Ho ho, we believe you.
Seriously, I've enjoyed your thread and will look in more often now.
What I like:
Weathering,
Spaciousness, uncluttered.
The depot, although I quite liked the other one too.
Your choice of locos and eras.
Your scratchbuilding and use of other buildings. That footbridge is lovely. I like the PW scene too.
What I thought could be better:
Weathering on the traverser: the base area would be full of muck and certainly NOT white. The rest of it is great though and a definite plus point, interesting. I have been to loas of depots in France that still have them.
The station signs at Marshfield in early photos: their bases are too toy like.
Some of the lights are a bit bright.
The steelworks needs more pipework:http://www.flickr.com/photos/52386003@N04/5173171336/ http://www.flickr.co...N04/5173100044/
http://www.flickr.co...in/photostream/ and don't forget that any long runs have "omega" loops in them for expansion. Also, steelworks are DIRTY!!!!
So not much to DISlike really, just niggles.
Overall a great layout and I will look in again when you update. Keep up the good work.