Jump to content
 

Episode V: A New Year


Keith Addenbrooke

257 views

Happy New Year!  Well, I hope so.  As we enter 2024, I've been thinking about setting some modelling objectives.  Some find them helpful, whether it is the hard and definite deadline of a committed exhibition or show date, or practical steps to maintain progress on a larger project, or simply aspirational targets to aim at - in order to maintain some degree of modelling focus.  Some might be looking forwards to retirement, and want to structure their time in order to make best use of it, for others finding time in a busy schedule means that identifiable objectives improve the chances of something actually getting done.

 

Some well organised modellers end the modelling year with a review of progress, ready to go again after the holidays: three 2023 updates from layouts I follow on RMweb are @AndyB's Bentley St. Mary - A Southern vignette in N gauge,  @St Enodoc's Mid-Cornwall Lines - 1950s Western Region in OO, and @ian's Die Ercallbahn - Fulfilling a childhood dream.  In my view each deserves a round of applause - not only for making regular progress, but for sharing it with us too.

 

As for me, paddling in the shallow end, I tried breaking down an early attempt at a project micro-layout into smaller steps to aid progress:

 

 

But a bookcase I planned to use for display and storage was repurposed and I lost the space I wanted (the bookcase later went mouldy while in our cellar).  Then a couple of years ago I tried setting myself a project progress target date:

 

Again, I'd not considered the potential loss of space that also saw a premature end to that idea too.

 

What have I learnt?  It seems that setting objectives or targets is not in and by itself enough: my ideas have been too vulnerable to external changes, such as when space is needed for other purposes.  That's particularly relevant for me at the moment because, as previously hinted at in earlier blog posts, our domestic objective for this year is as follows:

 

  • Move House

 

We need a more accessible house due to health issues, and as our home is also my office and workbase, I have to have a suitable working property too.  A possible place has been identified, but it will require us to massively downsize (something we should do anyway).  I will also lose nearly all my modelling and storage space, leading me to another project re-think.

 

I need an approach to modelling for 2024 that does not depend on having any particular space.  At which point I refer back to a video from Dave Meeks' Thunder Mesa Studio I included in the first post of this blog, and the #1 thing he suggests we need to consider before starting a layout project (watch from 20:45 onwards for the relevant section):

 

 

"What kind of story do you want to tell?"
 
As someone with too many interests, and perhaps too few attachments to any one era or genre, I've been finding this really helpful.  As my previous blog testifies (Hot to Not Build a Model Railway) I've had no shortage of ideas or attempts along the way.  Don't get me wrong - I've had loads of fun enjoying the hobby, have learnt far more than I ever thought I would, and have built some stuff - but that larger layout project has remained elusive.
 
Right now I can't plan in much detail, but I can think about the stories I most want to tell.  In some ways it's a development of where my thinking was nearly four years ago, when I was looking at UK GWR OO Branch Lines.  Where am I at now?
 
For some weeks, there has been a grid sitting on my desk in which I set out, scale by scale, what I was interested in:
 
Chart2.png.0f7fc46c1b2ee2e1828fca9207ef55d7.png
 
Looking at it, it's clear I had more North American HO equipment than anything else:
 
Chart1.png.d24ca8d94841a9b10eb41134d09be694.png
 
But there’s a catch - North America is a Continent, and what I had would tell three different stories: from the Alaska Railroad, the Santa Fe Rly and the North East / New England.   It was not one cohesive collection for taking forwards, and was ripe for slimming down anyway.  But even after the clear out I mentioned in the first post of this blog (that reduced the collection to two themes), I still felt somewhat overwhelmed by how much I was left with.  That didn’t help when it came to thinking about moving house:
 
spacer.png
 
Maybe it's not a large collection by the standards of many RMweb users, but for me the amount of space needed to do justice to the impressive size of these locos and freight cars - even if there aren't that many of them in total - meant American HO wasn't ticking the right boxes for me for 2024.  I'd not managed to settle on a track plan I like, partly because the kind of industrial switching layout that would suit my space and interest in structures doesn't quite convince me.  A switching spur doesn’t give me a story I feel committed to.
 
