Jump to content
 

Dad-1

Members
  • Posts

    467
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Dad-1

  1. Sadly Kadees offer a great solution to an insurmountable problem of finding a cheap simple way of uncoupling.

    The original OP was specifically interested in coaches and I have run a friends layout where working with bogie

    coach stock was very reliable. I don't uncouple my passenger trains as I only run them on a Roundy-Roundy.

     

    For a short siding weeds can activate the standard tension lock couplings. As with every system there is a problem !

    What you can't do is run a locomotive over the weeds, they stand too high for the limited clearence under locomotives.

    Here is a short video -

     

    For my large layout where I run trains of 40+ and need to separate at any location around a 45 ft + circuit I use a manual

    method. There is some derision regarding the 'Hand of God', however there was no automatic uncoupling in BR freight

    yards. They all relied on a shunter with his pole, so in actual fact shunting with a magnet on a stick is much more prototypical

    than an automatic magnetic, or weed activating system !!

     

    The difficulty is being within easy reach - NOT always possible and as good a reason as I can think of for trying, and trying again

    to succeed in finding what Kadees need on YOUR layout

     

    Dad-1

  2. Kadees CAN work, but in my opinion are a flawed system for use with '00' British outline

    freight stock.

    O.K. This will almost certainly cause a storm, but it's true.

    It can easily be said that the problem is caused by ...... everything BUT the Kadees !!

    Get the fitted height right to within 0.04 of a mm ? Perfect central alignment ? Remove

    any slack in the axle boxes so the wagon always tracks EXACTLY over the centre-line

    of your magnets. Keep B2B's to a level where there is little lateral slack.

     

    What a load of rubbish !!

     

    The idea is great, the engineering of components is commendably good - SO WHATS WRONG ?

     

    Whats wrong is that British outline freight, in fact almost any piece of rolling stock has magnetic

    metal wheel sets, wagons are also usually ballasted by mild steel weights, all this is prone to

    producing Magnet Creep. Magnet creep stops the Kadees from working as planned due to a

    piece of rolling stock following the train and not fully disengaging.

     

    I have heard it's always the modellers fault - Too much magnet, or conversely too little magnet.

    Well, to operate well into the free shunting mode there needs to be enough magnetic pull to

    separate the knuckles. This is already enough to cause creep, reduce the magnetic pull until

    there is no creep and the couplings won't function fully !!

     

    As to super free running stock, something that I've always thought as being the ideal (and I

    have run a 57 wagon train at an exhibition) it is a curse for Kadees, accelerating the magnet

    creep problem.

     

    I do have them working to around 90 - 95%, but this is achieved on a shunting puzzle where

    all the stock used has been fitted with brass wire brakes. The down side of that is a light

    Hornby sentinel 0-4-0 is unable to pull 6 wagons without slipping to a halt. Luckily that is the

    absolute limit of train length only used very occasionally, and with 5 wagons it will just manage.

     

    The principal is good, the engineering is good, but the sad truth is they are not really compatible

    with the British outline wagon, be that kit made, or from any of the other RTR manufacturers.

    Yes I do have a big choice of wagons (close to 500) from up to a dozen different sources.

     

    Dad-1

  3. For me the real 'Rub' is that I really wanted a 48XX for the clubs new exhibition layout.

    Personally I have a Dapol 14xx as well as a Hornby version. Surprisingly perhaps for

    some they both run reliably as they bounce along. I had hoped a 'New' allegedly

    improved version would be an improvement in accuracy AND running. When I buy a

    new locomotive I expect it to run ...... in an acceptable way. My previous 90 have, so

    it was regrettable and one can't fault Hatton's in giving a refund, They did however

    ignore my letter asking if they could check one before sending ............ MMMmmmm.

     

    Dad-1

  4. Yes Brinkly,

     

    It's going back, You can't knock Hatton's, I had their reply at 09.13 this Sunday morning !!

    My concern is that THIS IS what we want for the layout, BUT it must be a good one as it's

    for the clubs new West Bay layout that I'm currently working on in my shed.

     

    NHY581 obviously has problems with the same version - HOW many do I try before we give up ?

     

    Dad-1

  5. What can I say ....... all the exit comments were that it was good and so much better

    than our old accommodation in the United Reform Church hall in central Bridport

    where parking is so difficult to find.

     

    Signing off Summer exhibitions until the last weekend in July 2019 - Same venue !!

     

    To cap it all my Castell Mawr was voted best in show by the visiting public.

    We ended with a Hornby 42XX pulling 57 ...... To think a guy once told me he'd read

    in some review that they didn't have very good traction ?? - What ??

     

    Special thanks to all our visiting layouts, traders and guys in the club particularly

    Terry for spending much of the day outside monitoring parking.

     

    Dad-1

    • Like 1
  6. My last shout for this our first enlarged exhibition, we hope to be the first of

    many at this new location.

    Currently working my way through 6 pages of 'check lists' to have everything

    required on hand - like a battery powered soldering iron !!

     

    Please come and enjoy, including having a go on the 'U' drive shunting layout

    Look for the sign !

     

    post-7874-0-17481400-1532428460_thumb.jpg

     

    post-7874-0-00198900-1532428540_thumb.jpg

     

    Dad-1

  7. Back to realizing just how much work can be involved in running a larger layout at an exhibition.

    It's freight ..... HOW many wagons ? Currently sorted out 164 that are going, and hankering after

    at least another 20 !!

