?

     

    I suggested when I first saw these that doing them in the brown and cream livery to complete the Vintage trains rake would be an excellent idea. Although I was told they are a Mk2z I would readily accept these coaches done so far and liveried and numbered as the rake on the mainline as there is little difference between the types. 

  3. On 05/04/2024 at 15:48, XChris said:

    In all honesty I think Bachmann have massively under utilised this new tooling. So far they produced models like 375 and 790 but these are no good as the common machines can be renumbered and people would buy 2/3 not just one and that’s if they like that one. They really need to use the tooling create the real odd balls like 601/901 like the flush fronted DRS ones not the celebrities. But they need to deliver the odd standard one too that people can do some (dare I say it) modelling and renumbering too. They will find boxes shift then a mix is what you want but I just don’t see them doing this at the moment.


    Bachmann need to choose the celebs as they are charging more than others and so need something thats iconic to pull in the demand for theirs over the other alternatives. Bachmann's choices though still don't get all the celebs or popular ones that you might be looking for. Some standard workhorses would work too as the demand 'should' be there but you still need to gauge what period or whether they are weathered, etc. 

    Bachmann still (overall) do the whole green and blue for one release, then sectorisation and later in the next, rather than just go for what you need to make when you see what has been made already and what the competition is doing... 

  4. On 08/03/2024 at 22:42, XChris said:

    I would think a DMU would be expected first, then maybe an EMU


    I think you could be right. Accurascale would be a good choice to undercut Bachmann again with the release of something like the Turbostar - which Electrostar option... 

    Other DMUs to consider I think would be:
     

    Voyager/Meridian 220/221/222
    Class 185 - with Desiro options
    All singing all dancing IEP - 800/801/802... etc
    110
    HST... 

    • Like 1
    • Agree 3
  5. If you go back over the various wish lists that were done for a few years, you can use the data to see where the trends are. Matching this to models on bargain shelves tell you what sells and where the demand is. 

    Some models have been made that were mid polling, others higher have been picked but some remain. As such you expect these to be options, but then so too are others that have been done and need the dcc refresh - particularly some steam options. Does a retool make the process cheaper and more efficient so stops the price rises that now make some think twice about which model to get. The fact that tooling options mean that more varients can be done gives hope that this no longer is a reason not to make a model. Cue the B16 and its varients being pushed front and centre. 

    What I would propose is that some models are wanted by those looking to get another model. I would suggest these are:

    8F
    B16 1, 2 and 3, 
    BR standard 3
    Ivatt 2MT and 2MT-T
    Hall Class
    Bagnall tanks  - Victor, Vulcan, Valiant
    J21 / J25
    A8
    GWR Large Prairie 

    • Like 2
  6. 1 hour ago, Markn said:

    Oh 💩 I was happy before but that Bachmann coach looks rediculous now compared to that latest photo 🙃 

     

    Repaint it is. Railmatch EWS Maroon looks a good match? Unless anyone from Accurascale can let me know what paint code they used?

     

    To be honest you could have it as a faded one... but the Mk. 1 set that I have repainted I have used Pheonix paints for BR Coach Crimson. As in Blood and Custard livery... but painted full coach in that and they look spot on. 

    • Thanks 1
  7. 6 hours ago, giz said:

    Received my TransPennine livery 2Bs this morning, thought I would compare them to other TP coaches I have colour wise.

     

    This first one shows the Model Rail Bachmann version. Dark blue is quite different:

     

    IMG_3578.JPG.d0e837cf3d47914037925d6a6de55506.JPG

     

    However, compared to a Lima coach I repainted with Railmatch paint and converted to a 2C there is a good match:

     

    IMG_3579.JPG.d5799d2608c13efadc0f97403e3f131f.JPG

     

    The intention was to run my Lima and Hornby repaints in one train and the Bachmann and Accurascale in another but it looks like the Bachmann coaches could do with the dark blue repainting.


    Id say they are spot on. From my research and little memory of the time I think Transpennine was a livery carried at the time and was darker. Regional Railways comes along based on this but think the shade of blue got a bit lighter..... 

