Jump to content
 

The Great Unrest: Modelling the 1911 railway strike


Mikkel

3,710 views

Here’s an attempt to reenact the 1911 railway strike in OO. The strike was an important but sometimes overlooked event in the social history of Britain's railways, and involved some very unusual scenes. The cameos are based on contemporary photos, but transposed to my own Farthing layouts.

 

 

1. The strike begins

 

001.jpg.4dbcbbc659feed9010b9b85032d65b55.jpg

 

“The Great Unrest” was a period of labour unrest during the years 1911-1914. 

 

 

002.jpg.7c4307649ccea0e88a9743bcf72171e7.jpg

 

The period saw more industrial disputes than any before it.


 

003.jpg.8c887dd8dd7d38fb5ac3b62418255653.jpg

 

During the years 1911-14 there were 4229 officially recorded strikes in Britain.

 

 

004.jpg.c97ceeaf4247d898def7af481a84726e.jpg

 

This included Britain's first official national railway strike which took place over three dramatic days from August 17-19, 1911. 

 

 

005.jpg.2c581b616f152227ca3b4b25baae3b81.jpg

 

The strike arose from dissatisfaction among railway workers with the lack of progress in the so-called Conciliation Boards that were supposed to negotiate worker’s conditions. 

 

 

006.jpg.f23999a3f127ae4fdf8b467ca230e4a0.jpg

 

In June 1911 railway workers in Liverpool joined dock workers and merchant sailors in the Liverpool Transport Strike, demanding shorter hours and better pay.

 

 

006b.jpg.de49f7eb2027f10959c570778e07fba1.jpg

 Source: Ronramstew on Flickr.

 

The strikes in Liverpool gradually gained broader support and spread to other towns. With some delay the railway unions decided to back the strikes and expand them. A formal national railway strike was declared on August 17.

 

 

007.jpg.7132276bc01c837357399c29f4572dbd.jpg

 

The unions sent telegrams to 2,000 railway centers across the country, urging all railway workers to abandon work and go on strike.

 

 

008.jpg.d64abfc01efc5abe18d4c066c00be7b3.jpg

 

According to sources this increased the number of workers on strike to approximately 150-200,000 of the 600,000 railway workers recorded at the time.

 

 

009.jpg.fab6c1b2ecf4f5724da3c3fc0ec25e41.jpg

 

Action was most intense on the railways that connected with the North, including the MR, LNWR, NER, GCR and GWR. On the southern railways, few workers got involved in the strike.

 

 

2. Bearskins on the line

 

010.jpg.c0d25e9b65e74d8a60285016248e9a17.jpg

 

The railway companies refused to accept the strike and met with the PM Asquith, who guaranteed that they would be able to continue railway operations.

 

 

011.jpg.bbe81fb67070463f3fff1a7db59b4a63.jpg

 

After a failed attempt to negotiate an arrangement with the unions, Home Secretary Churchill approved deployment of 58,000 troops around the country.

 

 

012.jpg.7ab4d18b371fdc81a87b7d3f91ed18c6.jpg

 

The army’s brief was to secure running of the railways and avoid interference or sabotage by the strikers.

 

 

013b.jpg.25773a64d3d52ad7ef500ce8d8da31d0.jpg

 

Numerous photos from around the country show troops guarding stations, signal boxes, junctions and loco sheds.

 

 

014.jpg.67d2cd66129aacbfa6de7c025ecb8c78.jpg

 

This scene was inspired by a photo in the 1911 edition of "The Sphere", showing troops guarding GWR facilities.

 

 

015.jpg.598ec68844303edb012fd839c002a224.jpg

 

 Many of the deployed troops wore an unusual combination of field uniform and full-dress headgear.

 

 

016.jpg.5e96c0756ad140012e93fa0d7884b64f.jpg


Perhaps an early spin doctor had been at work?

 

 

017.jpg.2ebe07044cb0bbc823c4c2b6cbfbf9cf.jpg

 

Similar scenes were captured at e.g. LeicesterYork and Clapham Junction.

 

 

 

3. Crossing the picket lines

 

9478455871_52b77dfce6_o.jpg.ddd93d722546762f03f75652d236f423.jpg

Source: Sarah on Flickr

 

The army was also employed to assist the police escort horse-drawn deliveries.