Instead, I've identified three stories I really want to tell - and for me I don't think I'll get the number below that.  I like Short Lines, Branch Lines and Main Lines.  So, how best to tell them?  This is what I'm looking at:
 
1 choice of Scale - HO.  It is a scale I feel comfortable with, and while that also applies to TT, sticking with HO for now gives me all the options:
 
Chart3.png.6c93e99abc7bff586e5fc62b39402d06.png
 
How might this look: for a Short Line common carrier I can combine my interest in Narrow Gauge modelling and North American prototypes by continuing with HOn30, and to this end have started a new project thread in the Narrow Gauge Forum with that in mind: The Carrabassett and Atlantic Lines: US Modelling in HOn30:
 
spacer.png
 
When no-one is looking I can run my H0e on the same track too:
 
10thDecPhoto1.jpg.5b5cced10c9ae730cf61e397e1ab487c.jpg
 
Rather than return to UK OO Modelling for a Branch Line idea at this point, I've been looking at Epoche 1 German outline ideas, taking advantage of the very high quality models available at great prices second-hand:
 
spacer.png
 
While another loco (or two) would be OK, I have the four basic branch line trains:
 
  1. Branch Shuttle (A Wittfeld Accumulator battery electric railcar)
  2. Branch Passenger
  3. Through Passenger
  4. Local Goods

 

Older Fleischmann flanges need me to stick with Code 100 track, so I can also get out my few remaining pieces of legacy UK OO when the cameras are off.  

 

That 'just' leaves the Main Line story - which has been my undoing before (see here and here).  Trouble is, I do rather like full length 26.4m close coupled H0 coaches:

 

5JanPhoto4.jpg.0f71b77796faeb957a9672251bbd7972.jpg

 

But with a four coach train (for example) measuring around 57" am I still being too ambitious, when my Branch Line Train is just over 2' long and an equivalent Narrow Gauge train in the same scale only needs 18" ?

 

5JanPhoto1.jpg.1f6f5900be9da0424bcf33cf7b6c81a0.jpg

 

That's my work in progress.  But I can make a start with some structure kits confident they'll fit the story, even if the size of the page is not yet known.  Of course, this has long been obvious to many, but it may now help me set and reach some objectives, rather than too often re-starting instead.

 

5JanPhoto5.jpg.d5c4f66966e57d70b69d3e69f0ac0975.jpg

 

I expect things will move slowly this year while the house move progress (or if it doesn't).  I don't expect to share another update until February, when hopefully there'll be some modelling to report on at last.  It would be nice if that happened next.  Until then, thanks for reading, Keith.

 

5JanPhoto3.jpg.b75c1110acb19a26a8c827bd0eba53e9.jpg
 

 

Edited by Keith Addenbrooke

  • Like 1
  • Friendly/supportive 4

4 Comments


Recommended Comments

  • RMweb Gold

Keith,

 

Half the problem with any layout scheme is getting started. The other half is keeping going! Life does have a habit of derailing plans which can really put the kybosh on long-term or grand schemes.

 

Perhaps a modular (or sectional) approach might help? For example a selection of fiddle yard, terminus, through station, industry scene on different (small) boards that can be mixed and matched in some way - either to ring the changes or all together on the patio on high days and holidays.

  • Agree 2
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment

Hi Keith.

Thanks for the name check. Although I'd be the first to say that over-planning is simply asking for life to come and bite you in the derriere. 

 

@ian is quite right in saying that the challenges are getting started and then persisting with it.  

 

Ian's idea of a series of modules .ight allow you to work on a small project, complete it, and move on.

 

Obviously space is, and will be, an issue for you. I'm wondering if you've considered using one of the Mens' Sheds in your area? Perhaps sonething could be constructed and maybe even stored there? 

Cheers for now. Andy

 

  • Agree 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Plans have to adapt to changes as the layout progresses, life thows things at you , new ideas come along and,and,and... My current scheme has gone through more changes and iterations than are good for it and many long lived layouts are similarly afflicted.

  • Like 1
  • Informative/Useful 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

Thank you to @ian and @AndyB for your helpful suggestions, as always. After a visit to the first 2024 meeting of our local 009 Society Group this afternoon it was time for the first build of the year: kindly bought for me as a Christmas Gift by one of my daughters in the Family Secret Santa:

 

IMG_0207.jpeg.10bfdf6d45c67af9d8d5f33fcc2e5d28.jpeg

 

IMG_0209.jpeg.6d9b93eccd6f4ee19eb795add5ae7bc6.jpeg

 

I’ve never actually owned one of these folding workbenches before, though I’ve long wanted one.  
 

In terms of other places to model, there are also several active Model Railway Clubs in our Area.  While the 009 Society Group doesn’t have a premises of its own, the Clubs do - which reminds me, I promised to visit one when I got the chance, so must set that up (the other one, which I have been shown round, has Club nights when I’m busy).  I get.a lot from belonging to the 009 Society, so ought to mention Club membership as relevant to this discussion topic, Keith.

 

Edited by Keith Addenbrooke
  • Like 1
  • Friendly/supportive 2
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...