Jump to content
 

GWR 1-plank (part 2)


magmouse

796 views

So this is where I left it last time - the basics of the underframe, running gear and body complete, but a lot of detail to go:

 

pic00.jpeg.e54af1ae7e703d4e15205bf843ab3b71.jpeg

 

Detailing on the sides and solebars came mainly from Ambis etches. The document box is an ABS casting, and the horse hook is a piece of wire for the loop, and plasticard for the base.

 

pic01.jpeg.27d6d739724b3ea29e7e050e2918bf8f.jpeg

 

The bolt ends on the underframe are from plastic rod as before, including the strap bolts that pass through the headstock. I am not aware of a photo that shows the interior details clearly, so the only thing I have added is the side knees. There is a photo that gives a glimpse of the interior of what may be a GWR 1-plank open here, which gives a sense of the thickness of the knees:

 

https://lnwrs.zenfolio.com/p864799494

 

 

pic02.jpeg.f90eee2422c7aa3389be47aeec71bcca.jpeg

 

There are also two L-brackets each side, attached to the solebar and supporting the curb rail, which I made from an etched part for the vertical, and a piece of plasticard for the horizontal. I also attached the springs, and made the spring stop blocks from plasticard.

 

pic03.jpeg.442f69f407a544c1d4f4cabc3d508237.jpeg

 

You can also see in this picture I have drilled out small holes where the rings go to tie the sheet ties to, on the solebar and end rail. I didn't add the rings at this stage, and I still haven't - I am planning to make a 'lift van' (container) as a load, and until I have worked out the roping arrangements I won't know if I need the rings to hang down or be pulled upwards under load.

 

I added the cap strips to the top of the sides and ends, with a strip of 10 thou plasticard. I cut my own strip for this rather than using ready-made, as the cap strips are just slightly narrower than the plank beneath it, and need to be just the right width to get the right effect. I only realise now I am writing up the build that I didn't add the domed bolt heads that hold the cap strips on as well as bolting the planks to the curb rails. Oh, well...

 

pic04.jpeg.d5d26967fabae77edbc32a018aa2523c.jpeg

 

The two best pictures I have of these longer 1-plank wagons both show the unbraked side, unfortunately. It is possible to make out that they have a single wooden brake shoe, but no detail - in fact, I couldn't find any really clear picture of GWR single shoe brakes. There is a picture in Russell's GWR Wagon Appendix of a dumb buffered three plank wagon, where it is possible to see the brake gear, partly in silhouette, and I decided to follow that. I suspect the type I have modelled, with its push-rod mechanism, is more complex than most one-shoe brakes, where the lever is attached directly to the arm that suspends the brake block. So, it is probably a slightly whimsical choice, but I fancied it, and in the absence of more concrete information, I decided to go for it.

 

The push rod with its adjuster and the associated lever was made from wire and some spare etched parts. The adjusters, with all the holes, comes from the push rods of ordinary wagon brake gear, and I kept one side over-long while soldering it all together, so there was something to hold onto. The spare material was filed back later.

 

pic05.jpeg.8933e8e6d7838da417ef123eff5ffa5f.jpeg

 

And here it is with the brake lever added and the whole thing cleaned up:

 

pic06.jpeg.182c9e0caff8b81b23de1c9d56e48df6.jpeg

 

Here is the brake lever guard - this early type has a pin-and-hole locking mechanism, rather than the familiar ratchet. One the left is the strip that runs down the back of the brake shoe, with the attachment point for the push rod - again made from an odd bit of a brake gear etch.

 

pic07.jpeg.a9f0be5d0c1c66929eb94f6204d0fe12.jpeg

 

I made the brake shoe from plasticard, starting by scribing the curve to the right radius with a pair of dividers, and then cutting the other sides in relation to it.

 

pic08.jpeg.8a266863d20b1219f827596aca8cc015.jpeg

 

And here is the brake mechanism assembled. I kept this, the lever with its cross-shaft and the lever guard as separate parts, only assembling it all after painting, right at the end of the process. This helps avoid damaging these delicate components.

