Jump to content
 

Episode 7: Loose Ends, Last Orders and a Fresh Challenge


Keith Addenbrooke

341 views

Our planned house move is now likely to happen in the Summer.  With more time to get ready, an Easter update makes sense.  There's a new challenge to report on, as well as some modelling progress.  I'll start with loose ends being tidied up:

 

Loose Ends:

 

Left over from my American HO project last year was my incomplete Walthers' Grain Elevator Kit.  I've been keen to build this for a good while, so even though my plans have changed it was nice to get it finished.

 

First task was to weather the head house and loading / unloading shelters.  As I use brush weathering, it made sense to do this before assembly:

 

Photo2bGrainElevatorHeadHouseWeathering.jpeg.fa6540261ad03a838ab54d53adffd0fc.jpeg

 

I added some styrene card strengtheners to the head house when I assembled it, and a false floor at the elevator end to hide the curve of the silos:

 

IMG_0757.jpeg.ba309494112521fabb0ecdc7f0

 

The finished model is as impressive as I'd hoped, even if it would still be small by prototype standards:

 

IMG_0759.jpeg.7677442675d9d5225835c31bbe

 

Photo5bGrainElevatorVehicleSideView.jpeg.54ab5537ec2482bf4582f81eb8f2b7ce.jpeg

 

IMG_0758.jpeg.872dea40dfbeb318cf6f6b8ebd

 

(Some of these images also appear in my Narrow Gauge HOn30 thread)

 

Question is, what to do with this now?  We're having a big clearout, as our new home will have less storage space.  The Narrow Gauge mini-layout I built in 2021 has been passed on through our local 009 Society Group, and I have thrown out some of the building kits I assembled a while back but now have no use for (I really didn't need a dozen railway stations!).

 

I wasn't sure what to do with these three American HO building kits though - all personal favourites but also now surplus:

 

IMG_0696.jpeg.6d9f0e8b90959ba1524ea563fd

 

IMG_0698.jpeg.e66737da97b88f8b3d50aa8322

 

IMG_0699.jpeg.eaad25baadceba309be24bf1eb

 

All three being Walthers meant they were designed to complement each other, with selective compression carefully managed to help them go together.  When I compared them to a part-built Craftsman Kit of a single store however, the illusion was broken.  All of a sudden, the Walthers buildings look smaller than they probably should, although all are 1:87:

 

IMG_0702.jpeg.4e79b148d5ee632a82bfa5739c

(Images above have also appeared in my HO Union Station Diorama thread)

 

After this test, it was a much easier decision to part with the three plastic buildings, donated to the local Model Railway Club for use or onward sale through their Club Shop.  This has created a bit of space on the workbench:

 

Photo9aPostClearout.jpeg.aa82a5c17e481d186c1f86c2d93869d6.jpeg

 

The Craftsman Store Kit is being kept for possible use in my HOn30 project, but progress is slow.  Each window has delicately cut separate upper and lower sashes.  As the frames (and shutters) have 'peel and stick' backings, they aren't difficult to assemble, it's just one of those jobs I find best tackled in small stages:

 

Photo13StoreFrontWindows.jpeg.849cb7e976e5c3142a4d136e754bf9ff.jpeg

 

Photo14StoreFrontWindowsInsideView.jpeg.9c72a0b7f8af0dad362acb9933e09caf.jpeg

 

When completed, the model will appear in my Narrow Gauge Modelling Thread.

 

Last Orders:

 

My previous blog entry talked about the impact of Hatton's Model Railways closing.  Largely out of sentiment, I made a last minute purchase just before the website closed, buying a heavily discounted Continental Signal Box (Stellenwerk):

 

IMG_0589.jpeg.f47c3ab36e428101a14edfecc6

(also pictured on the ‘Hattons to close’ thread)
 

But 'Last Orders' applies to some modelling too.  Our current,  Victorian house has a single-storey outhouse at the back which I've been able to use for spray painting and as a baseboard factory.  With a couple of larger kits in my stash, it makes sense to spray the larger components now, even if I don't tackle the actual kits before we move.

 

It's no coincidence I have two models using the same components, as I bought the Post Office as a substitute when I couldn't find an affordable kit of the station (I'd noticed the Postamt is modelled on an end part of the station):

 

Photo20NeustadtandPostOffice.jpg.82b23ac1a2fd9e4a1d9069a2ff0bc5fd.jpg

 

Key parts of the Post Office were sprayed first.  This is now all dried and back in the box (not the box pictured):

 

Photo21PostOfficeSprayPainting.jpg.f3d62f4ff1372f402996289488a3f841.jpg

 

Just getting a photo of the pieces for the station proved a challenge: the box is not only large but 4" deep.  In the end I took advantage of the floorspace created by ditching a bed that used to be in this room but had become surplus too:

 

