Jump to content
 

GWR 4-plank with sheet supporter and sheet


magmouse

919 views

What's that you say? Another GWR 4-planker? Haven't you had enough of those? Well, if you're sure...

 

pic00.jpg.bc335330514f83d26e35d97566d53ea9.jpg

 

This is 41211, freshly turned out in 1908 style: grey paint with 25" lettering, axleboxes upgraded to oil types, and a sheet supporter fitted. All the latest features of a truly modern merchandise wagon of the new century, in fact - Swindon has played its A-game. Not so, unfortunately, the folks who have loaded it. The rather filthy sheet has been put on crooked, obscuring the wagon number, and it hasn't been tightened properly, so risking the formation of puddles, should it rain.

 

pic01.jpg.f695d4ba69ba9c74f1ea62f6d4530381.jpg

 

A look round the other side offers a clue. The straw sticking out of the door suggests it was shut rather hastily - perhaps there is some kind of crated livestock inside, or some other troublesome load? We will probably never know...

 

––o0o––

 

The construction of this wagon follows similar methods to those I have shown in previous blog entries, so in part this post is a recap, with one or two new features, and some photos of stages of the process not shown in the earlier posts.

 

The starting point of course was the Peco (ex Webster) kit - in this case, one picked up second-hand as a 'fixer-upper' - already built but not painted, and with broken brake gear. I began by removing the remains of the old brake gear, and giving the wagon a good clean. The new brake gear was made up using a spare moulding from a Slaters (ex Coopercraft) kit - one of the benefits of modelling the first decade of the 20th century is most wagons had only single-sided brakes, so there are often left-over parts from kits that provide for either-sided brakes.

 

The vee-hanger was an etched brass component, and the cross shaft follows my now standard method, with an thin inner wire and sections of brass tube to make up the full diameter. This way, the holes in the various components only need to be the size of the wire, not the entire shaft.

 

pic02.jpeg.6477150f6347e2eb339fe460ca718025.jpeg

 

I didn't fit the brake lever and guard at this stage, as they are prone to damage during the rest of the construction. Next was the sheet supporter, following the methods used for the empty 4-plank and sheeted 5-plank wagons already described:

 

 

The supporter was made in two halves, from 1.6mm brass wire. The ends were filed down to take a strip of nickel silver, to form the flat section:

 

pic03.jpeg.3e040beba18079119c501065b43f28b9.jpeg

 

Pins were soldered in, to fit into holes in the wagon ends to hold everything in position. It's perhaps worth noting that the pivot mechanism on this wagon is fixed to the bottom plank, unlike the previous 4-plank wagon, which had it fitted to the second plank up. This means the verticals of the supporter need to be a different length - the rail should land exactly on top of the sides when tilted over. One motivation for this difference was to get as much variety in the height of the bar between this and other wagons with sheeted rails - both the 5-planker already built, and others planned.

 

The supporter bar was assembled with additional strengtheners in the centre:

 

pic04.jpeg.829f8b24373a54c9f0660c18a68f9a6f.jpeg

 

The mounting points for the rail were made from plasticard and glued to the wagon ends:

 

pic05.jpeg.db36f4ae121308e6e6d5d27111821fdb.jpeg

 

The rail was mounted in position, with the inner vertical supports held in plasticard blocks glued to the wagon floor. It is important the rail is firmly fixed, as it gets a lot of handling during the fitting of the sheet.

 

pic06.jpeg.693beaa77b81951b79b37248ae84b73d.jpeg

 

You can also see in this picture the formers, which help the sheet form the shape I wanted. These were made from 20 thou plasticard, and I made a paper template for the curves to ensure they were the same on both sides. The formers in the centre of the wagon have a dip in them, to get the sense the sheet is fairly slack, and hanging under its own weight.

 

I'd learned my lesson with the semicircular guides, this time making them from T-section instead of L-section. This ensures the material doesn't try to twist as it is bent round a former (in this case the handle of a tool, which happened to be the right size). Once bent to shape, one side of the tee was filed off, leaving the required L-section.

 

pic07.jpeg.af18bf716285778aed757f9aceb24319.jpeg

 

The guides are attached to the wagon by spacer blocks - wood on the prototype, and plastic section on the model. Brass wire pins add strength, and I drilled the holes for these in the guides first. The guide was then held in position and used as a template to mark and drill through the blocks, so small errors in the positioning of the holes in the guides didn't matter.

 

pic08.jpeg.a089cc4bf3d137513ff7d92febda6e1f.jpeg

 

pic09.jpeg.1260121be4408e6cbfc1e93231bcd103.jpeg

 

Once the wire pins were in position, the joints were flooded with thin CA glue. The pins were cut off and filed down, leaving a small amount protruding to represent the fixing bolts on the prototype.

 

The trapezoidal-shaped plate and the latch pin at the top of the semicircular guides were made from plastic sheet and rod. I didn't bother with the detail on the plates on this build, as they are almost completely hidden by the sheet.

 

The tying-off hooks on the ends and curb rails were added as before, made of soft iron wire.

