Jump to content
 

Buckjumper

Members
  • Posts

    1,107
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

Blog Comments posted by Buckjumper

  1. Very good! The tree helps disguise the hole in the sky very well. Remember that private sidings were invariably gated; a short run of fencing either side with an (operable) gate that swings back towards the loco shed would add to the ruse.

     

    +1 for the double arch bridge. It works as an excellent view block to the fiddle yard on layouts like Llanastr and

    . (time index 1.38 shows this perfectly).
    • Like 1
  2. Hi Dave

     

    Yes I agree, and wouldn't want to denigrate the brand; WEP kits are lovely things to build - a couple of my most recent ones can be found here and here - but I completely understand that getting that second fold square is potentially an issue.

     

    I've seen some kits for outside framed vans build the framing up with multiple laminates, though that takes a lot of clamping with heat sinks to prevent distortion, and there's an awful lot of filing to make good the edges.

     

    Adrian

  3. Fab.

     

    Jim's kits are lovely to build. He's said on more than one occasion that he prefers to draw the artwork for wagons rather than locos, so I wonder if we should raise a petition for him to produce an outside-framed covered van?

     

    I've got one of those WEP AA16 outside framed TOADs in the 'to do' pile. Interesting comments, as like Connoisseur kits, WEP kits usually to go together very well. So thanks for the tip about square brass tube which I'll bear in mind if it goes all pear-shaped.

     

    The figures are nicely painted too.

  4. Nice plan! Two things spring to mind, one practical, one visual; bearing in mind the overall desirable length you've quoted, and the scale couplings on your models, it's worth ensuring that you are able to reach everywhere you need to as the layout is quite wide compared to its length. Worth also checking clearances in the loop too. Second thing is you might want to consider some kind of view block where the private siding disappears off stage. The curved nature of the backscene/proscenium arch helps enormously, but a small building or a tree will draw the eye of a viewer standing front centre away from the visible hole in the sky.

     

    And yes to installing a trap protecting the main line from the loop and two front sidings.

     

    BTW, you know how long those lovely locos of yours took to build, line and paint? That's how long it'll take to build a weeping willow to the same standard. It'll be worth it though!

  5. Lamps were from Laurie Griffin, as were the early socket type lamp irons. I hope your loco's are going to be the cabless type, i've always loved those!

     

    Thanks - I'll be ordering sets of lamps from Laurie.

     

    Yes, all the Metro (and 633) locos running on the circle had open cabs, so mine will be too. This is the 633 and this is one of the Metros I'll be building for the layout. I need a Large Metro alongside, but there's no decent kit, so I may have to bash another Roxey one to get what I want.

    • Like 1
  6. I do wonder if the timbers are a bit too light

     

    Nope - sleepers and timbers ranged from very dark brown when new and freshly creosoted under pressure, to light silvery grey when old. Old in pre-Grouping terms being 16 - 20 years on running lines, depending on the company, though sidings could have sleepers a lot older. Your best point of reference are telegraph poles which are also pressure-treated and disply a wide range of colours as they age.

     

    What a big difference between these tracks and those in The Bay! Perhaps once the builders have the goods shed up and running the Superintendent of the Line will send a PW train to the station?

  7. By all means keep the loco bright and clean while you need to solder, and a good scrub to remove all grease and acid deposits before painting is necessary, but tarnish doesn't affect the paint keying to the metal, in fact some painters I know allow the metal to tarnish before painting as they believe it keys better!

     

    Good luck with the Ivatt. I believe the College 4MT was the root cause of baldness among several modellers, and that there are several workshop walls with the remains of 4MTs still buried in the plaster, having impacted at great velocity...

     

    Certainly some of the Shedmaster wagon kits were ex-Jidenco, so the well tank could be too.

  8. Mikkel,

     

    Thank you, but I'm a bit of a bodger when it comes to photography. Thank gawd for digital or I'd be well and truly stuffed. All my presentable shots have been taken with a Canon 300D which is now getting on a bit in digital terms, but I do utilise two necessary extras - a Manforotto tripod and a remote switch. I've yet to get a decent shot with artificial light, even bright daylight bulbs and that worries me when it comes to taking future shots of Basilica Fields. I guess I'll be digging deep for some decent floods.

     

    Back to liveries; you've made some interesting points.

     

    There were a range of photographic emulsions on offer at the time, and yes, they were red blind, but - and it's a big but - not all exhibited the same properties. Going back to matters Great Eastern as I can at least speak with some authority without putting my foot in it, it is almost impossible to see the vermilion lining on +99% of all images which isn't too much of a problem on the ultramarine livery as one can see the blue and black border, but in the past it has caused much consternation with those locos painted black. Both Adams and Bromley's black locos had red lining, and after 1890 all goods engines were painted black.

     

    An unofficial painting procedure has been handed down by the photographer and ex-GER employee Ken Nunn, and because of that one document it was long assumed that all black goods engines from 1890 were lined red in the same style as the blue passenger locos, but this lining couldn't be seen on the emulsions of the period. Only relatively recently have we come to understand, from other contemporary sources, that the GER infact pulled a fast one and lined only the lowliest of four-coupled shunters, and all other goods and shunting engines were plain black and unlined.

     

    Here's an example of the difficulties encountered. This class of downright ugly ducklings was the first mogul (2-6-0) not only on the GE, but in the UK, and was painted black, lined red, and the cab side number plates were vermilion. See how difficult it is?

     

    Back to Slinn's comments about black lettering; I simply don't know enough about the GW, or have the resources to hand to make too many bold statements. I believe a study was conducted to see if the eye can differentiate between red and black on these old emulsions, and the consensus was a resounding 'No', but I don't know if it was particularly scientific in its execution, and I think there is a lot to be said for gut feeling.

     

    No. 59972 appears *to me* to have red characters, and both the running number and small GWR appear to be darker. I agree, this may well be down to the photographer touching up the lettering - ye olde photoshoppe! I hadn't made a connection with this practice possibly giving rise to the theory of black lettering, but that seems like a distinct possibility to me.

     

    Thanks for your considered thoughts - they are precisely what I had hoped for.

    • Like 1
  9. I've no idea about the livery. I've have one of these built in 2mm and know it needs to be filthy, but I haven't the heart to do it after adding all the lettering. The model you have created looks really nice. It seems to show that I have missed the steps off under the doors too.

     

    And it's an awful lot of lettering! I don't envy you doing it in 2mm either - even in 7mm it had its moments.

  10. Stovepipes; the best looking of all chimneys...well, to my eyes, at least! But then the LSW and GE shared many aspects thanks to Adams' ties with Stratford's design office, even after he had taken the job at Nine Elms.

     

    Handsome little model. I've got a handful of photos of 735, but none of the rear to check those lamp irons for you. There were a number of differences between having the LSW livery applied for the first time and being taken over by the Southern, and I can't see anything you've missed.

     

    Are you sure it's got to be Southern and not the lovely LSW livery?

  11. So now you have no excuse for not fitting Vacuum Brakes to your AA7 'cos I have some info as to how it might have been done.

     

    The key is when did it happen for the AA7s? A photograph of Acton yard c1911 (assuming the date is correct) with several AA7s in residence shows two with their ends to the camera. One definitely has a vacuum standard, but it appears the other one doesn't. If the photograph isn't lying, and the assumed date is correct, then perhaps the end of the Edwardian period is when conversion took place...in which case perhaps the Basilica AA7s should remain unfitted. More data please mister!

     

    In discussion with John Lewis we came to a conclusion that the converted Toads might have been for use on services from West Wales.

     

    Which would have been what...from about c1889 onwards using the X3 Micas?

×
×
  • Create New...