Jump to content
 

Pearson 4-2-4T – Part Two


MikeOxon

543 views

In Part One , I wrote that “this engine had several very unusual features” and, in regard to building a model, “I had to start somewhere and, with so many peculiarities, it was hard to choose. As a ‘gentle introduction’, I decided to start with the two bogies.”

 

I intend to continue, as far as possible, to follow a line of ‘least resistance’ but before going any further, I collected as much potentially useful information , photos, and drawings as I could.

BER_Pearson9ft-Dwgs600x800.jpg.37ef07964c0cef5eb071a238bec2bb24.jpg

 

In his book ‘The British Steam Locomotive 1825 – 1925’ p.106, Ahrons noted that “no description of them, beyond the meagre details in Colburn's " Locomotive Engineering," page 73, has ever been given, and the following account of their constructional details may therefore be of interest.”

 

 

He continued with quite an extensive article, providing many key dimensions and descriptions of the rubber suspension system. This suspension anticipated Alex Moulton’s work for the Austin Mini by more than a century! Ahron’s also referenced an article in ‘The Engineer’ supplement, 16 Dec 1910 , which provided various sectional views of the engine from which I could make a start.

 

 

Using these drawings, I started by creating some of those major components for which I had already gained experience in modelling other engines.

 

Ahrons gave the boiler dimensions as 10ft. 9in. long by 4ft. 0½ in. inside diameter, so I created a tube of length 43 mm, inside dia. 16 mm, with 1 mm wall thickness, which provided a good match to an ‘The Engineer’ drawing. I then added firebox and smokebox by tracing over the drawing and extruding as required, to create solid ‘bodies’ in ‘Fusion 360’. The results were as shown below:

 

3D4-2-4model-0.jpg.0866a0ecbc6fa4e3e9174e6a256f0b9d.jpg

3D model of Boiler Assy. Referenced from an illustration in ‘The Engineer’.

 

The next ‘familiar’ item on the agenda was a pair of driving wheels. although these are a little larger than usual, at 36 mm diameter, and flangeless. The stages of my usual method are shown below:

 

StepstoDrivingWheel.jpg.7a73b132e112019d122b2222d91930ec.jpg

My steps in 3D modelling the Driving Wheels

 

It always surprises me how rapidly something resembling an engine emerges, especially once the platform, chimney and safety valve housing have been added.  The chimney and safety valve cover were created by my usual method of tracing the profile and then using the ‘Revolve’ tool to create the cylindrical ‘bodies’.

 

The platform was a simple rectangular extrusion from the plan drawing, with the exception that small ‘humps’ had to be raised over each of the bogie wheels. Those early designers did nothing to make life easier for the workmen having to fabricate these shapes by hand!

 

3D4-2-4model-3c.jpg.abaccf7f9d3ba3bc46cde4b734ac084c.jpg
First impression of my evolving model

 

That has completed most of the straightforward parts of this engine and it is now time to start tackling its (many) peculiarities!

 

Outside ‘Frame’

 

According to Ahrons “The inside bearings were only 5in. long, and therefore additional outside bearings, 9in. long, were provided, the hornblocks of which were riveted to the triangular queen truss " frame," shown outside the driving wheel”.

 

This ‘frame’ was my next subject for modelling. I created the truss and the outside rim of the splasher as a single ‘body’ in ‘Fusion 360’ by extruding from a drawing, as shown below:

 

OutsideFrame1.jpg.5b3977f1770ade4e921b34e4833255d9.jpg

My sketch of the outside frame supporting the driving axle

 

Most of the sketch was made by using the ‘three point arc’ tool in ‘Fusion 360’ and then I extruded the area coloured blue to form the frame. Next, I extruded the rectangle representing the axlebox, to house the outside bearing. I used another useful tool – the ‘offset’ tool – to create an outer rim around the frame and then ‘pushed’ the annulus (coloured yellow) backwards, to surround the driving wheel as the splasher.

 

Yoke and Boiler Support Plates

 

Now it was time to address two more peculiarities – the yoke across the top of the boiler and the curvaceous plates that supported the boiler from the platform. I created both these features by sketching over one of the front-elevation illustrations from ‘The Engineer’.   Again, the most useful sketching tool was the ‘three point arc’ and I then extruded the outlined area to form plates of 0.5 mm thickness, as shown below:

 

There were two identical ‘yoke’ plates in tandem (blue in my sketch) straddling the top of the boiler, with pivoted brackets between them, to carry the vertical suspension rods above the riving wheels.  Two curved support plates (green) were placed, one on either side of the boiler, immediately ahead of the driving wheel splashers.

