Jump to content
 

2750Papyrus

Members
  • Posts

    915
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by 2750Papyrus

  1. 4 hours ago, ERIC ALLTORQUE said:

     All the big capital battleships met their end by airpower and an aircraft is peanuts compared to the cost of a capital ship.

    Not true.  Royal Oak and Barham were sunk by U boats, Hood, Scharnhorst and Bismarck by other battleships (though the latter had been incapacitated by aircraft).  Queen Elizabeth and Valiant were fortunate to be moored in shallow water when subjected to underwater attack.

     

    Aircraft carriers were - and are - just as vulnerable to air attack as surface ships.  Battleships became obsolete because the range of their main armament (guns) was a fraction of that of the aircraft carrier (aircraft).

    • Like 1
  2. 5 hours ago, Barry O said:

    You obviously have never met the submarine builders of Barrow.. they get quite loud if someone says something they disagree with... generally in the words "PICK YER WINDA!"

     

    Baz

    If it came to fisticuffs, would they floor-plate you?

    • Like 1
  3. 18 minutes ago, Flying Pig said:

     

    It's hard to see a situation in which Britain remained at war with Germany and the conduit from US production capacity remained open as anything other than a British and later Allied victory, regardless of who shot down more aircraft.

     

    An interesting viewpoint, strategically, though I think most people at the time - including Goering? - would have taken a tactical perspective. 

     

    I think I agree that Brits would have been aware that the immediate threat of invasion had been defeated. Was there a widespread appreciation of the extent to which US production would contribute to eventual victory? 

     

    Whilst Churchill believed this and worked hard to achieve US support, the Battle of the Atlantic determined how valuable this output was. 

    • Like 1
  4. Interestingly, I think all posters ascribe to the opinion that the BoB was a British victory.  Eric "Winkle" Brown records that, in his meeting with Goering, he asked who won the BoB.  Goering replied that it was a draw, citing that British losses in the latter part of the battle were similar to German losses, and that the battle ended when Hitler cancelled Sea Lion and started planning for the Russian campaign.  I don't think I've ever seen discussion of this view.

  5. I would recommend "GWR Goods Services An Introduction" by Tony Atkins and David Hyde to anyone interested in finding out more about goods train operation.  Whilst it is obviously about the GW, the principles involved would have been used on other major systems.  The complexity of the services provided, and the thousands of staff involved, I found really eye-opening.  Last week I bought a book from OPC and the parcel included their summer 2022 brochure, which offered this volume and volumes 2A and 2B for £20, a  real bargain if still available.  Further volumes deal with topics such as collection and delivery services and docks.

     

    I have also just finished reading two volumes on the operation of bus services by the railway companies up until 1932 and have been struck by the extent to which the railways, and the GWR in particular, provided an integrated transport system of the type no longer existing in the UK.

    • Like 1
    • Agree 2
    • Informative/Useful 1
    • Interesting/Thought-provoking 1
  6. My last employment was with a small UK subsidiary of a large US company.  My colleague and I found amusement in some of the names of our US colleagues, the best of which was "Randy Spangle". 

     

    We had to explain that to our US MD!

    • Funny 5
  7. Many years ago, I picked up a rebuilt LNER Claud Hamilton at a toyfair.  Quite a decent attempt using a cut-down B12 body on the L1 chassis.  It was a steady performer but is now relegated to a cupboard by the modern Hornby model.

    • Like 1
    • Informative/Useful 1
×
×
  • Create New...