 

 

019.jpg.735e74bfe5149589adba8033de7a8d73.jpg

 

Photos show horse-drawn wagons lined up in small convoys.

 

 

020.jpg.6320a5480023840126e95f475fdb5b97.jpg

 

The stable-men were all on strike, so no reins 😊. No, reins are just not practical on my layouts which are constantly set up and dismantled.

 

 

021.jpg.b2e69ee03559420160c06363a62319fc.jpg

 

With the protection from troops, some goods got through to their destination.

 

 

022.jpg.87314b074a90c68900f9f5afd4ef8e71.jpg

 

Other cartage vehicles were stopped by striking workers. 

 

 

023.jpg.5686130721f1e17eeaa46b2aef853844.jpg

 

Pictures show confrontations in the streets… 

 

 

024.jpg.3a146e2fae00dd4541faab96a2dc8a4a.jpg

 

… as workers sought to halt deliveries and confront strike breakers.

 

 

024b.jpg.3d324f7dd88750cecfe8e018196c22b0.jpg

 

In some cases, horse-drawn wagons were overturned to stop their progress.

 

 

24c.jpg.b6765c5ce565cf006104d1afb7d4bd12.jpg

 

The disturbances fuelled some sensationalist reporting in the media, but the strike also led to more fundamental debates about the salaries and rights of railway workers.

 

 

4. Impact on passenger operations 

 

025.jpg.c54e7ccf734b8fe3ca9dab337979074d.jpg

 

Passenger operations were differently affected across the country. 

 

 

026.jpg.37b870546b41c348e776950aaf4f55bf.jpg

 

In areas with little strike activity, services were maintained to some extent.

 

 

027.jpg.e585af80aac08e90f0680fb440dbca3b.jpg

 

Nevertheless, knock-on effects led to delays and cancellations in many parts of the system.

 

 

029.jpg.7a80c278a07a5788bbaa99356770ff79.jpg


In some areas most of the staff were on strike and trains came to a complete standstill. This scene was inspired by a photo from Manchester which shows passengers walking along the tracks, having left a deserted train and making their way into the station.

 

 

030.jpg.d0146be41d3d4f01bc8c484a58ca9526.jpg


The largely unstaffed stations must have been a strange experience.

 

 

031.jpg.d7cf44add8f80d05daa7365546548335.jpg


Without staff, what is a railway?

 

 

5. A Siphon Special

 

032.jpg.ccb68b0126801bfacf8aab2a481816ee.jpg


With so many men on strike, it became a challenge to secure sufficient stock for passenger services.

 

 

033.jpg.c6002ce0e20b16021159982d2982f6d3.jpg


Special measures were therefore required. This is an old K’s Siphon that I got off ebay. The doors were cut away…

 

 

033b.jpg.ba0d00ce50d215d125f450ab1a387e85.jpg

 

…and new ones made from laminated styrene.

 

 

034.jpg.ec96c73c2c1d757b1e10e6976014eb6b.jpg


New doors in place…

 

 

035.jpg.a8d31275506aa00c16867f0b67dbbf2d.jpg

 

… and a few details added.

 

 


This short video clip shows the roof fitted with magnets, thanks to Dave John for that idea.

 

 

036.jpg.0860b8a9b385b0b9780b56afef2899a3.jpg


A Siphon Special.

 

 

037.jpg.5e3789f2594f6012c6557da645a5679f.jpg

 

Perhaps you think I'm pulling your leg.

 

 

038.jpg.78f7f99ef31558fb02c418d15034bdac.jpg


Surely the glorious GWR wouldn't transport passengers...

 

 

039.jpg.7a31aa5702d350f95a625aa0c5a6bf86.jpg

 

... like this?

 

 

040.jpg.9c290ebdbb1bc9157a6dbedceb6bdf67.jpg

 

But once again...

 

 

 

041.jpg.304acc7ef9be41054634ad2b9756595b.jpg

Source: Embedded from Getty Images.

 

...reality beats fiction.

 

 

6. Tragedy at Llanelli

 

Despite the lighter moments this was serious business, and at Llanelli it went all wrong.

