A Missing Link?
In my last few posts, I’ve been delving into the almost lost world of the early days of the GWR broad gauge. I notice that my previous post aroused little comment so, perhaps, I have moved rather too far from what most people think of as ‘railway modelling’ - but I do like using models as a way of improving our understanding of these early engines. I do appreciate the various 'likes' that many of you have given me.
Before I move back into more familiar territory, there is one more piece of history to record, regarding an engine that may not have existed at all – at least not in the form in which it was described.
Francis Whishaw on the GWR
One of the earliest books to survey the British railway scene was Francis Whishaw’s “The Railways of Great Britain and Ireland” of which the 2nd edition, with additional plates, was published 1842.
He wrote “THE Great Western Railway is by far the most gigantic work of the kind, not only in Great Britain, not only in Europe, but, we venture to say, in the whole world. Mr. Brunel, not satisfied with the beaten track pursued by those who had gone before him, determined on carrying out this important work on entirely new principles; and, notwithstanding the numerous adversaries he has had to contend with from every quarter, has thus far been eminently successful in his favourite project, and will, no doubt, ere another summer shall have passed away, pronounce this mighty work to be completed throughout.”
I should add, though, that Whishaw did go on to criticise the great increase in the costs incurred, over the original Parliamentary estimate … something with which we are all too familiar!
Concerning locomotives, Whishaw left us with a puzzle, when he wrote :“we have ... classified these machines according to their magnitude, and the gauge of way to which they severally belong. Thus the six-wheel engines for the seven-feet gauge, as those on the Great Western Railway, belong to class A ; ...An engine belonging to class A is shewn in elevation in Plate 1, the frontispiece. and sections and details of an engine belonging to this class are exhibited in Plates 7, 8, and 9.”
Whereas Plate 1 shows a locomotive of the ‘Firefly’ class, the engine shown in Plates 7, 8, and 9 does not correspond to any engine known to have worked on the GWR!:
Whishaw Plate 7
Whishaw Plate 8
Whishaw does not specifically state that this is a GWR engine, although that assumption has been made by many later writers and is reasonable, considering that no other British railway used a 7 foot gauge.. The image has also sometimes been referred to as being a member of the ‘Firefly’ class, which it superficially resembles, at first glance.
I have also noticed that there are many similarities between these drawings and the example of Stephenson’s ‘Patentee’ engine, illustrated in Tredgold’s ‘The Steam Engine, Vol II’, Plate LXXXXIX (99), published 1838. To demonstrate this, I overlaid the two drawings to the same scale, as shown below:
Comparison between Whishaw’s Plate 7 and Stephenson’s ‘Patentee’
Creating a 3D Model
I decided to create a 3D model based on Whishaw Plates 7 and 8, shown above. As usual, I imported the two images as ‘canvases’ into ‘Fusion 360’. I used the various sketching tools in this software to create drawings, which I could then extrude to create the main components of the engine. I also copied details of the frames and axle guides from the drawing of the ‘Patentee’ engine in Tredgold’s book..
.jpg.6e88b63b7fec84384a55136203ff80d4.jpg)
Examples of Components extruded from Whishaw plates
Once I had extruded all the necessary components, including use of the ‘revolve tool’ for the chimney, safety valve, and manhole cover, I assembled them together, within the Fusion 360 software, and created a ‘rendered’ 3D image:
My 3D model created from Plates in Whishaw.
Comparing Models
When viewing the images of the Whishaw engine in isolation, it is not difficult to conclude that this image has similarities with the GWR ‘Firefly’ class. That idea is quickly disposed of, however, when I bring together the above model with the model of ‘Argus’, a member of the Firefly-class that I created in 2021.. Note that both these models were created to the scales indicated on the original drawings.
My 3D models of the Whishaw engine and Firefly-class ‘Argus’ brought together
Once the two models are placed together, the profound differences between their overall dimensions is immediately apparent! Notice too, the much lighter frames and smaller driving wheels of Whishaw’s engine.
Similar Engines
There was a Stephenson 2-2-2 of the ‘Patentee’ type, named ‘Harvey Combe’, which was built n 1835 and was used by Messrs. Cubitt, the contractors, during construction of the London and Birmingham Railway near Berkhampstead. The scene was captured by the artist J.C.Bourne, as shown above in my header image:
According to an article in ‘The Engineer’ by J.G.H. Warren, dated 24th Sep.,1926, Nicholas Wood, in a “Report to the Directors of the Great Western Railway,” December 10th, 1838, gave results of experiments on the ‘Harvey Combe’ of the London and Birmingham Railway, to compare with contemporary experiments with the North Star of the Great Western Railway.
I have not read Wood’s report in full but it suggests the possibility, at least, that similar engines might have been used by contractors engaged in construction of the GWR. It does seem to me that an engine similar to that shown in Whishaw would have been far more suitable for that task than the large-wheeled engines specified by Brunel, as the initial engines for the GWR.
Perhaps, then, the engine shown in Whishaw’s book represents a ‘missing link’ between the engines built by Stephenson for the London and Birmingham railway and an engine or engines used during the construction of the broad gauge GWR?
Mike
Edited by MikeOxon
-
11
-
1
-
4
16 Comments
Recommended Comments
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now