Martinaston

Andy It is a sad fact that as well as creative, skilled imaginative craftsmen who can create the feel of a time and place, this hobby also attracts a large number of sad obsessive types who can think of nothing better than to find some small details to nit pick. She really isn't worth spending any time worrying about. Please don't take any notice, simply say "poor thing, she can't help it" and carry on being creative, skilled, imaginative, instructive and funny. This would be a poorer place without you and your support and encouragement to every one on this forum. Best wishes Chris

Just a thought......................................how about if the NER branch was designed as an end to end rather than a roundy-roundy. You could then set a couple of trains off on their merry way on the main line and run the occasional train along the NER and back. That might open up a whole new range of options geometry wise.

Hi Jeff I can see what you mean about wanting to include the tunnel air vent, a very interesting railway related structure - and certainly of more interest than a blank fell or even yet another small gathering of sheep. I think my worry is that it might be visible in views/photos which also include the line of the track and the tunnel portal and so look "wrong". Although associated with the tunnel would it not look better placed as far as possible from,and not obviously related to, the tunnel portal? Chris (the name Martinaston reflects another interest - no prizes!)

On my one and only post so far I did say I wouldn't make any further comment as I simply cannot bring myself to pass judgement on such wonderful work..........but, in my VERY humble and uninformed opinion, a tunnel air vent should surely be sited over a tunnel and some distance from the tunnel portal. If I am reading your sketch correctly your proposed position is neither.

Hate to disappoint you Jeff - still no-one disagreeing with you! The disagree tag happened by accident, I was only aware it was me when I looked back to see who it was - that has to go down as the most embarrassing ever first involvement with the forum, I have been following your progress avidly for a long time but haven't posted before because I do not feel qualified to comment. In reality I am in awe of what you have achieved but as I do not have a layout, (only an eclectic collection of stock so far), I have kept my thoughts to myself. I WILL start a layout one day,( planning has been going on for a looooong time), and I take inspiration from the wonderful efforts of you and many others on the forum. Best wishes Chris