    • Like 1
  8. 21 hours ago, james-htfc said:

    Desperately trying to justify one for my early-2000s Yorkshire layout but none of this first batch are quite right.

     

    I think the closest would be the FGW, which I could rework to FNW, or one of the Merseyrail versions, but they'd need to be the later versions with the large digi destination screens – does the tooling allow for this feature in future runs?

    Would snap your hand off for Northern Spirit, Arriva (Northern) or any of the transition liveries that Arriva/Northern acquired (T&W, RR etc).

     

     

    Regional Railways units lasted into Arriva Trains Northern days so ones rebranded would be able to serve your purpose. 

     

    From my memory, the provincial blue and chocy cream units that were left were painted into Northern Spirit. That then was left while 156s got the paint brush. Arriva arrived and began painting 142s but this saw many of the various regional railways units last well into arriva trains northern operation. I also recall seeing some units swapped over between those in the North and those in Wales. Think that was due to some units having had seats installed in Wales that were matching those up north, so other ones went down that would allow the welsh ones to have standard fleet seats across their 143s too. 
     

    So a rebranded regional railways unit with a small Arriva logo would work fine! 

    • Like 2
  9. Hello all, 

     

    Time for a bit of an update with the build of the layout and the plans for the future. Apologies here but there won't be too many photos jut yet. 

    The layout has been moved so that it can be assembled and tested in place. That saw a need for a van to be hired in order to get it to the venue. When doing this it was realised that even with a few people and the crates concept working properly that the layout overall was going to be too big to move easily. While this is very disappointing I felt that it was better to scale back the layout now rather than continue on and build the layout which would then be taxing for having to need more people to help whenever it was wanted. 

    As such, 4 boards are being removed from the overall plan - shrinking down the total space the layout would take up but then also making it much easier for venues to accommodate should they want to host the layout.

    The main area of boards being removed will focus on the townscene area, turning departures that that end into a full mainline departure as it snakes it way around the corner. The idea now is that the next board down features the curves into the fiddle yard and can have a townscene built over it for extra scenery. While this is a compromise it allows some scenery to be retained even if the town area will pretty much have a cliff running through the area to get from the lower bottom of the baseboards here up to where the town is over the height level needed for trains to pass underneath. 

    At the far end the loading area looks to have been saved, with the operation of this flipping in terms of direction. This will see the area built on a board so that the line curves round towards the back of the layout. The branch line will still remain between the main and loading area before joining with the double track on the next board. It will also serve as the arrival line for trains to the loading area that will propel stock into this scene. Here it will pass onto the river scene which was always popular with those that have seen it and so has been kept. It makes the fiddle yard a bit smaller but this should still allow a nice amount of stock to be shown and for some to be able to be swapped out when running exhibitions. 

    Despite this, there has been some work done this last week where the plans have started to come together. The boards for the yard and station have been made and crated. Other areas because of the reduced size have started to be matched and the boards that have been made and are now spare will form the basis of a smaller depot layout that can be made and exhibited just on my own. So in many ways it can and has been made to work out. The change still allows the layout to function even if the whole focus now is pretty much on just the station and the traffic passing through. While some boards have gone the compromise on the curves at the end of the layout means that its unlikely high speed running can or should take place and the lack of the extra length will mean that engines running on sound are not seen accelerating as much off scene. Still, it manages to hold onto a lot of the original idea - the station, depot, loading area, branch and north exits all remain. So there should be a lot of activity for those watching to enjoy. 

    Will try and post some updates and photos as time allows, but this is after what has been a change of plans... 

    • Like 2
    • Friendly/supportive 2
  10. So - it wasn't my best move. Plugging in the connecting blocks to test the track saw me plug in the blocks 2 further to one side than they should have been. There was a short snap sound as all the 3v LEDs got fried at once. I looked around, realised what had happened. Checked the power over to proper supply. Nothing. It would all have to be done again. 

    Thankfully, the way the layout is made has paid off. Taking up the boards allowed relatively easy access to the wiring the lampposts that needed swapping out. Some scenery needed to be given some persuasion to let go, but this can and has been fixed once its back down again. 