    Currently stacked in the shed :-

    post-7874-0-53612200-1531388478_thumb.jpg

     

    Now to find and box all the buildings and nit-knacks, animals, builders merchants stock and .............

    Just as well I still have 2 weeks !!

     

    It'll be a good day after which I think I'll need a holiday !!

     

    Dad-1

  8. We've been waiting for times before announcing that this year to help getting visitors

    to our new venue we will be - Running an open top bus service

     

    This will be free, but we are asking for donations towards the costs of fuel which we expect

    to be in the region of £70

     

    The timetable has arrival & departure times but I shall only show departure times

     

    Beaminster (square) 09.30

    Exhibition 09.50

    Bridport Town Centre 10.00

    Bridport Bus Station 10.10

    West Bay (George Hotel) 10.30

    Bridport Bus Station 10.50

    Exhibition 11.10

    Bridport Town Centre 11.20

    Bridport Bus Station 11.30

    West Bay (George Hotel) 11.50

    Bridport Bus Station 12.10

    Exhibition 12.30

    Bridport Town Centre 12.40

    Bridport Bus Station 12.50

    Exhibition 13.00 Arr     13.45 Dept

    Bridport Town Centre 13.55

    Bridport Bus Station 14.00

    West Bay (George Hotel) 14.20

    Bridport Bus station 14.40

    Exhibition 14.55

    Bridport Town Centre 15.05

    Bridport Bus Station 15.10

    Beaminster (Square) 15.40

    Exhibition 16.00

    Bridport Town Centre 16.10

    Bridport Bus Station 16.20

    West Bay (George Hotel) 1635

     

    It's also day 2 of the Bridport Folk Festival so this bus will allow transport over and above just the exhibition.

     

    Dad-1

  9. Currently working in the sunshine cleaning tracks and checking electrics - A month to go, but at the speed I work that's

    imminent !!

    Photo's in the sun are so much better, wish I'd bothered to add the 5 trees that live on this board.

     

    post-7874-0-88376600-1529586741_thumb.jpg

     

    The loco ? somewhere up on the embankment. This is Wales

     

    'N' layouts coming :-

     

    Bincombe Cutting

    Longmoor

     

    We'll be adding the listings of all later.

     

    Dad-1

    • Like 1
  10. One last curtain-Call for our Open Day

    Ron said he'd bump it up, but has the excuse of a broken computer.

    Still so long as his all sound Shillingford layout is there I shan't complain.

     

    Being less formal than an exhibition it hopefully gives more chance for

    us to chat over a cup of tea.

     

    Dad-1 is the chairman so come look me out.

     

    Dad-1

  11. Thanks Ian,

     

    No I don't have any shellac, meths is no problem so long as is doesn't loose any light

    distillates during it's 40 + years in my bottle !!

    I was wondering if Gum Arabic could be applied is exactly the way you suggest, which

    should turn them into water slide decals ?

     

    However as Steamport Southport suggested I have already got the HMRS LNER wagon

    sheet ordered. It think it offers all I need l except the allocation names and I had wanted

    to mark up as 'Thirsk' - the valuable part of that original sheet is in those allocations of

    York; Malton; Leeds; Goole; Hull; Newcastle; My late father was from Thirsk and I was born

    in Newcastle. The HMRS sheet has a 'Gateshead', that if the correct size I can use !!

     

    Dad-1

  12. Hi John,

     

    Thanks for the suggestion, but no luck. I may have tried a rather a strong 50/50 meths/water mix,

    but as everything was still on the table nothing to loose.

    I've also tried Microsol without it making any difference.

    I note HMRS do an LNER sheet where I can get suitable numbers, and N , E, although I don't

    know the comparative size to the original decal sheet.

     

    I'm going to try floating individual letters on a film of Johnsons 'Clear', but that approach wouldn't

    work with an allocation name as on this Cooper Craft sheet each letter in a name is an individual

    and separate letter.

     

    Dad-1

  13. I'm just finishing off a Cooper Craft NER birdcage brake van.

    The decal sheet is allegedly press-fix, not a problem as I've used loads

    of HMRS press-fix ....... Only !!

     

    The decals have dried out to the degree where the tacky attachment

    layer has completely dried up and the decals won't adhere to any surface

    and feel completely dry. In fact the adhesive protective tissue was loose

    without any indication of having been on the sheet.

     

    I cut out a couple of letters and carefully laid on a test surface, added a

    touch of water, the tissue coverings lifted away, but the letters (tested twice)

    wouldn't stick to the test piece. Dead glue !!

     

    Must check what decals are included on other HMRS sheets that I don't have.

    Normally I'm a GWR modeller. 'Thirsk' in 1.0 mm white letters would be nice !!

     

    Dad-1

     

  14. We're having a club open day on Sunday 27th May from 11.00 - 15.00 Hrs

    at Askerswell Village Hall (Our normal club meeting venue). This is just north

    of the A35 Dorchester to Bridport road.

    Entry is free for anyone within striking distance to come & meet us.

    Light refreshments available, biscuits/cake and drink at minimal cost.

    We will have the clubs test tracks 'N'; '00' analogue; and '00' DCC up and running

    as well as 5 members layouts covering 009; '00' sound'; '00' shunting that you can

    try your hand at, and more

     

    This is not an Exhibition, but a day to meet and enjoy our hospitality. For anyone

    that can't read maps find us at DT2 9EW.

     

    Dad-1

    • Like 2
×
×
  • Create New...