 

042.jpg.d7ba5a10d04e572ac5888e34373b2180.jpg

 

In a confrontation between the army and strikers on August 19, two civilians were shot and another four lost their lives in the explosion of a gunpowder van. There's an account of the sad events here.

 

 

043.jpg.7be6fe632a88360a4fa56c2956d3a03c.jpg

Source: Embedded from Getty Images.

 

I didn’t feel like modelling the tragedy itself, so decided to portray a scene from the following day when locals came out to inspect the damaged stock, as seen above.

 

 

044.jpg.49f4b2cf81ce4b1e2602f29571413757.jpg


Several GWR clerestory coaches were damaged in the clashes between army and strikers. Photos show them in 1908-1912 all-brown, so I painted my Slater’s C10 in a simplified version of that livery.

 

 

045.jpg.e4b1d352e5a110f88c4f9b8720ab6b64.jpg

 

Some distressed glazing was then added.

 

 

048b.jpg.2715f2a34c671b13e537ed55b7f218ac.jpg

 

Pictures show police, staff and curious locals inspecting the coaches.

 

 

047b.jpg.405864c6d109b6fe6a078de079dad57c.jpg

 

I wonder what they were thinking?

 

 

046.jpg.aa821dbd2f55218a1992ca5340397d4c.jpg

 

There’s certainly a sombre mood in some of the photos…

 

 

049.jpg.12d2b0aad4614324ef72c919d9003ab1.jpg


…the shattered glazing a reminder…

 

 

050b.JPG.d4e747c70beccb74b4897b02d4c76ea2.JPG


…that beneath the elegance of the Edwardian era…

 

 

051.jpg.348d9911b916dd5c6e5b7d8a2b3bc2d8.jpg

 

…lay great tensions...

 

 

052.jpg.5dfef1464de5f63d266095cd09b4f33e.jpg

 

... and deep divisions.


***

 

By then the strike was over. On August 19 the government mediated a deal between the railway companies and the unions.   The agreement addessed few of the workers' immediate concerns, and some workers felt betrayed by it. The deal did however strengthen the role of the railway unions as legitimate players in negotiating worker's conditions. The unions considered it a win and called off the strike. The years that followed saw more railway strikes, some of them more succesful. But the 1911 strike was the first, and it showed that something was changing.

 

***

 

PS: Please note that this is just a rough account of the strike, and I am not a historian. For further online reading see e.g. David Turner's write-up about the strike, the Brighton ASLEF page, and the Llannelli Rail Strike website. 

 

 

Edited by Mikkel

  • Like 26
  • Informative/Useful 5
  • Interesting/Thought-provoking 2
  • Craftsmanship/clever 14
  • Round of applause 38

51 Comments


Recommended Comments



Another post that reaches places others cannot reach 🙂

How come you have such an extensive knowledge of British history?  I doubt many school children here know anything about such matters.

Beautiful modelling, as usual

 

Mike

 

  • Agree 5
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Remarkable even by your standards Mikkel!  I can only imagine how long it took to set up all those scenes, let alone take excellent pictures of it all.

 

Best wishes

 

Dave

 

  • Like 1
  • Agree 4
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment

Great story about the strikes! But think about what all the fun you can have if you team up with Andy Modelu!

 

-Haavard

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Thanks once again for the kind comments and buttons, it's very much appreciated - especially on this grey and windy autumn day here in Copenhagen.

 

I think it's interesting to explore how model railways can be used to illustrate historical events great and small. In a way it’s already being done on WW1 and WW2 themed layouts, and of course there was this:

 

 

 

@MikeOxon, with an interest in Britain’s historical railways it seems sensible to understand some context. Also I suppose I’m just a bit of an Anglophile (yes we still exist 😀). 
 

@Hawk Yes, working with Model U on this sort of thing would be fun! But perhaps not very profitable for Alan... I was also impressed with the military figures from WD Models that are illustrated in the photos, and of course the Andrew Stadden Edwardians.

 

I found another photo of the Royal Munster Fusiliers on "strike duty", here:   

https://collection.nam.ac.uk/detail.php?acc=1976-03-50-66

 

- and then there is the photo below, which claims that these are "soldiers", as opposed to police. But whether that is correct I am not sure. 

