I'm not 'simply shooting from the hip' - please read my posts above. You also say you haven't seen the model yet - I have the benefit when I comment, of having an actual production model in front of me as I type...
I'm old as well Paul. The standard of build and finish on recent models is incredible. The Bachmann Polybulk quality of finish and printing is breathtaking as are Heljan Cargowaggons, Dapol Silver Bullets and many, many others. They probably all have little faults and you either live with them or vote with your wallet. I could never build or finish anything remotely to the standard of current 4mm RTR stock and that's why I bought the Kernow PBA - it's a model I've been waiting for for a long time and I was glad when DJM took over the job from Dapol. I like Daves approach to model development and how he listens to the response from potential customers. I think that's why I was slightly disapointed when I received the model in the post. Maybe I was expecting too much.
My original post #60 was purely to give my own opinion on a model in response to other modellers request's for views on the Kernow PBA wagon. I've commented positively on several aspects of the model as well as having some reservations. I've qualified all my comments with the proviso 'to my eyes' and 'it appears to me' - ie: it's my opinion and I could well be wrong.
However, I feel to be criticised for simply expressing an opinion on a forum, isn't a good thing.