    20231230_173914.jpg.f187755ef871a96f6090db6a8bc70a8e.jpg

     

    The buildings on the next board are now getting built and put into place. The kits are a range but give the town scene a decent feel to it. There is one that will become the 'North Eastern Hotel' with another to become an office/ council building that deliberately doesn't fit in with the buildings around it. 

    20231230_173918.jpg.dcb82c16c65d275d59b7a1251c4e8f66.jpg

    Another view of the buildings into the town scene. The road is made from sandpaper that was bought as a roll and then sprayed with a can from Halfords. This gives it a nice realistic look. Pavements are made from thin wood board with slaters sheeting placed ontop. Most of the buildings here are actually HO scale but given the difference and realism I think all look fine. The aim here is to build a decent scene overall to give depth and interest rather than the fairly simple town buildings you can get at the moment in 00 scale. 

     

    20231230_173921.jpg.8779177bdf8ed28669f27ce6c1da8818.jpg

     

    In this view here you can see the main high street as well as another bridge under the railway. From one end of the town scene to the other is supposed to also be a gentle gradient, meaning that its lower at the station and higher for where the backboard and break scene will be. 

    The two tracks here show the lines away from the station, although the one on the left will be bi-directional so that access can be gained to the branch line point that will be on the final board. 

    Will update more soon. Hope its all of interest.  

    • Like 4
    • Friendly/supportive 2
  11. 17 hours ago, jjb1970 said:

    On the model, the obvious answer ro all the stuff about duplication would be:

     

    -if you want a tip top 31 and want the Bachmann model then buy the Bachmann model;

    -if you want a tip top 31 and want the Accurascale model then buy the Accurascale model;

    -if you want a tip top 31 and you are not wedded to either manufacturer then take a look at the models being made by both, price and other factors which may matter to you and then decide which one to buy; and

    -if you're not interested in the 31 and are not intending to buy one then why does it matter and why would it vex you?

     

    I don't see why the decision making process of model suppliers in deciding which subjects to model is our business. If anything it gives us as consumers more choice and keeps producers on their toes if they know their release has to stand on its feet against a rival release.

     

    Or...

    if you want full comparison over which class 31 is your preference ask Hornby to do 31407 in Mainline Blue... 

  12. Nice idea and a good livery to choose, but then fallen into the same trap as Hornby when picking which 'Fragon-wagon' to do. 31452 is the only one with the headlight mounted on the left side, the rest of the fleet had it at the middle above the bufferbeam area. This just makes it harder to renumber a 31 as they often ran in pairs, although doing this for two Fragonset 31s at the prices that these will fetch will show more than some loyalty to those liking the black livery with the red stripe. 

  13. 10 hours ago, The Johnster said:

    Is the rumour true that you are going to produce a working 4mm scale model of a British Rail BLT sandwich, with DCC sound?                                                                                                                                                             


    Is one function where you whack it off the counter to see how solid it is?

  14. 12 hours ago, nightstar.train said:

    I think it's interesting to compare this announcement to the new class 37. Obviously this model was already well advanced in development when Accurascale announced theirs and so couldn't be cancelled. Bachmann have been sensible in choosing (mostly) liveries not done by Accurascale, so there should be space in the market for them. What I find most interesting is their pricing strategy. I think that Bachmann have had their fingers burnt with the class 37 with many variants not selling well and ending up heavily discounted. I've always attributed this to the fact it was significantly more than the Accurascale model, with virtually nothing to differentiate them detail and spec wise. With the class 30/31 they have priced it in such a way so that, after the usual retailer reduction, they are basically the same price as Accurascale. And £40 extra for the auto uncoupling is a very keen price. There are no variants in this run by Bachmann that I want, but if they had done a Wessex trains pink, a Railtrack blue/green, Reggie Rail, Intercity or a Fragonset model I would've jumped in for a sound deluxe model. I do think that the Mainline model may be a misstep and end up cheap after a while. Accurascale are doing the exact same loco, and it is a limited edition by them. Tellingly it hasn't sold out at Accurascale, unlike the EWS limited edition that was announced at the same time. 