 

the-railway-strike-of-1911-london-a-convCaption: A convoy of Pickfords removal vans being escorted over Waterloo Bridge by soldiers. Embedded from Getty Images

 

 

 

  • Like 5
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold
23 minutes ago, Mikkel said:

Thanks once again for the kind comments and buttons, it's very much appreciated - especially on this grey and windy autumn day here in Copenhagen.

 

I think it's interesting to explore how model railways can be used to illustrate historical events great and small. In a way it’s already being done on WW1 and WW2 themed layouts, and of course there was this:

 

 

 

@MikeOxon, with an interest in Britain’s historical railways it seems sensible to understand some context. Also I suppose I’m just a bit of an Anglophile (yes we still exist 😀). 
 

@Hawk Yes, working with Model U on this sort of thing would be fun! But perhaps not very profitable for Alan... I was also impressed with the military figures from WD Models that are illustrated in the photos, and of course the Andrew Stadden Edwardians.

 

I found another photo of the Royal Munster Fusiliers on "strike duty", here:   

https://collection.nam.ac.uk/detail.php?acc=1976-03-50-66

 

- and then there is the photo below, which claims that these are "soldiers", as opposed to police. But whether that is correct I am not sure. 

 

the-railway-strike-of-1911-london-a-convCaption: A convoy of Pickfords removal vans being escorted over Waterloo Bridge by soldiers. Embedded from Getty Images

 

 

 

 

They would be soldiers.  The Metropolitan Police did not have spikes on their helmets, although the City of London Police did, but their jurisdiction was only within the square mile.

  • Agree 2
  • Informative/Useful 2
Link to comment

I grew up in Llanelly from the mid-1950s, until going off to study in 1973. The strike was still within living memory for my grand-parents' generation, and there was no great liking for Churchill.  Years after, I was talking to a historian, whose speciality was the various Left groupings in the early 20th century; on hearing where I was from, he asked me if I'd heard of the 'Industrial Workers of the World' AKA the Wobblies. These were originally from the West Coast of the USA, moving in to South America. Some of their members worked on the ships bringing various non-ferrous ores to the smelting works of S W Wales. If they were seeking to establish a presence in the area, it becomes easier to understand the level of Churchill's reaction.

  • Like 3
  • Agree 1
  • Informative/Useful 4
Link to comment
8 hours ago, Mikkel said:

I’m just a bit of an Anglophile

Be careful, we might be holding out the begging bowl soon - though I gather currencies aren't doing too well in Scandinavia either.

  • Like 3
  • Funny 3
  • Friendly/supportive 2
Link to comment

A further comment, one thing I realised was telling the story was the contrast between the different groups, the railway workers, the soldiers and the first class passengers walking the tracks. Very effective placing of the figures, and also their painting.

Spot on!

  • Like 4
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Thank you. The figures walking on the track was the most difficult one to do and didn't quite come out as I'd hoped. It didn't help that most of the figures I have are standing not walking!

 

Visually, there is something disturbing about large groups of people walking along tracks. No wonder, as it is rarely under happy circumstances.

 

gettyimages-3066343-2048x2048.jpg.15b486a96fe17ad37fa8df1c21efee8b.jpg

Caption: 2nd April 1934. Passengers walking along the track to West Hampstead station after their train was halted due to a crash further along the line. Source: Embedded from Getty Images.

 

Edited by Mikkel
  • Like 7
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold
On 27/09/2022 at 13:21, ChrisN said:

 

They would be soldiers.  The Metropolitan Police did not have spikes on their helmets, although the City of London Police did, but their jurisdiction was only within the square mile.

 

Thanks Chris, that led me down a rabbit hole. I came back up a few months before the railway strike, namely in January 1911 during the siege of Sydney Street. Judging by other photos this is Metropolitan police, with no spikes on the helmets as you say. And Churchill again. 

 

1708919789_Winston_Churchill_at_the_Siege_of_Sidney_Street_3_January_1911.jpeg.696357c11efaae8ae4f7061afbe406e3.jpeg

Caption: Winston Chuchill at the siege of Sydney Street, 3rd January 1911.  Source: Wikipedia.

 

  • Like 9
Link to comment
43 minutes ago, Mikkel said:

Metropolitan police, with no spikes on the helmets as you say. And Churchill again.

