Well on the basis of the thread and the photos I have just ordered one!
if the technology works, there is a link to a video I took and posted on Youtube of a Sentinel four wheeler working at Brit Zinc Avonmouth - with authentic noises! I filmed it working in 1998 - the loco and its sister worked until 2003
Best wishes
Devonbelle
Devonbelle,
Thanks for posting this video. You can see/hear that there is not a great deal of sound or variation from the engine even under load.
This gets to a fundamental question about sound projects. Should the sound be as authentic as possible, even if that means it is uninteresting or, in the case of some horns I've recorded from other loco types, just plain horrible?
Or should the sound author use a bit of discretion to make operating the model more exciting, more immersive or simply more pleasant?
Please. These are rhetorical questions, I don't want this post hijacking on this point. If you wish to add to this debate there is an existing thread here:
http://www.rmweb.co.uk/community/index.php?/topic/44317-should-dcc-sound-favour-prototypical-or-pleasing/?p=482720
What I have decided to do is to provide two sound projects on the same decoder. One will be for the times the user wants as much authenticity as possible, and the other will have an alternative, something more like the sounds in the clip I posted.
Users will be able to select the sound project they prefer by changing CV265. This can be done as often as you wish, giving greater choice to the end user.
Kind regards,
Paul