 

pic10.jpeg.f5808ef96e8b23a4c2b5267f72a1274e.jpeg

 

The brake handle and guard were from Ambis etched parts, and safety loops and door springs from nickel silver strip:

 

pic11.jpeg.21a74b477e9f07918fa02f88074f7d13.jpeg

 

For the straw coming out of the door, I prised open the door that had been glued shut by the previous owner. Before I could add the plumber's hemp, I needed to paint the wagon, which I did with a grey mixed from Vallejo black and white acrylics, over an undercoat of matt black aerosol spray.

 

Lettering was from the waterslide transfers supplied with the Slaters GWR wagons, which I prefer to the Peco ones. 4-plank wagons aren't high enough for full-size 25" GW letters, so I used the 16" version intended for the later livery. These are a bit too small - they should reach almost to the top of the sides - but given they are almost completely hidden by the sheet, I didn't worry. The whole lot was given a coat of Vallejo matt varnish, which actually gives a nice sheen suitable for a newly painted wagon.

 

pic12.jpeg.a5e8760310457181e57f3a4ad60d5073.jpeg

 

To hold the straw in position before the door was shut, I added a small piece of plasticard inside the wagon, at right-angles to the side and just inside the door opening. Lengths of plumber's hemp was glued to this and the wagon floor before the door was shut and glued in place. Finally the straw could be trimmed to length.

 

pic13.jpeg.52c360bf354ca696c4396c601a1130ba.jpeg

 

The sheet was made as before, using Ian Smith's artwork printed onto 60gsm paper with a laser printer:

 

pic14.jpeg.9d8d539e0ac8263a0249be039c3b788c.jpeg

 

The back was covered with aluminium tape:

 

pic15.jpeg.aa8a2bffb2cb65a93f10a366db6d2c47.jpeg

 

The artwork was printed with a lower contrast, rather than a full black and white, to give a head-start to the dirt effect. Weathering powders were the next layer, applied with a wet brush before the sheet was cut out and fitted.

 

pic16.jpeg.9d01b88cf35cfa15074ae3dff75b0715.jpeg

 

Fitting was as before, starting at the ridge, using thick CA glue applied with a cocktail stick. The sheet was deliberately attached slightly of centre, and not quite square to the wagon, to give an asymmetric effect. I worked down each of the curved formers, gluing as I went and ensuring the sheet followed the curve to give the sagging look I wanted. The end folds were formed last.

 

Once the EZ line ties were attached, the sheet was touched up (the laser printing tends to flake a little at the folds or with handling). Final weathering was applied with powders and paint washes, until the writing was just barely visible, as often seen in photos. I applied minimal weathering to the wagon itself, as I wanted the contrast between newly outshopped wagon and grubby sheet.

 

The 4-plank open was the mainstay of the GWR wagon fleet in the late 19th and early 20th century, and most loads required sheeting to protect them from rain, soot and the risk of fire from cinders. This build, then, is about as typical as you can get for my 1908 period. The straw poking out from the door (based on a prototype photo) adds a little intrigue to this otherwise commonplace wagon.

 

pic17.jpg.4eb80ee255a25cbb35ca63a9db17a315.jpg

 

pic18.jpg.a798e1809cdbe2513cb6448ecfbdb202.jpg

 

pic19.jpg.2114ad3cbbf8c4372ca0300e491711b4.jpg

 

Nick.

  • Like 2
  • Craftsmanship/clever 15
  • Round of applause 4

19 Comments


Recommended Comments

The photo at the top of the page is one of those cases where the sheet looked so lifelike at first glance I didn't immediately realise it was picture of a model.

I bet it's stunning in real life if it's that good in a photo!

  • Agree 2
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
29 minutes ago, StuartMc said:

The photo at the top of the page is one of those cases where the sheet looked so lifelike at first glance I didn't immediately realise it was picture of a model.

I bet it's stunning in real life if it's that good in a photo!

 

Thank you, Stuart! It's not really for me to say if it is 'stunning' or not, but I am quite pleased with this one, even if there are bits of the sheet that I look at from a certain angle and think, "oh, and now it looks like slightly crumpled paper..."

 

Nick.

Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

Very well done. The sheet support is great, adds a lot of character. 

 

Having the tiedowns coming from eyelets like that makes a big difference, something I will have to try. 

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
1 minute ago, Dave John said:

Very well done. The sheet support is great, adds a lot of character. 

 

Having the tiedowns coming from eyelets like that makes a big difference, something I will have to try. 

 

Thanks, Dave. The eyelets are quite easy to do - just poke a hole in the sheet with a sharp implement, and feed the tie through from behind. It means you can glue to tie to the back of the sheet without worrying about being too neat or having to do sub-miniature knots. I touch in a dab of gunmetal pint to give a hint of the eyelet, though it looks a touch crude at this magnification. You have to do something in any case, as the white paper fibres, or a bit of the foil, always end out showing through where you make the hole.

 

Nick.

  • Like 2
  • Informative/Useful 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

That's a seriously nice piece of model making Nick.  The scruffy poorly fitted wagon sheet and the packing straw caught in the side door lifts that 4 planker to a whole different class of well observed realism.