     

    Bachmann usually announce Green and Blue Period releases as one batch, then some other later liveries as a second before back to Blue and Green and then later again. The later ones normally shift between either sectorisation and into privitisation and current privitisation liveries too, when its their turn. Here Bachmann look to be casting the net a bit wider and doing more by releasing more as other companies are doing. Its about time rather than the 3 models per batch that has been done. 

    As regards choices, I saw the pre-production pictures and hoped they would be going for popular choices straight away. The Blue and Green versions I can understand given the tooling and period chosen, but given Bachmann's price point is bound to be much higher than Accurascale I thought thats the part they should have used to get people to go for their version. Choices such as 31/5 in Civil Engineers Dutch, Regional Railways, Trainload Coal (to go with nuke wagons), Fragonset (the plain black one was never done) or 31454. Easy choices would have been any of the last 4 for EWS, save the EWS one itself. Personal best idea would have been 31110 in green, with the disks and modern headlight or 31190.  

    Others have said that Bachmann have been hit by the class 37 not shifting and to be honest I can see the same happening here... 

  15. The false floor idea is a good way for me to be able to build strength into the boards but also keep the boards in position and secure. It leaves the flat surface of the main board underneath allowing the board to be moved around and not risk damage to wiring, scenery or other items that can be exposed. 

     

    20231228_121458.jpg.313d98eef239f1b8bb4c9e20c4a5e3d2.jpg

     

    Here the frame of this board starts to come together. Struts across the board allow the scenic deck to be built on. 

     

    20231228_121515.jpg.438eec5ad98bc6022f244e70d2c74b3a.jpg

     

    Here as well as struts the boards for frames for the raised track level is going in. The bridge also has to be placed so that the levels for track can be worked out. 

     

    20231230_173914.jpg.ccc4d15c59c6b4ab4be1232142e91e64.jpg

     

    Then buildings start to be placed and the scene starts to build. Trackwork was placed to work out how things would look and lighting went in. Just as things were starting to come together.... disaster strikes... 

     

    More on that soon!

    • Like 2
  16. Hello all, 

     

    Time for another update as work has been going on over the last few months and theres a fair bit to catch up on. 

     

    With one board of the town scene starting to come together it was time to move onto the next. This saw buildings made for the next board done and then put roughly in place. Due to the scenic items on the layout, such as the bridge the track here snakes over towards the middle. This was just to add more interest as to be honest I have not planned this whole area in great detail. Its just been something that has evolved overall. 

     

    20231106_192347.jpg.6f638b91e760b8530ec4d77679d62d1c.jpg

     

    Here the track can be seen showing where the new routes will go. 60201 The Eleventh Earl of Mar is deliberately placed onto the up line as this area will be bi-directional over one line. 

     

    20231106_192402.jpg.5e3616bd978333878e7cf87c4cf5d918.jpg

     

    A view of the raised parts of the trackbed being done and worked out. This has the need for the board to also have a false floor built in so that electrics can be placed under buildings. 

     

    20231106_192417.jpg.9db34e2463cfae1e003e1243fa181100.jpg

     

    Another view of the basic town extension taking place. With the idea of the road down the centre forming the main part of the high street. 

     

    More soon. 

    • Like 3
  17. On 31/01/2024 at 12:52, charliepetty said:

    Livery samples should be at Glasgow & Model World live at the NEC !!!

    142 Northern RTR.jpg


    Should the marker lights protrude from the front. They almost look flush. Love the detail captured on it all. 

  18. Just seen this so joining in the fun... 

    Obvious ones missing from the ranges available to me are;

    J21
    B16 (all types)
    Q7
    BR Standard 3MT
    A8

    New tooled 8F, A3, A4

    New tooled HST and Mk. 3s with lighting in coach and CDL
    Decent unbranded TEA tank wagons with oil stains and weathering

    Long welded rail train
    Working tamper

    Class 170/171
    New tooled class 220/221/222 Voyager/Meridian

    Mk.2z in choc and Cream a la Vintage Trains rake
    (dare I say) new tooled Mk. 1 with working lights

    Bagnall Victor/Valiant/Vulcan Saddle Tank engine
     

    • Like 5
    • Informative/Useful 1
×
×
  • Create New...