Jump to content
 
  • entries
    17
  • comments
    96
  • views
    71,466

A Caledonian duo


Ben Alder

2,685 views

Following on from my completion of the Highland 0-6-0's my attention turned to a pair of engines that became a trademark of much of the Highland section in its latter days of steam- A Pickersgill 4-4-0 and a Macintosh 0-6-0, both of which proved very useful additions to the motive power department and which stayed till dieselisation.Once again, these are venerable white metal kits from Nucast and DJH respectively, and have been unavailable for some time now, but were part of my strategic reserve of models for the area in case R-T-R versions weren't released :angry: Well, it has proved a wise move and I am working through them methodically now. The double build of the previous two proved quite practical, so I decided to build these side by side as well, which seems to work for me- any hiccups with one can be puzzled over whilst attending to the other, rather than packing the problem away as was often the case before.

 

It dawned on me that this burst of activity is the first time I have built WM kits for nearly forty years blink.gif and most of them are of the same vintage, with many of the attendant quirks that characterised these releases, but different standards and expectations were the order of the day then.
One great step forward though for me has been to finally master white metal soldering, and most of the construction of these two has been this way, and very enjoyable it has been too....

 

To the models- the 4-4-0 had been started before and packed away at least twice, wheras the 0-6-0 was a straight build from the untouched kit. A look at the boiler and footplate casting as it came- at least it is a fairly solid base to work from- the HR footplate was very flimsy and twisted at the slightest provocation.

 

blogentry-2642-0-60751900-1309465302_thumb.jpg

 

blogentry-2642-0-88158400-1309465318_thumb.jpg

 

As before, R-T-R chassis were used, a T9 for the bogie and a Bachmann pannier for the 0-6-0. The T9 was almost an exact fit but the other is a bit of a compromise, and involved hefty carving away from the splashers and footplate to get the coupling rods to revolve freely. Fortunately the thickness of the castings and the generous clearance allowances for the coarser original Romfords made this possible. The pannier drivers are also a bit underscale as well, but to the eye on the layout it passes as acceptable.

 

blogentry-2642-0-81686500-1309465872_thumb.jpg

 

The 0-6-0 body ready for motor fitting- a small amount of filing and trimming back of the firebox area was needed, but compared to the amount needed on the smaller boilered HR ones this was one of the easier bits of construction.

 

blogentry-2642-0-82766700-1309472064_thumb.jpg

 

 

 

Assembly proceeded, with much perusing of images of the two types, and use of my trio of solder, superglue and 90 second epoxy can be seen in this photo. I found epoxy handy in boiler and fittings fixings- things like domes and chimneys could be tweaked into the correct position while the glue sets. However, problems soon appeared with both engines. The bogie engine turned out to be squint, with one footplate half leading the other by a mm or so, but showing up as out of squares all over the engine. Now, I don't know if it was a casting fault or a built in mistake by myself in the original gluing together, but the whole assembly had to be dismantled. I thought I might lose the whole casting, but to my relief it came apart more or less intact.

 

blogentry-2642-0-60750800-1309466819_thumb.jpg

 

It was from here on that the soldering iron became the preferred tool of choice as I discovered the hole filling properties of 70o solder and lashings of Powerflux, and the home made extractor fan started earning its keep. I managed to square up the chassis and after that there was little to note of with the 4-4-0. Everything went together with little problem apart from getting things square and in the right place, which involves studying pictures of the real thing as the instructions were of little use except to photograph WIP on sad.gif

 

Eventually body work reached a basically intact state and much buffing and cleaning was done to get rid of decades of oxidation and general grime, and then work started on the tenders.

 

blogentry-2642-0-20418200-1309467521_thumb.jpg

 

The two types had a plethora of pipes and fittings on them, esp. the bogie and I decided to make at least a representation of this on the bodies. Fortunately, both types have been well photographed in colour, so much poring over the like of Keith Pirt's Scottish volumes and others was done. It turns out that hardly any two had the same arrangement, so I did enough to pass muster although I basically used specific pictures of 57585 and 54491 as prototypes.The bogie engines had Westinghouse brakes, as did some 0-6-0's, but 57585 wasn't fitted as such, at least in my period.Two views of the bogie loco with pipework here.