Photo11NeustadtBox.jpeg.253a1c46abd2eb4f79c72a61d3bb20a9.jpeg

 

Photo19NeustadtPieces.jpeg.b2e7657812a781b218fd91f0ac644b3c.jpeg

 

These are just the walls, having been painted and left to dry in the outhouse before coming back in.  It's big:

 

Photo20NeustadtSprayPainted.jpeg.10226e67c212dec94fea3efb1cf19e97.jpeg

 

I think the photo on the box shows the station as it appeared in an earlier era, matching the postcard shared by @Mikkel below my previous blog entry, here.  Over time I think it has been repainted in a lighter colour, which I prefer and which explains my choice of colour for the walls.  The current version of the kit is lighter in colour.  I also brush painted the impressive entrance piece for colour matching:

 

Photo15NeustadtEntrance.jpeg.71fed3c7d7a65eaa4035d66bdc2fdb0a.jpeg

 

With the baseboard factory also closing, it'd be good to place a final order (with myself) before we move.  At the moment it's all just tidied up for house showings:

 

Photo16Outhouse.jpeg.662c20bce15e8c55dec9512861d6d8a2.jpeg

 

But this brings me to:

 

The Fresh Challenge:

 

In previous posts for this blog, I've been refining my modelling aims and project list.  But I've now run into: 'the problem.'  Our new home is more modern and will be much better for us in many ways, both as a family and as my wife and I work out of the home office.  But we're losing spare space and storage - not just the outhouse.  As we make progress with our much needed downsizing clearout it's become possible to see how life will work after we move, and we've realised the plan we had to accommodate my modelling and layout interests isn't going to work - at all! 

 

Long-suffering readers of my contributions to RMweb over the past four years will be familiar with the regular changes our family needs have imposed upon my ideas for space to use.  Now I'm having to think about modelling with no space at all.

 

Let me explain: I'll be able to set up a workbench in a spare bedroom when the family aren't staying, but the lingering smell of paint and glue means it needs to be in a room where others aren't waiting to use the space (we won't have a garage, a cellar or a large shed in the garden either).  I can look at ideas for portable layouts, but have to think about a question I was first asked about portable layouts by @AndyB in August 2020: "Where will you keep the layout?"  It's a rather good question for a property without storage space:

 

I have been here before: the first layout I ever had (but didn't finish) was a very compact N-Gauge Branch Terminus to Continuous Run that could easily have come from an early Cyril Freezer plan book (3'8" x 2'2", with 9" min. radius curves and points):

 

image.png.dd28bf2c3b33aa6717940029d3c06ca9.png 

 

I wrote about it in the Layout and Track Design Forum back in 2021 (here).  When not in use, it actually went into my wardrobe!  But I wasn't trying to include a station that will be 3' long or run mainline trains (or have three layouts)! 

 

If I'm going to build some new baseboards before we move, I need to get my thinking cap on again.  Despite all the lessons I've learned, I've never really considered the prospect of having no dedicated space.  I've always assumed I'd have a railway room one day (when the kids grew up), and never imagined I wouldn't one day be building the kind of layouts I dream about.

 

I'd like to see trains like this running on my own layout:

 

 

This was a test run to see if a six coach train looks OK for mainline running in H0 (I decided it was):

 

 

But a 6' x 3' table top isn't what I'm aiming for!  I know lots of dedicated modellers face this challenge, and have often posted on the Boxfiles, Micro layouts and Dioramas Forum (and back in the day contributed to Carl Arendt's Micro-Layout website).  It's just not what I'd been working towards.

 

I've plenty of modelling to keep me busy (not everything has been shown in this post), but whatever happens next may - once again - look a little different.  Until then, thanks for reading, Keith.

 

Photo22Brian.jpeg.3885f1e2748e951bb25b089548357a03.jpeg

 

 

 

Edited by Keith Addenbrooke

  • Like 2
  • Friendly/supportive 4

14 Comments


Recommended Comments

Hi @Keith Addenbrooke always interesting to read you latest post.

Out of interest I'm wondering how big your new garden might be?

 

It's a shame you're losing your outside workshop.

 

But I'm wondering if there might be room for a very small shed which could accomodate a terminus down one side of it. And an out and back track outside the shed? Some folk punch a hole through their shed walls to allow trains to go in and out. 

6' x 4' sheds are around £250; comparable to a couple of locos? Maybe there are 2nd hand ones going begging.

 

All the best. Andy

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

Thanks @AndyB, the outhouse has proved useful.  The baseboards I brought with me sat untouched in the garage for a couple of years after we moved, until I began my Great Western Adventure(s) during the 2020 lockdowns, and I realised the outhouse was the perfect workshop for spring and summer.