  • Agree 4
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
1 hour ago, Annie said:

That's a seriously nice piece of model making Nick.  The scruffy poorly fitted wagon sheet and the packing straw caught in the side door lifts that 4 planker to a whole different class of well observed realism.


Thanks, Annie! Since I need to do quite a few of these 4-plankers, it makes things more interesting to find differences and back-stories for them.

 

Nick.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

I agree, your wagons just get better and better Nick. I like the aluminium tape idea, must try that out and see if it works in 4mm.

 

The straw sticking out is a nice little detail. I've been wondering what might be in there which needs packing with straw. It could be a couple of Platypus, as the March 1908 instructions (page 26, bottom right) says to pack these in ample straw - but would small livestock not have been carried in a van?

 

Perhaps it's a shipment of... now what's the right word: Those big glass flasks packed in crates with straw?

 

Edited by Mikkel
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
40 minutes ago, Mikkel said:

I agree, your wagons just get better and better Nick. I like the aluminium tape idea, must try that out and see if it works in 4mm.

 

The straw sticking out is a nice little detail. I've been wondering what might be in there which needs packing with straw. It could be a couple of Platypus, as the March 1908 instructions (page 26, bottom right) says to pack these in ample straw - but would small livestock not have been carried in a van?

 

Perhaps it's a shipment of... now what's the right word: Those big glass flasks packed in crates with straw?

 

 

Thanks, Mikkel. The straw sticking out comes from a picture in Atkins, ‘GWR Goods Services’ part 2B, p.299, where it can be seen on a wagon in the bottom left corner. My thought of livestock in this truck may well be a bit fanciful - as you say, a van is more likely. Regarding the glass flasks, I think the word you were thing of is 'carboys' - used for acids and similar hazardous fluids. As I am sure you know, there is a great picture of these in Jim Russell's GWR Freight Wagons and Loads, showing a GW 3-planker full of carboys packed in straw.

 

Nick.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
53 minutes ago, Mikkel said:

Perhaps it's a shipment of... now what's the right word: Those big glass flasks packed in crates with straw?

Carboy?

 

A5carboy.jpg

  • Agree 2
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment

 "The straw poking out from the door (based on a prototype photo) adds a little intrigue to this otherwise commonplace wagon." ["quote selection" doesn't seem to working this morning so copied and pasted].

 

...it does, and yes, carboys might just be the concealed load (platypus? I think our leg's being pulled but I don't have the 1908 instructions to hand). And there is much to be said for the "commonplace", particularly when so well done.

Edited by kitpw
  • Like 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
28 minutes ago, kitpw said:

I think our leg's being pulled

 

Well, if special provisions were made for the carriage of elephants...

 

28 minutes ago, kitpw said:

And there is much to be said for the "commonplace"

 

Indeed - I am mostly managing to resist the temptation of the unusual, in terms of wagons and loads, though I have rather too many non-GWR trucks on my list for my pre-common user period. The thing will be to not run them all at once.

 

Nick.

  • Like 2
Link to comment

Platypi?

 

Pity the poor porter who had to unload them - at least only the males are poisonous...

  • Like 2
  • Funny 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Gold

Yes, I confess I was pulling your leg - even the GWR did not have special instructions for this species 🙂. Platypus would have been a good telegraphic code though!

 

Thanks for helping me with the carboys. I had a vague idea it was carbuncles, but Webster's dictionary did not agree!  

  • Like 1
  • Funny 2
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
35 minutes ago, Mikkel said:

I had a vague idea it was carbuncles

 

Well, they would make an interesting load too - stacked parts for modernist additions to 19th century art galleries (cf Prince - now King - Charles and the National Gallery extension).

  • Round of applause 1
  • Funny 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium

I'm having the greatest difficulty reconciling myself to this newfangled grey livery for Great Western wagons - it just doesn't look right.

  • Like 1
  • Agree 2
  • Friendly/supportive 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
1 hour ago, Compound2632 said:

I'm having the greatest difficulty reconciling myself to this newfangled grey livery for Great Western wagons - it just doesn't look right.


Get yourself some orthochromatic glasses, then you won’t notice the difference. Or just rose-tinted ones.

  • Funny 2
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
3 hours ago, Compound2632 said:

I'm having the greatest difficulty reconciling myself to this newfangled grey livery for Great Western wagons - it just doesn't look right.

Me too.  

  • Like 1
  • Agree 1
  • Friendly/supportive 1
Link to comment

Nik,

 

Another fantastic, well observed build, bring the ordinary to life

 

Can't wait for the next installments

 

Chris

 

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
  • RMweb Premium
20 minutes ago, Chrisbr said:

Nik,

 

Another fantastic, well observed build, bring the ordinary to life

 

Can't wait for the next installments

 

Chris

 

 

Thanks Chris - the pace will be slowing down soon, as I have almost caught up with the wagons already built before I started posting here, and I certainly don't build a wagon a week! I also want to post some thoughts about the eventual layout depicting Netherport, but hopefully I will be able to keep whetting the appetites of all the wagonistas out there. Getting feedback, and above all the interesting comments and exchanges of ideas has been great, and I am very grateful to everyone who has taken the time to read and respond to my posts.

 

Nick.

  • Like 3
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...