 

Boilerbrackets.jpg.c62741bb844bf6539050924d7140e122.jpg

Tracing the shapes of the Curved Plates around the Boiler

 

I then move and rotate the parts I have made and align them against my reference 'canvas'.  I have hidden the rest of the model for clarity:

 

Brackets.jpg.c88ba9e2aa913a5aa2f6a0467fa928c1.jpg

 

After producing models of these plates, I moved on to the suspension units for the driving axle. These were illustrated and described by Ahrons.  I created my models of the suspension units by sketching the profile over the drawing from ‘The Engineer’ and then using the ‘Revolve’ tool in ‘Fusion 360’ to create the cylindrical rods and the brass pots that contain the india rubber ‘springs, as shown below:

 

 

SuspensionUnits_Ahrons2.jpg.e27160b1c2921ddc4bf3c37f553fbca8.jpg

My extrusion of a suspension arm alongside ‘The Engineer’ Drawing

 

Motion Plate

 

The motion plate was, again, unusual in that its outer edges were shaped to follow similar curves to those of the boiler support plates. For details of their appearance, I had to turn to another drawing, shown in the Broad Gauge Society (BGS) journal ‘Broadsheet’ No.49 (Spring 2003).

 

The original is one of those ‘split’ drawings, with halves of two different cross sections shown together. To help my visualisation of the engine, I 'mirrored' each half to provide two separate complete cross sections, although I cannot guarantee that all the details on the two sides were perfectly matched.

 

BER_Pearsoncross-sect2800x600.jpg.b8679b2add1ea54dc64300b3a9c9a41e.jpg
Two cross-sections created from drawings in BGS ‘Broadsheet’ No.49

 

In my drawing ‘B’, I have shaded the split motion plate, which has square apertures for the connecting rods to pass through. I copied the outlines of these motion plates, as for the other boiler support plates, and extruded them to 0.5 mm thickness.  The valves were placed between the cylinders and the valve rods are shown with supporting slide bars. There are many other unusual features in these drawings that I shall return to later, including the well tank suspended below the boiler on brackets from the motion plate.

 

Cylinders

 

The cylinders themselves were too long to fit within the very short smokebox, so they extended for about 1 foot forwards of the smokebox. They were connected across the width of the engine by a box, which enclosed most of the front end of the valve gear, although there were two tail rods protruding from the front face of this box. A photograph of the front end of No.42 also shows a small steam cock on the centre of his cover

 

I constructed this box and the cylinder ends as a separate ‘body’, which I then fixed to the front of the smokebox.

 

Cylindercovers.jpg.4e14dd1a584dec578a47ed0376e616cb.jpg
My model of the cylinder ‘front end’

 

That has completed all the main components needed for a ‘top-side’ view of the engine. I have added buffer beams, copied from a different Broad Gauge engine, and extruded the outer sides of the coke bunker. Although simple in external appearance, this bunker has many unusual internal features but I shall come to these later.

 

In the meantime, my 3D model in ‘Fusion 360’ now looks as shown below:

 

3D4-2-4render7.jpg.d690496466fb0949f9fb5e31df1cc04e.jpg

 

I think this model is beginning to capture something of the ‘presence’ that the original engines must had. I still have a lot of work to do on the underpinnings – especially the attachment points for the bogies and the well tanks but right now I feel it’s time to pause for the Easter break!

 

Mike

 

 

Edited by MikeOxon
amend drawing

  • Like 13
  • Craftsmanship/clever 5
  • Round of applause 2

14 Comments


Recommended Comments

I am so happy whenever I see a notification to this blog. You really should consider publishing this all - I would definitely buy one in a bound up copy! I continue to be amazed at what you've produced.

 

Regarding your sketch of the boiler plate and yoke - are you able to expand a little on how you sort the alignment out in the axis that's not visible in the sketch? i.e. you are sketching a front profile and this is likely to end up at the very front or rear of your engine, based on where the model origin is. Do you do an offset extrusion? an 'Align' ? Do you create an offset plane?

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
MikeOxon

Posted (edited)

1 hour ago, Lacathedrale said:

Regarding your sketch of the boiler plate and yoke - are you able to expand a little on how you sort the alignment out in the axis that's not visible in the sketch? i.e. you are sketching a front profile and this is likely to end up at the very front or rear of your engine, based on where the model origin is. Do you do an offset extrusion? an 'Align' ? Do you create an offset plane?

I simply move and rotate the parts I have made and align them against my reference 'canvas'.  I have hidden the rest of the model for clarity [NB  I've added this clarification to the main text]:

 

Brackets.jpg.85edec50b40589b982d76a992bacc80e.jpg

 

I rarely do any measurements or create offset planes unless I have to 🙂

 

 

Edited by MikeOxon
  • Like 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Again very interesting.  I wonder how many other models actually replicate how the prototype was built?

  • Agree 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

I too am finding this fascinating. Effectively a structural boiler. The heat losses must have been significant with all those yokes rivetted on. 