 

At the new house, I’m afraid the garden is very small, as the house is on a corner: in the old days that would have meant a house with a big garden and plenty of room, but now it means two houses squashed in with small triangular shaped rear gardens meeting at the point instead.  There is a shed already (for garden tools, etc) and a conservatory, but not room for another shed.  As I’m no gardener, we’re OK with this, but an outdoor layout isn’t really an option, Keith.

  • Friendly/supportive 2
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Is there perhaps a local club that have premises that could house a portable layout?

  • Like 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
2 hours ago, ian said:

Is there perhaps a local club that have premises that could house a portable layout?


Thanks @ian, an interesting idea - our 009 Society Group doesn’t have a premises (a hall is rented for monthly meetings), but there are several societies locally I could talk to, including the very active local club whose buildings are close by (the club to whom I donated my American HO buildings).  Thanks, Keith.

 

Edited by Keith Addenbrooke
  • Friendly/supportive 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

Remember the dreams of railroad empires we used to sketch out in our youth (and sometimes still do)?  While sorting some stuff this morning I found this plan for the Cumbres & Toltec 3’ Gauge Railroad.  I’ve not been there, so it must have come with a calendar I had a few years ago:  

 

IMG_0841.jpeg.14caf024cca44de850e27116b3a41bd2.jpeg

 

In the context of this blog post and conversation, it struck me as exactly the sort of thing I think still sits behind my perpetual flow of over-ambitious project ideas, so it seemed relevant to share it here.  Beautiful!  Keith.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

 Hi Keith, some remarkable buildings to be seen here, the Grain Elevator not least!

 

I went through a similar downsizing exercise some years ago when we moved to a 91m2 flat, and if by "no space" you mean no dedicated layout running space then that's been my situation for 5 years now. I've been pleasantly surprised by how quickly I adapted. To give you an impression of how it works:  

 

I have a desk in our living room and some shelves in a cupboard. I can fit a a light (foamboard) layout on the desk and the larger table top layouts go temporarily on the dining table (which can be extracted for greater length). I use water based paints, non-odour glues, plus a handheld vacuum cleaner and a wet cloth to constantly remove plastic dust from filing etc.

 

We do have a small attic space two floors up where I store the layouts, but for convenience I usually keep one or two of the layouts in one of those plastic boxes that go under the bed. If you keep the structures detachable then they can go in the cupboard and the layout module will be flat enough to fit under the bed. 

 

It does require a small-layout or modular approach of course. And it probably helps if you're the kind of modeller who likes to work on just one or two projects at the time on your desk. With your interest in structures, that seems to match though. Although I admit it would be hard to fit the grain silos under a bed - and that it's a bit more complicated when there are kids around!

 

  • Like 1
  • Informative/Useful 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

Thank you @Mikkel - for clarifying that I do indeed mean ‘no dedicated layout running space’.  No self-respecting fan of micro-layouts can claim there’s no layout space at all, and your Farthing layouts / modules are a wonderfully creative application of the concept.  The explanation in your comment of how you manage to arrange modelling practically is particularly helpful as a useful guide to minimising disruption to home life, thank you.  A welcome aid to domestic harmony!
 

The Model Railroader author and contributor Pelle Søeborg is another modeller who comes to mind who’s face the challenge and moved to diorama modelling.

 

Steering my ideas back to micro-layouts would require some careful thought - the structures and trains I’ve been buying haven’t been collected with that approach in mind, but could be an option - perhaps alongside (or as part of) a portable layout?  I certainly feel encouraged by the responses from yourself, @ian and @AndyB.  Thanks to all, Keith.

 

Edited by Keith Addenbrooke
  • Like 1
  • Friendly/supportive 2
Link to comment

My personal take home from this is to count my blessings. I'm fortunate to have room to build and leave set up a space for my own layout. 

 

@Keith Addenbrooke I think you get a lot of pleasure from assembling building kits. And this might feed into a working diorama approach. I particularly liked the large station building g you shared with us. Nice bit of work that. 

 

You've previously focused on the roundy-roundy style of layout. But thinking about what Mikkel has mentioned I'm wondering if a small (hinged halfway) FY to terminus layout might work...with removable buildings for compactness.  Two  3' x 12"?

 

Or a US-themed shunting plank with a hidden FY siding inside a low relief warehouse. 

 

Not forgetting that a small, nicely modelled layout trumps a large mediocre layout every time.

 

  • Like 1
  • Agree 2
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

Thanks @AndyB - exactly the kind of ideas I’m already having:

 

3 hours ago, AndyB said:

I'm wondering if a small (hinged halfway) FY to terminus layout might work...with removable buildings for compactness.  Two  3' x 12"?

 

Definitely on the list for consideration: something I could tackle in either Narrow Gauge H0e or early-era German H0 with what I already have (previous pictures refer).  I’m reminded of the ideas a few years back for IKEA Billy-bookcase layouts.