 

blogentry-2642-0-67522000-1309468247_thumb.jpg

 

blogentry-2642-0-26225800-1309468285_thumb.jpg

 

As an aside- the cab backhead casting- an example of 1970's detailing wink.gif

 

blogentry-2642-0-44751500-1309468265_thumb.jpg

 

When I started the tenders it became obvious that there was something far wrong with the 0-6-0's one. Here it is as supplied and tacked together

 

blogentry-2642-0-67051900-1309468797_thumb.jpg

 

and after modification.

 

blogentry-2642-0-92253700-1309468976_thumb.jpg

 

Starting with a complete ignorance of CR locos, I soon discovered what a minefield this subject can be- lots of variations on a theme, usually blithely dismissed under the catch-all phrase of Jumbos. They seem to have had common access to tenders and fittings, and trying to pin down what went where proved too much work for a one-off job. I finally settled for 57585 which had steam and vacuum fittings and a smaller tender than that supplied. This was achieved by cutting down the existing one and using a strip of plasticard to pass as a patch repair that lots had to disguise any rough bits. The tendertop flare was sadly underdone as well, so much filing away of metal and some brutal bending of now very thin WM was needed to remedy this.

 

blogentry-2642-0-99459500-1309469644_thumb.jpg

 

blogentry-2642-0-24789600-1309469657_thumb.jpg

 

Eventually, with this cured, progress was uneventful and tenders were ready for priming.

 

blogentry-2642-0-83703100-1309470078_thumb.jpg

 

blogentry-2642-0-91040600-1309470060_thumb.jpg

 

I decided to model 54491 with the cab doors closed- a rarely seen feature of the real thing, but as there is a lot of chassis showing in the cab I thought this might disguise things a bit. I also added rolled up cab weathersheeting, which can just be seen in some of the layout photos.

 

blogentry-2642-0-25306100-1309470045_thumb.jpg

 

One final hiccup with the 0-6-0 showed up after priming- despite looking at dozens of images of the real thing I had glued on the chimney supplied with the kit at the start of the build, but only noticed its apalling shape at a very late date. It can be seen in this image.

 

blogentry-2642-0-01757500-1309471286_thumb.jpg

 

and in this workbench shot, where a prototype pic is in the background. Anyway, a replacement CR one was found and fitted.

 

blogentry-2642-0-34722000-1309471451_thumb.jpg

 

They had two coats of Humbrol acrylic primer and three of GW Chaos Black, with 54491 then lined out with Pressfix transfers. Weathering was confined to a dusting of well thinned Humbrol no.79 through the airbrush for this one, and 57585 received the same then about ten following coats of variations of browns, greys and black added to the basic mixture till it had a subtle mixture of shades passed over lightly to give a well worn look.
At the time of writing I still have to tidy up the cab numbering of 57585- a gloss varnish adhesive base still shows up in photos, and needs some disguising.

 

Lastly, a couple of the engines in action during their running-in turns.It was an interesting build and has given me two useful specific engines to add to a growing more accurate roster.

 

blogentry-2642-0-97998900-1309471911_thumb.jpg

 

blogentry-2642-0-61216500-1309471894_thumb.jpg

 

blogentry-2642-0-99485600-1309471873_thumb.jpg

 

November 2013- addendum.

 

The Bachmann chassis as originally fitted was too far out, even for my lax approach to the odd mm or two, so has been replaced with a C class version, which is more or less the correct spacings. Additional work was also done to the body work after even more shortcomings were noticed with this kit. A copy of a booklet covering the restoration of 828 showed up errors in cab cutout shape and spectacle glasses. The attached photos show this,so a bit more filing was called for to remedy things.

 

blogentry-2642-0-64098900-1415057073.jpg

 

blogentry-2642-0-84016500-1415057118.jpg

 

blogentry-2642-0-12313900-1415057147.jpg

 

Replacing the chassis involved some butchery in the cab area as the motor is set further back than the pannier, so a spare T9 backplate was fitted to hide this. Brutal stuff at this stage, but its amazing what a coat of paint can disguise....
blogentry-2642-0-45301000-1415057582.jpg

 

blogentry-2642-0-54266400-1415057280_thumb.jpg

 

And finally, in service and looking a bit more like a 812....

 

blogentry-2642-0-09237500-1415057407.jpg

 

Addendum Dec 2017

 

To bring this up to date, I eventually tired of the flaws in the 0-6-0 and with the advent of the Hornby 700 did a rebuild of this loco into a more presentable CR 812. The original 57585 had its chassis removed and the kit one built without a motor and the loco went to an elderly gentleman who had an interest in Thurso based engines to spend its retirement in a display case alongside other 60D residents. He has since died but the family are retaining the collection as a memory of their father. Here is a shot of the replacement conversion at work. It has since this photo had a replacement chimney fitted.