In fact, both the Met and the City police - note the difference in the helmets - some with a bright metal "button" and no spike  (Met) and others with a raised strip (City).  Anyway, two lots of police and some politicians, one suitably armed with an umbrella. Churchill remained Home Secretary only until the autumn of 1911 (Wikipedia says 24th October).  As I remember, he swapped places with the First Lord of the Admiralty.

 

A famous photograph much reproduced in school text books covering that era. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  • Like 3
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold
2 hours ago, Mikkel said:

 

Thanks Chris, that led me down a rabbit hole. I came back up a few months before the railway strike, namely in January 1911 during the siege of Sydney Street. Judging by other photos this is Metropolitan police, with no spikes on the helmets as you say. And Churchill again. 

 

1708919789_Winston_Churchill_at_the_Siege_of_Sidney_Street_3_January_1911.jpeg.696357c11efaae8ae4f7061afbe406e3.jpeg

Caption: Winston Chuchill at the siege of Sydney Street, 3rd January 1911.  Source: Wikipedia.

 

 

1 hour ago, kitpw said:

In fact, both the Met and the City police - note the difference in the helmets - some with a bright metal "button" and no spike  (Met) and others with a raised strip (City).  Anyway, two lots of police and some politicians, one suitably armed with an umbrella. Churchill remained Home Secretary only until the autumn of 1911 (Wikipedia says 24th October).  As I remember, he swapped places with the First Lord of the Admiralty.

 

A famous photograph much reproduced in school text books covering that era. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Yes I was getting confused.  It is a long time since I saw a City policeman, I think they are part of the Met now.  Churchill was highly criticised over this, although I am not sure they really had any idea what to do in such cases at the time.

  • Like 4
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Thanks Al, very kind of you.  As always the hobby is  a great way to explore history, big and small events both. 

 

  • Like 8
Link to comment
On 28/09/2022 at 22:46, ChrisN said:

I think they are part of the Met now

 

I'm pretty sure that they're still distinct organisations.

  • Agree 2
  • Informative/Useful 2
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold
2 hours ago, Adam88 said:

 

I'm pretty sure that they're still distinct organisations.

 

Yes, you are right.  I am not sure where I got the idea that they had been amalgamated.

  • Like 1
  • Friendly/supportive 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

Another incredibly researched, observed and beautifully modelled representation of railway history.

Very clever Mikkel, very clever indeed,

  • Agree 3
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment

Much as I enjoy your posts, Mikkel, this one seems to be bumped to the top whenever you make an edit!  The same thing happened to me when I restored some images to an old post and I had to re-set the date back to the original.  Is this the effect of a recent software 'upgrade'?

  • Informative/Useful 2
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold
9 hours ago, MAP66 said:

Another incredibly researched, observed and beautifully modelled representation of railway history.

Very clever Mikkel, very clever indeed,

 

Many thanks Mark. It's the first time all four of the little Farthing layouts were used in the same account. It would be nice to incorporate some more running of trains though, since all the layouts are operational. I suppose video segments is the obvious answer, though I hesitate as it may complicate things unnecessarily. 

 

 

4 hours ago, MikeOxon said:

Much as I enjoy your posts, Mikkel, this one seems to be bumped to the top whenever you make an edit!  The same thing happened to me when I restored some images to an old post and I had to re-set the date back to the original.  Is this the effect of a recent software 'upgrade'?

 

So it does, sorry about that! I've been playing around with "categories" to see if that could be an alternative way of indexing blogs.

 

Yes this is new, before when you edited a blog it did show up in the small blogroll on RMweb's frontpage, but now it also shows up in the main blog list and thereby pushes other newer entries back.  Thanks for alerting me to that.

 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

So good it was worth reading twice! If anyone needs their blog repeating then it’s definitely you Mikkel!🙂

  • Like 1
  • Agree 2
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment

 

On 02/10/2022 at 22:32, ChrisN said:

 

Yes, you are right.  I am not sure where I got the idea that they had been amalgamated.

Probably because their headquarters moved not long after the Millenium.  For over a century they had been based in Old Jewry, a minor street near Bank Underground, but just as the Met are no longer in Great Scotland Yard, they relocated to Bishopsgate.

 

I'm told the Post Office happily delivered letters simply addressed to "Old bill, Old Jewry"

  • Informative/Useful 2
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...