Jump to content
 
  • entries
    137
  • comments
    848
  • views
    116,028

Another dose of the pedants


Chris Nevard

510 views

6303432385_a0be36dfae.jpg

nevard_110101_catcott_IMG_1728_WEB, a photo by nevardmedia on Flickr.

 

 

It's Wycrail this weekend, so Catcott Burtle has been set up for the last week or two sufficiently high off the ground to hopefully avoid the various scenic details being chomped on again by the cat who has a taste for white metal, brass and plastic card.

 

The happy snappy above is of Catcott, the ficticious (maybe more 'faction') scenario depicting a mixed train off the Bridgwater Branch which regularly featured such trains. It's unlikely that an ex-GWR wheeled coach would have been used in this service, but I hope you'll agree it looks the part. The Morris 8 Series E, suitably grottied up adds a little depth to the shot. I'm guessing it's the photographer's car.

 

Another dose of the pedants; the other day I received 'one of those armchair' emails that pops through from time to time with some chap taking great delight in telling me that I've got it all wrong because Catcott never had a halt and sidings. He'd even been on Google Earth to point other bits out that are different to the actual location. Well I know that of course, and because my parallel universe version is so different it's pretty obvious that this is a bit of fiction! This hobby is full of people with little imagination sadly, who only see things as black or white. I do wish they'd spend their time more contructively and actually do some model making rather than stating the obvious and wasting internet bandwidth. I consol myself in that he's probably a traffic warden with aspirations of being a lion tamer - he'll almost certainly have a squeeky voice and definately share a bed with 'mother' despite being 64 years of age.

 

If you're the pedant, because I'm sure you read this blog and because I'm not known to suffer fools too well, here's what Catcott Burtle is all about (again):

 

'Catcott Burtle, a could have been scenario which is heavily influenced by the BBC TV film Branchline Railway, and having been taken in by the wild open feel of the area much dominated by willow, water and big skies. Many roads in the area crossed the railway via manned level crossings rather than bridges, with each crossing having its own crossing keeper and railway cottage. Several of the cottages had no running water or electricity right up to closure in 1966, the water being delivered by rail in milk churns! Catcott, one of the many crossings on the line never was a halt or had sidings. In the parallel universe world here, imagine if to serve the local peat deposits things had been very different?'

  • Find out more about Wycrail here

  • Like 6

25 Comments


Recommended Comments

  • RMweb Gold

It's not all true? My world is collapsing around me, evidently many of the books I've read are something called fiction too . . .

 

The photographers car must be dirty from chasing trains along the rural roads :)

Link to comment

The "armchair pedant" just has not been paying attention!

I remember reading in IIRC RMweb2 (?) of your start on the platform structure with the shaped supports which you had found? / begged? / borrowed? / acquired legitimately?.

It was made plain then that this was a work of "faction". I have followed it's progress with envy of the modelling skill displayed.

Had hoped to get to Wycrail, but have family duties to attend to.

 

Edit.. Let's hope that this pedant does not get to vote / comment on the Challenge Dioramas!

Link to comment
Guest Max Stafford

Posted

Well, the fool's had his comeuppance here all right! ;-)

 

Dave.

Link to comment

Hopefully the weekend won't harbour too many loons - you'll note from my avatar my scary new look. I'll make sure I pack the scary wig as below to keep the adenoidal horrors at bay! Actually the only reason for this blog is because I've had a rather busy week and not had time to do any model making at all - hence Mr Pedant becoming my bog subject for today for want of a better subject.

 

6305859994_155602648c_o.jpg

Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Damn!!!!! I thought it was a real place, but I forgot about the hole in the sky to let the trains in. :-)

To misquote Spike Milligan:

"There are holes in the sky where the trains come in,

they're ever so small, that's why trains are thin" :)

 

Back on topic, it is amazing how some folk 'go off on one' when things aren't exactly as per the real thing, especially when the skills to do this much investigation don't extend to "reading the **** message". I was utterly captivated by Catcott when I saw it at the Taunton RMweb day, I just can't figure the mind set of someone who needs to pick apart something so convincing overall :(

Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

I find your Catcott Burtle image less scary....

 

Perhaps your pedant fan is actually a Lion Tamer...with aspirations of being a Traffic Warden ;)

Link to comment

Hi,

 

I know Chris Nevard as a vampire is scary, I've already told him that he won't get a bacon butty if dresses like that!

 

Make to subject, there are a lot of people that are like that in this hobby. At the Reading show, I heard one person say to my layout "There's so many eras on this, it's ridiculous!" he obviously hadn't read the show guide nor the 2 sheets on the layout that explained that it is a preserved layout! My whole crew had a good laugh at that!

 

Best way is to either laugh at them or ignore them!

 

Simon

Link to comment

Now that is scary!

 

Is this how you will look at Wycrail?

 

Ha! You're sure someone isn't winding you up, Chris? Best, Pete.

It's just as sad whether or not it's a wind up.

Link to comment

I will pack the wig - actually when I used it Saturday night down the local I could clear a path to the bar just like that - fabulous! I'll avoid hair on the palms of the hands though, that might get in the way of the 3 link coupling hook.

Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

Can I borrow that mask you are wearing for next Oct 31st? It will scare the local scrounging kids witless; bah!

P

Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

You should just laugh it off! - I remember at one exhibition with Deadwater Burn two of said type of blokes trying to work out whether the backscene was a commercially available or commissioned one or what? It was more funny actually listening to all their various theories (none correct) than putting them right, tho I would have course if they had asked, told them exactly how it was done!

 

Nowt so queer as folk, as the saying goes!

Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

I'll wager I've gotten myself into at least as much trouble as you, Chris, if not more, with my own published lies!!

  • Like 1
Link to comment

I get fed up simply ignoring them, so thought let's get one back for once! The web is great, but the problem is even the most unworthy have a voice (which is good and bad).

  • Like 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Is there a balance in those who can remember getting on the train at Catcott Burtle?

Don

Link to comment

I sympathise with you here Chris and agree with your sentiments. And isn't it often the case that this type of unbalanced person is often the one with a beautifully detailed loco on their layout next to a tree that is obviously a lolly stick with a scouring pad on the top!

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...