Jump to content
 

Broad Gauge Covered Van


MikeOxon

889 views

Because of various distractions, I’ve not had much time for model-building recently. I have however been spending quite a lot of time thinking about those very early days of the GWR when those first engines, which I modelled last year, were being delivered. Some of these engines were delivered by canal to West Drayton, where it seems that the first depot of the GWR was established. At that time, the way ahead was far from certain and concerns about the desirability of adopting Brunel’s proposals for the ‘broad gauge’. were still being hotly debated.

429801503_WestDraytonStation800x600.jpg.d9a876d8e4a921e221e68b082d4ffc2b.jpg

Illustration from Measom’s Guide to the GWR 1851

 

Whereas we have quite a lot of information about the early locomotives, the other vehicles – carriages and wagons – have received much less attention but, fortunately, the late Eddy Brown of the Broad Gauge Society (BGS) collected a lot of information about these, which was produced as a series of Data Sheets, available to BGS members. I have already made models of several vehicles, which I based on the information from these Data Sheets but I also became aware that there are gaps that were either omitted altogether or received scant attention in these documents.

 

For example, when I built my ‘Coal Wagon for Bullo Pill’, I couldn’t find anything about 12-ton coal wagons in the BGS Data Sheets. Fortunately, however, I found an article in the BGS Journal ‘Broadsheet’ No.9 (April 1983), which described such a wagon and included a sketch. That same article included the comment that “The basic coal wagon shown featured many detail differences such as door types, number of doors, number of planks etc. In one case the addition of roof and sliding door produced a lime truck.”. That set me thinking about other variants and recently I discovered a list of OPC/BR drawings in ‘Broadsheet’ No.8 (Jan.1983). These drawings cover the short period from 1852 to 1854/5 and include a group of wagons sharing a standard design of underframe with various types of body. One that caught my attention is described as “Covered Goods Wagon, Henson's Patent Slide: Sliding side doors, patent sliding roof door, no breaks shewn. Body of wood with outside framing of wood and iron to accommodate sliding doors. Body side planking extending beyond the corner posts.

 

Covered vans seem to have been rare in early BG days, since most goods (and third-class passengers) were carried in open wagons, often fitted with hoops to carry a canvas tilt cover. I was intrigued by the reference to ‘Henson’s Patent Slide’. Henson is better known in connection with the LNWR and, according to the ‘Steam index’: “In 1841 Henry Henson was a civil engineer in charge of the Camden workshops of the London and Birmingham Railway. When the L&BR became part of the L&NWR Henson continued to hold that position and in 1847 he was appointed head of the wagon department of the Southern Division.”  Possibly, members of this community with more expertise about LNWR matters may be able to shed more light on the nature of Henson’s Patent.

 

1384977118_HensonFig3.jpg.5b090e4718df7fe00e4795a18f4078b5.jpg
Henson’s Covered Wagon – Proc.Inst.Mech.Eng.,1851

 

I also realised that, just as in the case of the coal wagon I modelled, this van was the subject of dimensioned drawings in Alan Prior’s book ‘19th Century Railway Drawings’. Thus, I had the basis for constructing a model by following my usual method of copying over a printed drawing using ‘Fusion 360’ software. To re-cap, I imported the drawing as a ‘canvas’ into ‘Fusion 360’ and then drew a series of rectangles to represent the outlines of various body features.


2011304074_BGCoveredVan360-1a.jpg.c7e7ace495120925c9eb1d60af23fb03.jpg

Next, I extruded the areas enclosed between the rectangles by appropriate distances, to create solid bodies of the depths needed to represent framing components, as shown below:

 

1636144248_BGCoveredVan360-2.jpg.41aab983d8d52c03bbf7b93c5e3d730d.jpg

 

For the roof, I extruded the arc cross-section from one end and then added braces underneath to maintain the shape. I also added surface details to represent the roof hatches.

 

763026248_BGCoveredVan360-5.jpg.fb39f50e01817cbc8719d59edbd38333.jpg

I use the ‘pattern on path’ commands in ‘Fusion 360’ to create regular structures, such as the cross braces and the planked sides of the van, automatically.

