Jump to content
RMweb
 
  • entries
    297
  • comments
    368
  • views
    84,020

James Harrison

729 views

Hot on the heels of the L1 comes the next loco project....

 

.... a BEC whitemetal 'Improved Director'.

 

This is a kit I bought late last year and for reasons I'm now starting to remember put in the 'I'll get round to it someday' pile.

 

Well today was that day and I'm starting to regret it, though I must say I do enjoy a challenge.

 

The first problem was a biggie.... the castings are buckled. The footplate I straightened out by gluing the splashers to it fore and aft and then applying pressure in the middle of the splashers using pliers. The boiler halves were the real issue; they went together nicely at the back and around the smokebox but part at the the bottom of the front and in the middle.... it took a fair amount of fettling, and I'm sorry to say some colourful language, to get them back straight-ish. They're still not quite right now.

 

349_zpsb13aa649.jpg

 

348_zpsde98a35f.jpg

 

I was able to use the boiler fittings from the kit, though I did replace the chimney with a spare casting from the L1 kit (the L1 and D10/ D11 share the same boiler diagram- I'm not entirely sure this extended to boiler fittings but the L1 casting was so much neater than the BEC example).

 

Overall at the moment- bleurgh. Just look at the amount of filler I've had to use to fill in the worst of the gaps.... and I've still to go back over it once the glue has dried. Oh yes, I'm gluing this together with UHU. The last time I used a soldering iron I managed to pick up the hot end....

 

The basic model's gone together easily enough, but I think that the experience has been enough at the moment to put me off whitemetal kits. The material strikes me as being too soft and pliable for larger castings like boilers and the fact it melts at low temperature has put me off soldering it. I think if I decide to go down the metal kit route, I'll go for brass ones.

  • Like 3

4 Comments


Recommended Comments

Comparing it to a Charles Reddy drawing in 'The Harmonious Blacksmith', it seems to match up pretty well above the running plate.  Below the running plate it looks as though the front frames above the bogie are a work of fiction- they don't just 'not match' the drawing, they don't come close!  The dome supplied in the kit also looks a little suspect- too small (though in the right place).  I may replace the dome with a Craftsman A5 one, which I think is nearer the right size.  Hope this helps. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Good to hear I'm not the only one who picks up the soldering iron at the wrong end :-)

 

This kit may not be the bee's knees but you're clearly making some fast progress. That's 1

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Progress will slow down pretty soon... more than anything else I start a new job next week :) which entails more commuting and less modelling time.  I reckon the D11 will be a nice model, but it's going to take a fair bit of fettling to do.  I've already decided the dome is too small, so I'll be replacing that shortly with a Craftsman one (Robinson tall dome from their A5 kit).  The main problem I finding is that the parts flex- it all gets neatly set up and glued and then it slowly returns to its 'banana form' before the glue dries.

 

The big question is when it is finished, how will it stand up against my Jaycraft D10? 

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...