Jump to content
 

York station in the 1950's.


kirtleypete
 Share

Recommended Posts

  • Moderators
4 minutes ago, kirtleypete said:

Unfortunately I won't be delivering the terraces tomorrow as my customer has tested positive for Covid. We'll have to rearrange everything once he's had the all clear. 

 

Obviously we've postponed the photoshoot too but still looking forward to seeing it in the flesh. Here's to a speedy recovery.

  • Like 1
  • Agree 3
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...
1 hour ago, lmsforever said:

Oh boy that shot looking through the station wow it looks like the real thing this is a fantastic layout and you all should be congratulated  on the brilliant modeling .Thanks for sharing this.

Yes, absolutely magnificent.  There are a couple of other extemely impressive models of major stations, but I don't think I've seen one to match this for craftsmanship.

 

Unfortunately I suspect the details seen in those views are probably not even apparent to anybody who has the privilege of visiting this layout - you would have to put your head down close to track level (as the camera must have been) to appreciate the work that has gone into the train shed supports etc as the roof conceals many significant details like the footbridge between the platforms. 

 

A visitor would see the station rather more like the view seen by a tourist standing on the City walls - admiring the exterior of the buildings.  Maybe the layout would benefit from a couple of small CCTV cameras fitted inside the overall roof to power screens displaying the comings and goings of trains?

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

That's the big problem with overall roofs Michael; you really only see the outside. One thing we certainly intend to do in due course is fit a video camera to a chassis and propel it through the station as though it is being viewed from a train. BRM might well do that when they visit, saving us the trouble!

 

Peter

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

40 minutes ago, Michael Hodgson said:

Yes, absolutely magnificent.  There are a couple of other extemely impressive models of major stations, but I don't think I've seen one to match this for craftsmanship.

 

Unfortunately I suspect the details seen in those views are probably not even apparent to anybody who has the privilege of visiting this layout - you would have to put your head down close to track level (as the camera must have been) to appreciate the work that has gone into the train shed supports etc as the roof conceals many significant details like the footbridge between the platforms. 

 

A visitor would see the station rather more like the view seen by a tourist standing on the City walls - admiring the exterior of the buildings.  Maybe the layout would benefit from a couple of small CCTV cameras fitted inside the overall roof to power screens displaying the comings and goings of trains?


Thats what I am planning with my layout Briganton - as I didnt have the space for the mainlines past Darlington so its based on a station that is very similar to the real thing. The build of this work for York is truely stunning. If I can help with advice for cameras then Id be happy to. 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Premium

A truly superb model that really captures York station as it once was.  I assume that the layout depicts the layout as it was after the 1951 remodelling - will the colour light signals be modelled too?

 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

They will but thankfully not by me! My customer actually enjoys things like that but it will be one of the last jobs that gets done as they will be vulnerable to being damaged while we're still working on it. 

 

David, thanks for the offer about the camera, I'll pass it on.

 

Peter

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, kirtleypete said:

That's the big problem with overall roofs Michael; you really only see the outside. One thing we certainly intend to do in due course is fit a video camera to a chassis and propel it through the station as though it is being viewed from a train. BRM might well do that when they visit, saving us the trouble!

 

Peter

 

I do have a (nearly) completed NER Inspection Saloon, with on-board video camera.

I've been wasting time recently but am working on a 2-2-4 tank engine to propel it!

 

(You can see something of it here - on my much neglected thread Do PM me if it would be of interest.)

  • Like 3
Link to post
Share on other sites

A general question, certainly not specific to this incredible model. I know cars and other vehicles were significantly smaller back in the day, but on any accurately scaled model, which I am sure this is, they look disproportionately tiny (and the roadways, by comparison, disproportionately large. Same applies to the vast empty spaces of goods yards when modelled to scale). The forecourt of 'Great Northern's Peterborough North layout exhibits the same phenomenon. I imagine this is something to do with our perspectives when we are live at street level, as opposed to taking the 'helicopter view' of a model.

 

But my questions are, firstly, is this just me? And if it isn't, do any modellers feel tempted to 'adjust' the scaling (presumably of the roads since I assume most of the vehicles on anyone's layout are bought-in) to make an optical correction (sort of the reverse of some of the forced perspective techniques used for backgrounds? And if so, any recommendations on how and how far to go about this, given any adjustment is likely to b*gg*r the geometry?

 

Incidentally, my wife is quite overcome by the modelling - my daughter lived in York until quite recently and we used to get to her over the footpath on the Scarborough bridge. Mrs L amazed to recognise so many buildings, but then says 'he hasn't got the bridge quite right, has he'. I've had to gently inform her that the bridge has been somewhat altered in the past half-century! But that a non-enthusiast can get so engaged in the modelling is a pretty good tribute to what you and your client are achieving.

 

Oh, she had one other comment - she didn't see how the 'Time Team' excavation fitted into that part of the Royal Station Hotel gardens you have modelled (of course, you have shrunk the hotel a tad, I think). But again, a lot of engagement from a non-specialist.

 

And since we've now all moved away from York, you are keeping our memories alive - even if ours are more 2015 than 1955!

  • Like 1
  • Interesting/Thought-provoking 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

On 05/07/2022 at 17:10, lanchester said:

A general question, certainly not specific to this incredible model. I know cars and other vehicles were significantly smaller back in the day, but on any accurately scaled model, which I am sure this is, they look disproportionately tiny (and the roadways, by comparison, disproportionately large. Same applies to the vast empty spaces of goods yards when modelled to scale). The forecourt of 'Great Northern's Peterborough North layout exhibits the same phenomenon. I imagine this is something to do with our perspectives when we are live at street level, as opposed to taking the 'helicopter view' of a model.

 

But my questions are, firstly, is this just me?

 

It's not you, 1950s/60s cars were significantly smaller than modern ones. A modern Ford Fiesta is a foot longer and about 9" wider than a Morris Traveller. All those crumple zones, deformable plastic bumpers, side air bags and impact protection thingies take up space. 

 

Edited by Wheatley
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • RMweb Premium

Compare a modern Mini with the original BMC model or today's Fiat 500 with the original.  Soon after I bought my Series 3 Focus I came back to it one day to find a Series 1 Focus next to it and a current Fiesta next to that - the Fiesta was larger than the original Focus!

Link to post
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, Tony Wright said:

 

 

Good afternoon Pete,

 

I had the privilege of photographing York for BRM yesterday......

 

576589245_York11.thumb.jpg.b8e61532998d5cd22cc69fdf2e7f3e86.jpg

 

1147465304_York12.thumb.jpg.78acabdfda9c92c292a295130cf6ea94.jpg

 

887518146_York21.thumb.jpg.67a925e5578ddf34cd35e821827cf4c4.jpg

816365109_York25.thumb.jpg.6984d7893c48abe6e7f576252326370b.jpg

 

My compliments on your quite-stunning modelling.

 

Regards,

 

Tony. 

 

 

Envy runs very deep sometimes. Fantastic modelling

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...