Hi everyone,
I rated Simon's post showing the RM with a 'like' for one, simple, reason - I believe he was quite right to raise the matter.
Like others, I also think that the writer of the letter is wrong. Most railway modelling is based around some flight of fantasy whether it be lines that never were, rewritten histories of lines that did exist, fake gauges (allowing for Padarn and the Glasgow Underground being close enough in 00). To add some humour, and ingenuity, alongside modelling skill and craftsmanship is a good thing for our hobby. At exhibitions I still meet too many of the 'anorak' brigade who manage to put off so many from the hobby.
I have shown the RM article of Hobbiton to a few friends, none of who are 'younger' or modellers, and they were highly impressed.
I cannot abide by the works of Tolkien nor many of those who followed in his footsteps but long may the layouts continue that follow in his, Pratchet's or others' imaginations.
Regards,
Alex.