 

blogentry-2642-0-39234400-1512682831_thumb.jpg

  • Like 5

15 Comments


Recommended Comments

  • RMweb Gold

Some heavy work there. That cut down tender is well worth the effort. You seem to get the same thing with GW loco's, a big tender only carried by a few and thats what the kit manufacturer plumps for!

Don

Link to comment

Many thanks for this article, very inspirational and two beautiful engines being the end result.

Link to comment

Thanks for the kind comments- I like to get something finished before I announce it to the world, as too often I can get sidetracked, but feel free to comment or ask if anything needs clarifying. I have also found that most of a modelling evening can vanish somehow if I start looking through RMW :blink:

Link to comment

Richard,

Could you comment on how the (whitemetal-bodied) Pickersgill traction compares with the traction on your (plastic-bodied) Wee Ben. I seem to recall that you were going to fit non-traction tyres on "Ben Alder"; did you in fact do this on both models?

Alan

Link to comment

:blush: - got sidetracked :blush: Actually they are on the workbench at this moment- I decided that it would be easier to do the two at once, and the current plan is to fit Romfords to one chassis and use the spare Hornby wheelset to donate an untyred set of drivers for the other. This is dependant on me removing and replacing the drivers on the axles successfully, so we'll see how that goes- I'll post as soon as it is done.

There is no real load demands on the Ben and no gradients involved so I don't foresee much of a problem from this course of action.

Link to comment

Just spotted this Richard and there's been a lot of fine work, not to mention perseverance with those kits… and you've made a really good job of them. Building them after 40 years, that's impressive – and makes me feel a little better about the white metal car kits that I haven't touched for 20-odd years!

Link to comment
Guest stuartp

Posted

Superb work there, thanks Richard. I have a Pickersgill and a Jumbo to refurbish, and another Jumbo to finish, and in all three cases the armoured chassis is the main obstacle to progress. So plenty of ideas there, thank you !

 

As for the tender it looks as though they've packed the tender from either the 66 Class or one of the Dunalistairs by mistake, DJH did both way back when. The standard issue Jumbo has the 'long slot' Drummond tender chassis (or at least both of mine have !).

Link to comment

Superb work there, thanks Richard. I have a Pickersgill and a Jumbo to refurbish, and another Jumbo to finish, and in all three cases the armoured chassis is the main obstacle to progress. So plenty of ideas there, thank you ! As for the tender it looks as though they've packed the tender from either the 66 Class or one of the Dunalistairs by mistake, DJH did both way back when. The standard issue Jumbo has the 'long slot' Drummond tender chassis (or at least both of mine have !).

 

Well, that explains a lot- I did contact DJH about this and getting another one, but didn't get much of a response, so went ahead and altered what I had. The kit chassis were the main reason they sat unstarted for so long, and are only fit for the bin IMO.

Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

It's great to see kits of Scottish locos actually built and running. Hopefully there are more in your store to follow, most enjoyable to read of your progress through the months. You are bang on about modelling time being lost when going into RMW and before you know it the night is closing in and no work on the layout has taken place!

Link to comment

There does seem to be a burst of Scottish activity just now. Kingfisher24 has his photo gallery full of goodies and Benachie is producing some nice 4-4-0's, and Oldlugger has a lovely J88 on his gallery. I am almost finished a HR 0-6-4T and there could be another three or four yet to come,although I now really have enough for my needs, but the construction bug is still biting and it might be a good idea to carry on while it is still there.

 

Both 4-4-0's now have chassis with no traction tyres- much to their running benefit-and they both are capable of handling the loads required of them, which isn't much TBH as a couple of coaches and a small freight load is all they have to pull, so the lack of grip of a tyre does not affect this.

As a sideline of this I now have some double tyred T9's that I hope will grace someones layout that does need grip :rolleyes:

Link to comment
Guest Max Stafford

Posted

Thanks for putting these up Richard. Like Stuart, I still have my old half-built Jumbo and Pickersgill lying under the bench. I hadn't thought of using proprietary chassis in this way to finish them but might just do that now having seen your own wonderful results!

 

Dave.

Link to comment

superb modelling of typical working scottish locos.

 

could you possibly put up a pic of the pickersgill 4-4-0 showing the cab interiorand how much of the chassis form the T9 shows, as i am tempted to have a go myself.

 

gary

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...