Jump to content
 

Pugsley

Members
  • Posts

    2,804
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

Posts posted by Pugsley

  1. Hi all,

    Anymore thoughts on the VAA van and OAAs. are they any good. 

     

    Thanks Peter.

    I don't know about the OAA, but the VAA is a typical Heljan model, IMO. Overall it's OK, but with some niggles once you start really looking at. The chassis is missing some strengthening ribs and there are a couple where there shouldn't be any. The springs are too shallow - the front of the spring mounts should be roughly level with the bottom of the solebar and the front links should project beyond them. The roof profile is wrong, it's too steeply curved, so they are a bit higher than they should be.

     

    There are also the bits that drop off, but they're quite easily glued back on.

     

    On the plus side, they're quite easy to rewheel to S7, if that's your kind of thing. So, I suppose, overall they're not too bad for the money, they just need a little tweaking, if you're a bit of a detail obsessive :D

    • Like 1
  2. Annoying, but we shouldn't assume this is a mistake. Part of designing a model is making it look like the real thing. Another part is making it cost effective to produce and fit together.

    Whilst that is true, objective two should never overrule objective one, otherwise it becomes an impression, not a model.

     

    Edit - I suppose, what I'm trying to say is that those two design goals are not mutually exclusive. The overall priority should be to make it look like a miniature version of the real thing, but it also needs to be cost effective to produce.

  3. Also noticed a reluctance to go into reverse when the gearbox is fully warmed up, the car has only recently had a brand new clutch slave cylinder fitted so I've no idea what's causing it. Awkward really as it has to be reversed in or out of the garage every time I use it!

    If it's only when warm, could either the master or slave cylinder be getting too hot? That can degrade the fluid and reduce the effectiveness of the clutch. It may also be worth checking that the replacement slave cylinder is exactly the same as the one removed - it will have an effect if the pitson size is different.
  4. Hi Pugsley,

     

    the Class B tank wagons - (Esso & Regent anyway) are not numbered but the Departmental one - Waste Oil is numbered - ADB999074. My question is - what about the little valve that is fitted at one end of the tanks - why have they not modelled that? and has anybody any thoughts as to a source for them? Nice models though.

     

    cheers

     

    Mike

    I didn't realise that - I was basing my observations on the vans and the opens.
  5. I also think they should have really not added the data panels/numbers (like their locos) as I now have to remove them all from my rake too as they obviously can't all have the same number!

    That's the one thing I can't quite figure out about these wagons - they supply the locomotives with no numbers, but the wagons, which you're far more likely to buy in multiple, come with numbers applied!

     

    Perhaps Heljan is a Danish company with an Irish background :D

  6. I tend to agree. At © I think we can see a groove in the board. If you look futher up in the opening, there is no sign of texture or cracks. The lighting is also better here, so any cracks should be visible ( B ). This indicates that there is metal sheeting covering everything.

    Yes, I agree, the entire area is metal sheeted.

     

    Scrutinizing the image I have also discovered som shadows behind the hinges (A). Could there be some brazing supporting the fixed three plank part of the sides?

    I think that is bracing there - if you look just to the left of the hinge on the far right, I think you can see the same bracing for the other side.
  7. I'm terrified of hand-building pointwork

    Don't be, it's quite straightforward once you get into it.

     

    Bullhead is well catered for from C&L, flat bottom is a little trickier in as much as the pre-machined rails aren't available, but still achievable. I built these for my, still unfinished, layout:

     

    file.php?id=101697

     

    You can either use Templot, or C&L sell templates for standard sizes. I'd recommend Templot, it allows you to design whatever track layout you want, reducing your reliance on standard sizes.

  8. There are a couple of good pictures in the Wagonload book by Paul Shannon (in the Rail Freight Since 1968 series) of the ends of these wagons, on pages 55 an 57 (I can't post them here for obvious reasons. Comparing these to the picture above, the roof might be curved a little too much, but not excessively so, but it does look as if the areas above the doors, between them and the roof, are a bit too deep.

     

    That might be why the wagon is a bit taller than it should be - it's probably only 1-1.5mm, just a bit difficult to correct.

×
×
  • Create New...