I’ve read through this thread and it seems that I’m the first RMwebber to have seen it, so I shall give my thoughts.
The film itself - brilliant.
Accuracy of rolling stock - disappointing, and I was rather hoping that the significance of the film would prompt extra effort by the producers and the KWVR to ensure there would be period appropriate locos and rolling stock, but instead it seems that it’s been a case of five minute jobs that make token changes.
However, I don’t go to see a film to moan about incorrect railway liveries, I go and see a film for the story it portrays. And the storyline was very well laid out; there are many themes of the original film/novel that are replicated, such as having to move to the countryside because maintaining the current livelihood is unsustainable, the lack of two parents resulting in the eldest child adopting some maternal roles, a sense of duty to help someone in a crisis despite pressures against themselves and a closely connected kind hearted gentleman who has influential connections that can be of help. It was also interesting to see how the Second World War has led to that repetition.
Abe, the black US soldier, added a new dimension to the story and shines a light on racial tensions that existed in the US army during WW2. While a fictional story based on real events, Michael Morpurgo’s book ‘The Amazing Story of Adolphus Tips‘ features two black US soldiers, one of whom says how the family they befriend were “the only white folks he knew that treated him like family”. With Abe, he wants to go home not because he is a coward, but because black soldiers are being racially abused. What follows is just like the landslide scene in the original film; an example of childhood ingenuity rescuing individuals from a threat, also with the use of a large white sheet.
I fear the soundtrack of The Railway Children Return will be Dunkirk Mk2 - one that I loved but everyone else found annoying! All the same, it helps set the scene for the combination of drama and discovery that lies in the film.
All in all, I thought it was a great film that I’ll probably buy on DVD!