 

pic09.jpeg.e2f9a33f982c455deedd7c603f466ad1.jpeg

 

The buffers are 3D prints kindly made for me by Duncan @drduncan, adapted from his 4mm scale versions. We spent some time looking at photos, discovering there are at least two different types with subtly different details such as the thickness of the ribs and the root radius where the guide meets the base. We also noticed that the packing that sits between the cast buffer guide and the headstock again varies, so we decided not to include it as part of the 3D print.

 

The prints were designed to work with Peco GWR buffer heads and springing mechanism. I discovered I had drilled out the holes in the headstocks too large for the spigots on the buffer prints, as the prints hadn't been finished at that time. The length of the spigot is critical, as it determines how far the buffer heads protrude when held in position by the spring wire behind the headstock, and so the effective buffer length. I therefore made new spigots from plastic tube, to go over the printed ones.

 

Here we see the packing pieces (spare components from Slaters MR buffers), the plastic tube, the printed buffer guides, and an assembled buffer:

 

pic10.jpeg.631719996ae7b5e052765e2fe17b06b3.jpeg

 

And fitted:

 

pic11.jpeg.90213103c6c47ba901e03a60fc6e442f.jpeg

 

This next picture summarises the state of play, with springs and buffers in place, and the locating pieces for the wheel and axleguard assemblies. Also in this picture you can see the whitemetal part that holds the brake lever and its cross shaft - borrowed from an ABS set of LNWR single-shoe brake lever components.

 

pic12.jpeg.c7ef3442eb4b8660c34b021d023ce182.jpeg

 

Now on its wheels, physically complete apart from the brake gear and couplings:

 

pic13.jpeg.52a8014fd4a879f69fd4ab45218ec068.jpeg

 

Painting started with a coat of grey primer, and continued with painting the interior with a bare wood effect (I'm planning a separate post on my method for that at some point). I find it preferable to do the interior first, as it is easier to deal with any over-spill from this slightly messy process before doing the body colour.

 

pic14.jpeg.03d2ede7b432d88d3f18852624c6d419.jpeg

 

The body colour was my usual mix of black and white Vallejo acrylics, brush painted. The lettering made use of Railtec's excellent bespoke service, as the G and W need to fit the side exactly, and are therefore a non-standard size.

 

Underneath, the brake gear was added, though I still haven't glued it in place as the brake lever covers where one of the sheet tie rings needs to go, so I need to finalise the load and roping first. I glued the wheel assemblies lightly with a couple of dabs of glue, in case I want to remove them in the future. By this point, I had decided to change to S7 standards, so a set of Slaters S7 wheels replaced the original ones:

 

pic15.jpeg.6d5d5806abe6b02c4c50bbadd63ecc8a.jpeg

 

I applied some light weathering with grey powders (mixed from black and white to get a bit of variation) and did some final paint touch-ups - and done!

 

pic16.jpg.ea1da566c09ea2f207858787f1477001.jpg

 

pic17.jpg.4de6a7f4fc566146dcb56856c5d3837a.jpg

 

pic18.jpg.1f8c0718568130f1b24da4e2fe373789.jpg

 

pic19.jpg.e07e4985c3b66526696a0312de9c9640.jpg

 

Nick.

  • Like 5
  • Craftsmanship/clever 18
  • Round of applause 3

13 Comments


Recommended Comments

  • RMweb Premium

That brake push-rod is a thing of delicate wonder.

 

On width: you've forced me to look again at the two photos in GWR Goods Wagons (3rd edition) p. 270 and see the brackets supporting the curb rail...

  • Like 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
2 minutes ago, Compound2632 said:

That brake push-rod is a thing of delicate wonder.

 

You can see why I had to model it, whether it's correct or not - a mid-Victorian delight!

 

3 minutes ago, Compound2632 said:

On width: you've forced me to look again at the two photos in GWR Goods Wagons (3rd edition) p. 270 and see the brackets supporting the curb rail...