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
29 minutes ago, ChrisN said:

I wonder how many other models actually replicate how the prototype was built?

Thank you Chris - that's exactly what I am trying to do.  I've started looking at the underside and it seems to have been an extraordinary assemblage of brackets with no proper frames at all.

 

2 minutes ago, Dave John said:

I too am finding this fascinating. Effectively a structural boiler. The heat losses must have been significant with all those yokes rivetted on. 

Quite a few early engines had 'structural' boilers.  The 'Firefly' replica at Didcot had to include additional framing, to meet current regulations

  • Like 1
  • Informative/Useful 1
  • Interesting/Thought-provoking 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
Quote

This suspension anticipated Alex Moulton’s work for the Austin Mini by more than a century! 

That really made me smile Mike.  Plainly the rubber suspension must've worked, but how well and what maintenance issues there were with it would have well and truly lost to the mists of the past by now I suppose.

At least there is the sectional drawing in The Engineer as a reference as without that much of these amazing engines construction would be a complete mystery.

 

Quote

I think this model is beginning to capture something of the ‘presence’ that the original engines must had.

 

It's most certainly doing that, - excellent work Mike and I'm looking forward to further developments.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Very informative, Mike. I find these early engines quite instructive, because they show off more clearly the fundamentals of a locomotive.

 

And I like those external suspension arms, very stylish actually - especially in your rendering. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Mike, having read your latest, and referred back to my “primitive “ efforts of 4 years ago, I can plainly see why your approach of “Research first” speeds up modelling with accuracy!
My model was based almost entirely on the side elevation in Mike Sharman’s book.  Your cross section drawings have clearly demonstrated the deficiencies in this method!
 

So, back to the CAD.  Fortunately I keep stl files of all components, but it’s still a lot of interesting work - already started, at the expense of my Rover & Alma project!

  • Like 1
Link to comment
18 minutes ago, brunelfan said:

 Your cross section drawings have clearly demonstrated the deficiencies in this method!

I agree, it is very hard to produce anything other than an 'outline' from those drawings.  Beware, I have also found several inaccuracies in those drawings, many of which emanate from 'The Locomotive Magazine'.

 

I also find it difficult to interpret more detailed drawings, mainly in trying to work out how various parts were orientated in three dimensions.  The underside is proving particularly difficult.

  • Friendly/supportive 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

Theres two aspects strike me, first off the bogies are mounted in ball and socket joints, with no allowance for any sideways movement. This means any sideways displacement on a curve has to be met by the driving wheels, and any movement there looks to be blocked by the suspension arrangement. Hence the need for flangeless drivers, but the tyres don’t look especially wide. It must have been very tricky to run over any restricted point work.

Then there’s the rubber suspension, which looks as if it’s applied to the bogie wheels as well. Getting the weight distribution set up is bad enough on an ordinary engine with leaf springs and adjustable nuts on the spring hangers, quite how it was done on this one would be a challenge, to put it mildly.

  • Thanks 1
  • Interesting/Thought-provoking 1
Link to comment
52 minutes ago, Northroader said:

the tyres don’t look especially wide.

On he drawing of the suspension from 'The Engineer', the tyre width is marked as 6" (15.24 cm)

  • Informative/Useful 3
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

Not quite a steam roller wheel, but there’s a bit of meat.

  • Like 2
  • Agree 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

One wonders what was the basis for the 1910 The Engineer drawings. E.L. Ahrons had been a Swindon apprentice in the 1880s, so may well have had access to first-hand information about these engines.

  • Interesting/Thought-provoking 2
Link to comment
22 hours ago, Compound2632 said:

One wonders what was the basis for the 1910 The Engineer drawings. E.L. Ahrons had been a Swindon apprentice in the 1880s, so may well have had access to first-hand information about these engines.

The history of these engines has received extensive coverage in various issues of the BGS journal 'Broadsheet'.  My fellow BGS member, Douglas S Johnson, built a model the hard way, using brass and nickel silver, and wrote a full description over two issues of the 'Broadsheet' in 2020. 

 

Concerning drawings, he wrote: "There is some dispute over the validity of some of the ‘original’ drawings - see ‘Nemesis’ in [Broadsheet] 54.30. This is understandable, as some ‘as-built’ drawings were issued by Swindon for the centenary exhibition, while others are B&ER drawings dated August 1852 — April 1857, together seeming to be the basis for the drawings printed in ‘The Engineer“ of December 1910. There may be no good reason to doubt the accuracy of these drawings, despite their various dates and provenance, as being a near true representation of how the locomotives first ran, or were intended to run.The photographs show some things otherwise. as should be expected given the rapid pace of development in that period."

 

Douglas generously showed me copies of several of the early drawings, which were a great help to me in understanding some of the details of these engines.

 

Mike

  • Like 3
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...