 

The underframe was of the same design and wheelbase as that I made before, for my model coal wagon, so I only needed to increase the length of my existing model to match the new body.

 

275969274_BGCoveredVan360-4.jpg.c346097a2fea5ebcf61f17647531a841.jpg

 

So, that’s the hard part done and the next thing is to transfer the design files to the ‘Cura’ slicing software, which prepares the ‘gcode’ files for my Geeetech E180 printer. I printed the various components in four separate print jobs. For the record, the printing times were:

 

  • Roof 70 mins.
  • Sides X2 73 mins
  • Ends X2 31 mins
  • Chassis 65 mins

 

As I have mentioned before, I prefer to break the printing into several parts, so that I can check each part separately for any problems, without having to wait for the entire job to be completed.

 

809580859_printedcomponents.jpg.2bb4ef8ba8b177d685840af6ef250913.jpg

3D-printed Components

 

I was very pleased to find that the roof printed well, despite having no ‘honeycomb’ helpers to support the hollow underside. My basic FDP printer successfully bridged the 10mm gaps between the cross bracing, saving both time and material.

 

1848151197_printedvanroof.jpg.ca7f7c579f24ac285554464e3a9db761.jpg
3D-printed Van Roof

 

All that remained was to fuse the components together by running a 200°C soldering tip along the seams between the parts:

 

2043726434_3D_CoveredVan-2.jpg.a220d559dc0f451039c3421382b5e798.jpg
3D-prnted Covered Van – assembled

 

As usual with my models, there are various details to be added but I feel it has captured the appearance of an unusual prototype from the early 1850s.

 

Mike

  • Like 8
  • Informative/Useful 1
  • Craftsmanship/clever 6

7 Comments


Recommended Comments

  • RMweb Premium

Definitely an interesting model Mike.  I have Alan Prior's book and I've often looked at that van and wondered about it.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
42 minutes ago, Annie said:

I have Alan Prior's book and I've often looked at that van and wondered about it.

I thought the same, so was pleased to identify it through the OPC collection. Looking at photos of the Swindon dump there were lots of variations that probably remain undocumented.

  • Agree 1
  • Interesting/Thought-provoking 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

Yes apart from the odd lucky photo of a locomotive where a goods wagon sneaked into the shot as well it's pretty much the Swindon dump photos that are the only record of some wagon types.  The late Eddy Brown's data sheets certainly help to fill in some of the gaps, but even then it still comes down to having to take a guess at what the actual details were like on some goods wagon types.

  • Like 1
Link to comment

I've had to resort to 3D printing on commision some roofs - I appreciate the complexities of the process a little better, but you can't argue the results aren't satisfying. I know you've said you have a fairly entry level printer before, do you have any more details?

Link to comment
3 hours ago, Lacathedrale said:

I know you've said you have a fairly entry level printer before, do you have any more details?

My printer is a Geeetech E180 FDM mini-printer that cost just under £200 when I bought it in Dec.2018. I bought it simply to explore what I could do with a new modelling method and struggled at first with the 'learning curve'. It's taken me to places I never expected to go!  A lot of my early progress (?) is documented in my other blog.

 

Regarding roofs>  This one is tending to curve up a bit at the ends.  Perhaps I should add a longeron or two underneath.

Edited by MikeOxon
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

Henson's patent covered goods wagon was discussed recently on my wagon-building topic in the context of early midland covered wagons:

 

Interesting to see the Great Western getting in on the act. 

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
41 minutes ago, Compound2632 said:

Henson's patent covered goods wagon was discussed recently on my wagon-building topic in the context of early midland covered wagons:

I frequently look in your wagon thread but somehow missed that post! 

 

How curious that we should have been considering the same thing at almost the same time.  Your descriptions are very helpful, although I'm still not sure how the sliding parts worked on the GWR version.  Did the roof hatch slide sideways coupled to the sliding door?  I was expecting to see some evidence of runners on the roof but there is nothing obvious on the drawings I have seen.  On the broad gauge, it becomes a surprisingly large vehicle.

 

Mike

  • Like 1
  • Interesting/Thought-provoking 2
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...