 

So there's a question: how much overhang before brackets get used? When there is a packing piece between the curb rail and the solebar? When there is no packing piece but the curb rail is greater than a certain amount? No packing piece, but also no notch in the curb rail for the corner of the solebar to fit into?

 

That's a 3-volume book right there...

 

Nick.

  • Like 4
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
3 minutes ago, magmouse said:

So there's a question: how much overhang before brackets get used? When there is a packing piece between the curb rail and the solebar? When there is no packing piece but the curb rail is greater than a certain amount? No packing piece, but also no notch in the curb rail for the corner of the solebar to fit into?

 

When the overweight foreman sits on the curb rail and the deflection is greater than ³⁄₁₆".

Edited by Compound2632
  • Funny 4
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

A cracking build magmouse. Well worth the extra effort on the brakes and compensation. 

 

I also use a transverse buffer spring, not quite as elegant as that, but I find its less prone to jamming than coil springs in the buffer casing for wagons. 

  • Agree 2
  • Thanks 1
  • Informative/Useful 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
3 minutes ago, Dave John said:

A cracking build magmouse. Well worth the extra effort on the brakes and compensation. 

 

I also use a transverse buffer spring, not quite as elegant as that, but I find its less prone to jamming than coil springs in the buffer casing for wagons. 

 

Thanks, Dave. The buffer spring mechanism is the standard Peco components - all except the buffer housing itself. It's a good way to do it, as you say - another advantage is you don't have to worry about drilling two different diameter holes to the right depth as you do with internal springs.

 

Nick.

Edited by magmouse
  • Like 2
Link to comment

 

"...and done!" ['quote selection' not selecting again]

....yes, and very well done.

 

[but works for the comments...odd]

9 minutes ago, Compound2632 said:

how much overhang before brackets get used?

There may be an answer in that some versions (e.g GWR Siphons, straight sided horseboxes) have a cast or forged triangular bracket taking the load from the side of the van when all or most of the side overhangs the sole bar.  I suspect the simple L bracket on the one plank wagons and other similar types hold the kerb rail in (lateral deflection), not up: otherwise, if there was any significant load on it, it would bend.

 

  • Thanks 1
  • Interesting/Thought-provoking 1
Link to comment

As ever a beautiful model even if the arguments around details of the original wagons abound....

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
8 hours ago, Chrisbr said:

arguments around details of the original wagons abound....

 

Discussions. I was hoping for your further comments on register dimensions in the light of my comment on Part 1...

Link to comment
13 minutes ago, Compound2632 said:

Discussions. I was hoping for your further comments on register dimensions in the light of my comment on Part 1...

friendly probing debate 😀

 

Sadly, I don't have copies of any of the stock books referenced yet so was not able to add anything useful, I do have an old narrow gauge stock list (pre the standard books) but that doesn't contain any dimensional data, so no value to the present debate

  • Thanks 2
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

Another top quality model again. But I am intrigued to know how you get the wheels in after you have soldered the W-irons onto the printed circuit board. 

Mike

  • Like 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
22 minutes ago, airnimal said:

But I am intrigued to know how you get the wheels in after you have soldered the W-irons onto the printed circuit board.

 

They first time, with finescale wheels, the W irons were soldered on with the wheels in situ. I used electrical cored solder so there wouldn't be acid flux fumes potentially causing rust on the steel wheels.

 

The second time, with the S7 wheels, I just bent the brass w-irons out and back again. A rather crude approach, and not one I would recommend on a regular basis, but it did the job.

 

Nick.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
  • Interesting/Thought-provoking 1
Link to comment

I lovely wagon build, I particularly like the printed buffer, and the brake gear is exquisite, but the wagon is the wrong colour, it's not red LOL.

  • Funny 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
3 hours ago, stevel said:

I particularly like the printed buffer

 

Yes - big thanks to Duncan @drduncan for those lovely items.

 

3 hours ago, stevel said:

but the wagon is the wrong colour, it's not red LOL.

 

Don't worry - more red wagons coming soon!

  • Like 3
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...