 

For a larger project with my big kits and longer trains, I could see if a Minories-type terminus / FY might be possible, or at least a working diorama rather than a shelf display of stand-alone buildings?  (As you say, I do enjoy making structures).

 

3 hours ago, AndyB said:

Or a US-themed shunting plank with a hidden FY siding inside a low relief warehouse. 

 

…perhaps like this one, which I have in stock - when built it is 19.5” long, enough for a couple of boxcars to be hidden:

 

IMG_0844.jpeg.0d5271f59fe249665cc5ce9195271632.jpeg

 

In my break today I’ve spray painted the parts of this kit to get it ready for assembly.  It wouldn’t take long to get started, as despite several rounds of clearing out and slimming down my collection(s), I still have the buildings for a US switching layout - add a transload / team track facility and there’s more than enough for a portable Inglenook:

 

IMG_0845.jpeg.5275715b424065d9a3fbba3dbd59e1fc.jpeg

 

My first task though is to put the brakes on - even with the busyness of Easter, this is the stage in the ideas process where I can easily go in to hyperdrive: with almost 50 years of studying track plans and ideas to call on I’m already generating too many ideas - it is settling on something that is genuinely practicable and seeing it through that needs consideration.

 

Knowing me, I’ll be tempted again by smaller scales, even though my exploring has proved H0 gives me a nice balance when it comes to the proportion of modelling time to be spent on the frustrating fiddly bits (every scale has fiddly bits).  Z-scale remains enticing, but as I struggled with some of the detail in N (esp. couplings), I need to be disciplined / realistic about how I’d fare when things started to break on a Z-scale layout (static model shown here with H0 Sam): 

 

IMG_0846.jpeg.638d225b5ec37926b1768d748821ac41.jpeg

 

My hope is that moving house and starting with a clean slate will give me the incentive to change my thinking about what will satisfy me as a layout project(s) - to match that with what I will actually have storage space for.  There is certainly much to be said in support of your final observation:

 

4 hours ago, AndyB said:

Not forgetting that a small, nicely modelled layout trumps a large mediocre layout every time.

 

Very true - there are some fantastic small and micro-layouts around.  Once we get the keys to our new home (which should be soon), I can try and turn the excitement of new opportunities into project ideas - all being well, that’ll be what happens next, Keith.

  • Like 1
  • Friendly/supportive 1
Link to comment

"...I could see if a Minories-type  terminus / FY might be possible,..."

 

red-alerts.gif.9c571bf6089f46c4f4fad69293435f19.gif

 

Other track plans are available. 🤣

 

You might like to take a look at this book. A lot lof interesting micro plans, UK and US outline.

 

20240326_171851.jpg.04f4ad02e3778ef5cf54a593315df520.jpg

 

As for the switching layout this one came to mind...from the 1977 MRC exhibition.

 

20240326_174956.jpg.96aba564b7ffaa8d79dafc2427f32fe7.jpg

 

I'm certain there's a layout out there for you. And, as you say, a new home nay inspire you. 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
  • Administrators
8 minutes ago, AndyB said:

You might like to take a look at this book. A lot lof interesting micro plans, UK and US outline.

 

20240326_171851.jpg.04f4ad02e3778ef5cf54a593315df520.jpg

 

That Dockside layout on the cover is excellent... 😁

  • Round of applause 1
  • Funny 1
Link to comment
1 hour ago, Phil Parker said:

 

That Dockside layout on the cover is excellent... 😁

Ah yes. A small dockside layout. 

Keith could have his 🍰 ...and you'd eat it.  🤣

  • Funny 2
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

Thanks @AndyB and @Phil Parker.  From memory, author Nigel Adams was a Vicar in Coventry.  I remember going to a model railway show they put on inside his Church (I think there were half a dozen layouts, all O Gauge / Scale). I seem to recall he was also involved in the Talyllyn (volunteer guard?).  I did have a copy of the book, must have been twenty years ago now.  Melbridge Dock is an excellent example of a small layout that has stood the test of time.

 

Not sure I’ve seen a plan for Wyandotte Transfer before, but it was another well-known layout back in the day: I think it was featured in “The Encyclopedia of Model Railways” sold as a Marks and Spencer “St Michael” book in the late 1970s / early 1980s.  Thanks Andy - two very good examples (and a good cake joke too), Keith.

 

Edited by Keith Addenbrooke
  • Like 2
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold
On 26/03/2024 at 18:01, Keith Addenbrooke said:

 I still have the buildings for a US switching layout - add a transload / team track facility and there’s more than enough for a portable Inglenook:

 

IMG_0845.jpeg.5275715b424065d9a3fbba3dbd59e1fc.jpeg

 

 

That's a good idea. Bud's Trucking Company looks very suitable as one of those buildings that both give a purpose to a couple of sidings and at the same time serves as a facto backscene. A good choice by Walthers for a kit.

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...