Whatever way you look at it, I think that the WHR are always going to need the big strong Locos (Garretts and the SAR 2-8-0s) because as the name suggests, it runs throught the Welsh HIGHLANDS?
Whilst it is nice to see the original stock for the line running, concessions HAVE to be made for revenue. Of course I suppose everyone just getting on together would be out of the question?
Suppose it really is a case of the finished product justifying the means?
On the other hand, if all that should be run is "heritage"/original stock, maybe someone needs to ring up the NYMR and tell them they've got to get rid of their Bulleidsn N15s and Schools classes.... And while they're at it they could tell the SVR that Westerns never went on the line? No? Didn't think so...
If a weekend of small children telling mummy and daddy that Thomas is coming pays the bills for , say an overhaul of Russell, where's the problem? It's not a perfect world, but compromise is the name of the game. So the FR might have been seen to be heavy handed and stepping on toes (Not taking any sides here), but the job is almost done, why not concentrate on making it into one of the new "Great Little Trains of Wales"???
Phil
PS, Could you fit a canoe in the guards van? That way I could do the Afon Glaslyn without the long walk back to the car... Hmmmmmmmmmm.................... :D:D